Posted on 11/20/2026 7:19:12 PM PST by SunkenCiv
Planetary Defenders: This Is Not an Exercise tells the story of how NASA, its international partners, the astronomy community, and scientists around the world raced to observe and track the asteroid, understand its orbit into the future, calculate its impact probabilities, and eventually retire it from the risk list.
NASA experts provide an inside look at the complex process of tracking 2024 YR4, a newly discovered near-Earth object. This documentary follows the international collaboration between astronomers and planetary defense offices as they analyze data to assess the asteroid's potential threat and coordinate official notifications.Planetary Defenders: This Is Not an Exercise | 20:14
NASA | 15.1M subscribers | 701,217 views | October 14, 2026
(Excerpt) Read more at youtube.com ...
Dear FRiends,
We need your continuing support to keep FR funded. Your donations are our sole source of funding. No sugar daddies, no advertisers, no paid memberships, no commercial sales, no gimmicks, no tax subsidies. No spam, no pop-ups, no ad trackers.
If you enjoy using FR and agree it's a worthwhile endeavor, please consider making a contribution today:
Click here: to donate by Credit Card
Or here: to donate by PayPal
Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794
Thank you very much and God bless you,
Jim
The YouTube transcript was processed with my fine country craftsmanship, and *may* follow.
Transcript
Chapter 1: The asteroid threat
NASA+ NASA has been tracking a potentially hazardous asteroid. There is now a chance of a city-destroying asteroid. It’s called 2024 YR4. Asteroid 2024 YR4. 2024 YR4. With a potential impact in 2032. Scientists have labeled it a city killer, which sounds dangerous at first glance. But what are the actual odds this space rock reaches us? And what can we do if the chances continue to increase? A NASA+ Original Documentary. From the Planetary Defense Coordination Office. Planetary Defenders. This Is Not an Exercise.
Chapter 2: Discovery and assessment
2024 YR visited the Earth at 2.2 lunar distances on 25 December, so Christmas. It was not discovered, however, until the 27th. The night that 2024 YR4 came out of the Chile telescope, I was the person on call in Hawaii looking at the data and it was a completely routine night. It was before I go to bed, checking on the data from those telescopes, and just saw another near-Earth object candidate, and then submitted the observations to the Minor Planet Center and went to bed. At first, we didn’t know it was very significant. It was one of several discoveries.
The ATLAS survey, operated by the University of Hawaii, finds about 200 to 250 near-Earth objects per year. This object was sort of a garden variety new NEO. There was nothing about it when we first saw it that suggested that it would be especially dangerous. The impact probability climbed. It started to increase with more data. That’s when things really kind of heated up for us. On December 22nd, 2032, there was a chance that it could impact Earth. From the measurements taken from the ground, 2024 YR4 was estimated to be about 40 to 90 meters in size.
You’re talking about an object that could be a city killer. It was a large enough size to be dangerous, possibly the size of a jumbo jet. Well, if you remember the Chelyabinsk impact of 2013 over Russia, that was estimated to be about a 20 meter asteroid. Produced a 0.5 megaton amount of energy when it blew up in the sky, and it damaged 7,000 plus buildings and over 1,000 reports of injuries. So you go from a 20 meter object to a 60 meter object. The bigger the object, the bigger the punch.
So we knew we only had a few months where 2024 YR4 was going to be observable, and then it wouldn’t be observable until June of 2028. That’s why it was so critical to try to retire the risk before the object grew too faint to see it. When the probability at the beginning was was still pretty small, one thing I noticed is that the Earth was dead on center within the uncertainty distribution.
Chapter 3: Orbit and trajectory analysis
At that point, I realized that it was a good chance that the probability would go up significantly before dropping. At that point, I sent a message to Kelly and told her, look, this asteroid 2024 YR4 might get interesting. Little did I know it would get this interesting. So, and you can see, I don’t know if you saw this plot. The evolution of the probability. Yeah, that’s a nice plot. It’s kind of interesting because as new data start coming in, the probability starts working its way up.
I was in charge of doing the orbit determination and impact hazard assessment for 2024 YR4. Right, this is an animation showing the initial detections of 2024 YR4 as observed by ATLAS. This is not what we work with. What happens is that this information from the images gets converted to a bunch of numbers. This is what we receive. You have a number of observations. And for each observation we know what time it was observed and the coordinates in the sky. And this is the precious information that we use to figure out what the trajectory of the asteroid is.
