The Ten Lost Tribes: The Case for Afghanistan, Kashmir, and Pakistan

What follows is initial evidence that links some people groups in Afghanistan, Kashmir, and Israel. It is thought provoking. HOWEVER, IN POSTING THIS, LET ME ENCOURAGE THE INTERESTED TO GO TO THE WEBSITE AND READ "OVERVIEW" IN WHICH THE CASE AGAINST THE TEN LOST TRIBES IS PRESENTED. Also, note that the "people of the book" as Mohammed called them (Christians or Jews), who converted to Islam, were considered by him to be totally Moslem and totally acceptable. The two sections below deal with Afghanistan and Kashmir.

The Bible mentions the city of Medes as one of the locations of the Assyrian exile of the Ten Tribes of Israel. Most explain and understand this area to be the region in Northwest Persia called Kurdistan. It is an accepted tradition that the people of this area are from the Assyrian exile.

When one considers the possibility of the people of this exile wandering north and east, then this would apply to the Tribes of Israel living in the Caucasian Mountains between the Caspian Sea and the Black Sea which includes the areas of Armenia, Georgia, Azerbaidzhan, and Daghistan (areas of Khazar in old days). An eastern expansion beyond the Caspian sea includes the areas Uzbekistan, Bukhara, and Turkemistan. From these areas it is very easy to move south to Afghanistan, India, Pakistan as well as to get to China.

If one travels from the area of Medes or Hamadan to farther east, crossing the Khayber Mountains or the Khayber Pass, he comes into the frontier of Afghanistan today. There I personally found an amazing sight. There are so many of a tribe with names that had Yusuf in the name as Yusufzai, Yusufuzi, Yusufzad, etc., who claimed origin from the Lost Tribes and I personally believe it.

Yusuf means Joseph and Yusufzai means children of Joseph. The tribes of Joseph are the tribes of Ephraim and Manasseh who are a part of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel. They also call themselves Bani-Israel meaning children of Israel. Their tradition is that they were carried away from their ancient homeland. Formerly they were shepherds in search of pasture but they gave up their nomadic life and settled into village communities.

Not only the Pathans, but also the Afghan Royal Family has a very well known tradition placing its origin in ancient Israel, they came from the Tribe of Benjamin.

This tradition was first published in 1635 in a book called Mahsan-I-Afghani and has often been mentioned in the research literature. According to this tradition, King Saul had a son called Jeremiah who had a son called Afghana. Jeremiah died at about the time of King Saul's death and Afghana was raised by King David and remained in the royal court during King Solomon's reign.

About 400 years later in the time of disorder of Israel, the Afghana family fled to a land called Gur which is in central Afghanistan. They settled and traded with the people of the area and in the year 662, with the arrival of Islam, the sons of Israel in Gur converted to the prophet with 7 representatives of the Afghan. The leader of the sons of Israel was Kish like the name of Saul's father.

According to this tradition Muhammed rewarded them and Kish's Hebrew name was changed to Arab-A-Rashid by Muhammad and was given the task of spreading Islam among his people. This is the roots of Afghan Royal Family.

So Afghan Royal Family has the tradition of ancient Israel - Benjamin Tribe of the Southern Kingdom of Judah.

Leaving Afghanistan and Pakistan where the Pathans live, when one goes east, it is the State of Kashmir in northern part of India which is west of Nepal. Kashmir consists of a very wide and beautiful valley, surrounded by tall mountains and I think it is one of the most beautiful places in the world.

There are 5 to 7 million people there. Generally speaking, they have clearer complexions and are different from the other citizens of India. An Interesting tradition is passed down among the Kashmir people regarding their ancestry from the Lost Tribes of Israel. This tradition is supported by extensive literature written by both the people of Kashmir and other scholars.

In Kashmir, various places are called with Israeli names, like Har Nevo, Beit Peor, Pisga, Heshubon. These are all the names in the land of the Ten Tribes of Israel. The same thing is true in the names of people, male names, female names, and names of village.

The people in Kashmir perform a feast called Pasca in Spring, when they adjust the difference of days between the lunar calendar and solar calendar and the way of this adjustment is the same as Jewish. Several books are published on this. The Udu language which is used in Kashmir includes many words of Hebrew.

Most of the people of Kashmir are Muslims. In spite of it, they are sympathetic towards Jews and Israel. It is evident that their origin has also led to their interest in the people of Israel.

