The stories most of the women told were strikingly similar: They first crossed paths with the man on an online dating site. They agreed to meet him for drinks. Then, they said, things get foggy. They don't remember much, just glimpses, they said: pushing the man away as they lay naked in bed, waking up and feeling as if something very bad had happened. But did Jeffrey Marsalis, 33, drug the women and force them to have sex with him, as prosecutors implied, or, as his lawyers say, were the acts consensual? A jury may get to decide. Common Pleas...