But that orbit comes with some uncertainty. And so you have a swarm of possible orbits that are compatible with the data. And then you take an observation. The orbits that are no longer compatible with the new data can now be ruled out. And so the set of possible orbits gets smaller every time you collect additional data. And within a second you quickly get to an estimated orbit solution. You get the list of close approaches. We can visualize that. This is an animation of the orbit of 2024 YR4 over time.
Next, 2028, we make a close approach to the Earth, but not so close to represent a potential impact hazard. But if we wait until 2032, here’s what happens. You can see it’s going in and about to come close to the Earth, and that’s where the possible impact was. I try not to think too much about how significant planetary defense can be to people. I know how to compute asteroid trajectories. It’s a mathematical problem. I’m a mathematician. I just enjoy crunching numbers and predicting where where asteroids are going to be in the future.
Chapter 4: Official notifications
27 January. That was when we hit the 1% mark. So over the course of January as the impact probability of 2024 YR4 continued to rise, we were all very conscious of this 1% threshold that is an agreed threshold both within the U.S. and internationally, or three on the Torino Scale, which is a way of assigning ratings to what level of concern an asteroid might pose. Once you reach impact probabilities of 1% or more, that’s kind of a clear mark. Once you get to that point, things become real. So I was in an airport on layover at the time, and I found a table to sit at with some gentleman who had no idea what was happening.
And I got on the meeting between the NASA personnel and the Planetary Defense Coordination Office, the JPL Center for Near Object Studies, and ESA’s NEO Coordination Center, and our Italian colleagues at NeoDyS. And we all watched together as our respective public databases changed to 1% or three on the Torino Scale. And I remember people saying, “Oh, haven’t seen that before.” Meaning like the colors that were displayed on the websites and the numbers that we were seeing. We’ve now hit 1% with an object that’s 50 meters or more that could be a city killer if it actually struck the Earth and actually hit a populated area.
I was responsible for notifying both within NASA and to other U.S. government agencies, that there was this potential for a future impact that had reached that 1% threshold. Also, in the International Asteroid Warning Network, which is organized by NASA, I had the responsibility of giving a similar notification both to the Space Missions Planning Advisory Group, which looks at mission options in the event of an identified potential impact threat. And I also sent that notification to the UN Office of Outer Space Affairs because they are responsible for disseminating that information to UN member states.
Chapter 5: Global tracking efforts
This was the first time we had an asteroid of such significance since the asteroid Apophis was discovered in 2004, and back then, there weren’t the processes for doing official notification through the U.S. government or internationally. This was the first time that we were exercising all of those processes for real. Okay...so 535,000. We definitely wanted to get more data to improve our knowledge of the possible position of this object in 2032 when the possible impact could happen. So over the next few weeks after that, after reaching 1% and three on the Torino Scale, the planetary defense community continued doing what they do because they do this all the time. They continued observing the asteroid and all the other asteroids they observed.
We had more than 60 different telescopes tracking this object and collecting data. Observatories in Australia, Chile, Japan. Of course Arizona, California, New Mexico. It was an international collaboration. As astronomers continued to track this asteroid, the impact probability continued to rise. We always knew that the object would be observable from the ground until the end of March, and then that is all we would know until June of 2028, when it would be observable again.
You’re looking out 500,000 miles into space, and you’re trying to see this little dark object. It got faint quickly. It was moving away from the Earth. So over time, there were fewer and fewer observatories that could be utilized to continue to track it. So there was a little concern. Hey, this thing is moving fast. It’s fading fast. What if we don’t get enough of the big telescopes to see it before it fades from view? It was actually pretty critical that the community get together and retire this risk before the first apparition ended.
Chapter 6: Follow-up observations
We have to be ready to work any clear night, 24/7, prepping for the evening and then working through the night. But when you have something that is a potential impactor and we have a whole team working on it, it can get really fun and dynamic. I’m Dr. Eileen Ryan, director of the Magdalena Ridge Observatory’s 2.4 meter telescope. Now, this telescope mirror has quite the legacy. It was one of two spares left over from the Hubble Space Telescope program. So it’s an exact replica of Hubble.
We actually built this facility in order to be able to use it. So we had a construction phase and a very small crew. There was only four of us working together: an engineer, a technician, and my husband and I to actually build the facility. My husband and I are the two senior astronomers that run this facility. I’m William Ryan and I’m a research faculty at New Mexico Tech at Magdalena Ridge Observatory, 2.4 meter. 2024 YR4 was a really interesting object. Bill and I were just looking at it, kind of keeping a watch on it.
