India says it has found its Moon lander, but it still cannot communicate with it

www.theverge.com ^ | By Loren Grush@lorengrush Sep 9, 2019, 9:41am EDT

[Red Badger]

Can the little bot still function?

India claims to have spotted the country’s Vikram lunar lander on the surface of the Moon days after the spacecraft presumably crashed during a landing attempt. India still has not made contact with the lander, which went silent moments before its scheduled touchdown, but Indian officials are hopeful that the lander might still function.

“We are trying to establish contact,” Kailasavadivoo Sivan, the chairperson of the Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO) which oversees the lander, told Asian News International (ANI). “It will be communicated soon.”

The Vikram lander is a key part of India’s Chandrayaan-2 mission, which is aimed at studying the Moon’s south pole in greater detail. The lander, which was carrying a rover called Pragyan, was supposed to perform the first soft landing on the Moon for India by touching down in the south pole region. If it had been successful, India would have become the fourth nation in the world to put a vehicle intact on the lunar surface.

But Vikram’s landing did not go as planned last week. On the afternoon of Friday, September 6th, the lander was using its onboard engine to slowly lower itself down to the ground. When the spacecraft was just 1.3 miles (2.1 kilometers) above the surface, India suddenly lost communication with the vehicle. A graph of the spacecraft’s trajectory, shown during a live stream of the landing, revealed the lander to be slightly off its planned course just before touchdown.

Now, India at least knows where the Vikram lander is located. The lander traveled to the Moon with another spacecraft, an orbiter that is still circulating above the lunar surface. The orbiter successfully spotted the Vikram lander from above, taking a thermal image of the vehicle, according to ANI’s interview with Sivan.

Sivan did not clarify what state the spacecraft is in, claiming it was “premature to say anything.” In the meantime, there have been very few official updates from ISRO. After the landing, the organization posted a brief message to its website, highlighting the technical complexity of the Chandrayaan-2 mission and noting that the lander worked mostly as expected. “All the systems and sensors of the Lander functioned excellently until this point and proved many new technologies such as variable thrust propulsion technology used in the Lander,” ISRO wrote on its website.

The organization also noted that the lunar orbiter is still operating as planned and may even be operational for up to seven years around the Moon, instead of one year as planned. Overall, ISRO claims that between 90 to 95 percent of the Chandrayaan-2 mission has been accomplished, despite losing communication with Vikram and Pragyan.

[Brilliant]

Should not have used those Chinese parts.

[alancarp]

They’re still on hold with their call to the support number where an agent named ‘Ryan’ will soon be able to assist with anything they need.

[DannyTN]

Just like my last good date. Communicating fine afterwards and suddenly silence.

[humblegunner]

Now, India at least knows where the Vikram lander is located.

"By the many arms of Vishnu, I swear it is upon the moon!"

[2banana]

There is much irony in all this.

[21twelve]

Probably should have waited to talk about docking maneuvers and thrusters until the second date?

[Calvin Locke]

Their plan was for a soft landing.

[cuban leaf]

They landed too close to the Nazi base. This was expected.

[1Old Pro]

I heard it mistakenly landed on a Hollywood sound stage.

[Vaquero]

The moon belongs to the USA. 🇺🇸 we planted the flag 🇺🇸

[Buckeye McFrog]

Hello, and thank you for calling the India Moon Lander Communications Help Desk. My name is Larry, and I shall surely be endeavoring to do the needful for you, isn't it?"

[Army Air Corps]

I am waiting for the song and dance version of the report...

[Preachin']

Now they know how it feels.

[willyd]

Have they tried unplugging it and plugging it back in?

[Vaquero]

by grabthar’s hammer you shall be avenged

[seawolf101]

[DannyTN]

I did wait. I don’t think I even mentioned my robot designs.

She told me her last name (a polish name with 12 syllables and 3 times as many vowels). Then she said she didn’t lie cheat or steal.

I said, I’m not expected to say that am i?

Then I read the rest of what she said and realized I better clarify.

So I said, I’m not expected to say that name, am I?

Then I told her I didn’t lie cheat or steal either, but I wasn’t exclusive until we agreed to be exclusive. But I have a good feeling about you so just let me know when you’re ready.

Apparently she wasn’t ready.

At some point after that, I said I was trying to figure out how to land that fish. That might have done it.

As far as the Chinese, if they embedded a female AI in their lander, they may never hear from it again.

[red-dawg]

Is the ISRO located in Bangalore?

"It will be communicated soon."

"Thank you for calling ISRO, my name is Reechird, how may be of help to you?"

[ctdonath2]

I watched the live coverage.
Knew it was over when “LANDING DELAYED” appeared.
No failure ever acknowledged.

In comparison...
I watched live coverage of the Israeli landing.
Wasn’t long to admitting failure and intent to try again.

Culture matters.