We really didn’t have the need to get on sky at that particular time early in January, because it was very bright and we generally try to chip in and teamwork by going after the faint objects and have the smaller telescopes look at the brighter objects. But right about mid to late January it started to get fainter and fader. But also in mid-January, we were given the alert that it was particularly interesting because it had a 1% probability of potentially impacting the Earth in December of 2032. And so our job as a follow up telescope is to get more information to extend the arc of the orbit, where that object is in space and time.
And that’s what our job is for every new asteroid that’s discovered. But for YR4, it was very important because it was we have this increasing potential for impact. Okay, so here we’re actually looking at the first images that we took of YR4 when it was sort of handed off into our magnitude range. So we kind of overlapped with the meter class telescopes that they were starting to be pushing their limits. But for us we were looking at a very bright object.
This little scatter here is the scatter of the sky that’s around the target. And this is the signal from the asteroid itself poking through that noise. So it’s very convincing at this point, even in these single images. And so we were on sky looking at this object nearly every night. Okay. So so this image is looking really good. So the object is dead in the center pretty much. So it was pretty easy when we first got on it in January because it was 22nd visual magnitude. Each magnitude is two and a half times dimmer than the previous one.
We’re going to have to go pretty long exposure right now. But by the time we took our last data point on March 1st, it was 25.5 visual magnitude, which is a magnitude that we thought was outside our range. We were now pushing our limits as a as a 2.5 meter telescope. And then now YR4 looks like this little tiny dot here. And it was amazing that we were able to reduce our faintness limit by a magnitude. So in the end, it was actually quite thrilling to be working with telescopes like Lowell Observatory, having a four meter telescope, and then larger telescopes like Gemini, and then finally handing over the pass of this asteroid to the James Webb Space Telescope in the final days that it was visible from the Earth. So a thrill like that is hard to come by.
Chapter 7: Risk retirement
February 18th, there was a lot of suspense going on when we got up to 3%. There was, of course, a lot of scrutiny on any little change, any fraction of a percent change. The daily routine was I was waking up and even before getting breakfast, the first thing I would do is to check my email to see if there was new data coming in that I had to analyze. I just plugged in those data, updated the orbit solution, and tried to assess what the new impact probability was.
I would oftentimes reach out to observers and try to get confirmation that everything was in order, that the reported measurements were accurate enough for us to use in a reliable way. Getting it wrong was not an option. It was really a tight timeline. There was no break. And then when everything was good, reach out to Kelly, let her know what the situation was, and post the results on our website so that the entire world would know where we stand. Once it reached 2%, and then once it reached 3%, it was very sobering.
Although we also knew that any time we could find that that impact probability would start to drop if the uncertainty about where it could be in 2032 started to shrink off the Earth. And then over the coming days, it kind of leveled off and then it started to drop. Boom. The Earth is completely outside. The probability of impact is now essentially zero. It went away.
And as new data started coming in, you could see that the uncertainty was moving away. And, and so we were on the off ramp and going towards zero. And so that’s, that’s when we realized that this object was going to go away. And, and we could retire the possible risk of impact. There was some sense of relief when it fell off, because even though that was the expectation, you just didn’t know when that would happen. And, you know, dealing with, with, with YR4 on a daily basis for, for nearly two months, it was, was certainly a commitment. But that’s, that’s what, that’s part of our job. That’s what we are tasked to do. For us, it’s kind of the object, the sort of object we actually dream about, right?
Chapter 8: Planetary defense future
We don’t want one to hit the Earth and end civilization, but we do want to know that the thing we’re building is actually going to identify some objects that are hazardous and allow us to do something to mitigate a possible threat. You cannot do anything about a 100 meter asteroid that you don’t see coming. We can eliminate that risk. We just have to have the right technology, the right coordination, and we have to continue to evolve planetary defense. This is kind of like a dream come true to somehow contribute to science in this way.
It is really, really fulfilling to see how all of this work, all of the astronomy and all of the science feeds into something that could affect people’s everyday lives. But we’re not completely out of the woods yet. If there are really like a million of these objects out there that are 30 meters, 20 meters , 40 meters, there are a lot more of them out there. If we get to the next stage of evolution of planetary defense and the next stage in the coordination, I think we may see in the next 20 years, we may actually find the next Earth impactor.
The rest of the '2004 YR4' keyword, sorted:
City killer, eh? Can we pick the city?
East and west coast ore target rich
I apologize. I posted without realizing it was you. It was an accident.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.