The history of the Kashmiris is shrouded in mystery as is the history of other people in that region. Most Kashmir researchers are of the opinion that many inhabitants of Kashmir are descendants of the Lost Tribes who were exiled in 722 BCE. They wandered along the Silk Road into the countries of the East, Persia and Afghanistan until they reached the Kashmir valley and settled there. Others say the wanderings began approximately 300 years later. The wanderers settled in Kashmir, kept their traditions until they were forced to convert to Islam when the spread of Islam reached the valley. The priest Kitro in his book, the General History of the Mughal Empire, said that the Kashmir people are the descendants of the Israelites.

The traveling Arab historian El Bironi in the 12th century wrote, "In the past, permission to enter Kashmir was given only to Jews."

The priest Monstrat said that in the time of Vasco da Gama in the 15th century, "all the inhabitants of this area who have been living here since ancient times can trace their ancestry, according to their race and customs, to the ancient Israelites. Their features, their general physical appearance, their clothing, their ways of conducting business, all show that they are similar to the ancient Israelites."

Recently Mr. Ikbal Chapri, the owner of a houseboat called Haifa (the same name as a big city in Israel) in Srinagar, Kashmir, has written about this topic in the local newspapers.

His article was about the names of the tribes and places of Kashmir which are exactly Hebrew. I have a copy of two pages of the list. For example, one of the tribes of Kashmir is called Asheriya which is Asher, the tribe of Dand is Dan, Gadha is Gad, Lavi is Levi. The Tribe of Shaul is the Hebrew name of King Saul. Musa is Moses, Suliamanish is Solomon. And you also have the tribe of Israel, the tribe of Abri which is the tribe of Hebrew, and the tribe of Kahana which is the word for Jewish priest. There are also 50-75 names of places in Kashmir which are in fact the Hebrew names that ancient Israelites were very familiar with. There is a place called Samaryah which is Samaria. Mamre is Mamre, Pishgah is Pisgah, Nabudaal is Mt. Nevo, Bushan is Bashan, Gilgit is Gilgal, Heshba is Heshbon, Amunah is Amon, Gochan is Goshen, Median-pura is Midian, and Guzana is Gozan which is a place name in Assyria and the very place where the Ten Tribes of Israel were deported.

The name Israel is very common among them as it is among the Pathans, and this name is never used among the Muslims. They also light a candle for the Sabbath, have sidelocks, beards, and emblem or design of the Shield of David.

In an area which is on the border of Pakistan, called Yusmarg (Handwara), there lives a group which to this very day calls itself B'nei Israel meaning children of Israel. Many of the inhabitants of Kashmir say that this is the ancient name of all the people of Kashmir.

In Kashmir there is a strange legend which says that Jesus did not die on the cross but in his search for the Ten Tribes reached the Kashmir valley and lived there until his death. They even point to his grave in Kashmir. This is very much like a legend I have heard somewhere in Japan before. Yes, Herai village (the present name is Shingou village) in Aomori prefecture, where there is also the legend that Jesus came to Japan and died there. They even point to his grave in Herai. It seems that sometimes the legend of coming of Jesus and his tomb is born where the Ten Tribes are said to come.

There is another strange tradition of a small community next to the Wallar Link who point out the grave of Moses. There is yet another tradition in connection with King Solomon according to which even King Solomon reached the Kashmir Valley and through his wisdom aided the people of Kashmir by successfully regulating the Jalum river. This tradition is also connected to a place called Solomon's throne which is situated above the capital of Kashmir, Srinagar. Isn't it strange and fascinating that there are historical and even folkloristic tales of ancient Israeli heroes in these strange and exotic places?

These also resemble legends in Japan. There is the grave of Moses in Mt. Houdatsu, Ishikawa prefecture, and a legend says that many secret treasures of Solomon are kept in Mt. Tsurugi in Shikoku, Japan.

The two primary historians of Kashmir, Mulla Nadiri, who wrote The History of Kashmir and Mulla Ahmad who wrote Events of Kashmir have established without a trace of doubt that the origins of the Kashmiri people are to be found in the people of Israel.

One subject of the Lost Tribes which has generally been ignored which I found to be personally fascinating are the tribe of the Pathans.

The Pathans are about 15 million people living mainly in Pakistan and Afghanistan as well as in Persia and India. They have a tradition of being of the Lost Tribes and have Israeli customs.

The Pathans have custom of circumcision on the 8th day. This is a known Jewish custom, and is the oldest Jewish tradition. I myself witnessed and was present at a very joyous circumcision ceremony on the 8th day after birth. Muslims have custom of circumcision but it is not on the 8th day, and usually at the age of 12.

The Pathans have a sort of small Tallit called Kafan. This is a 4 cornered garment which they tie strings similar to the fringes (Jews call them Tzitzit) and is one of the oldest Jewish traditions going back to the Torah and it is a sign of their Israeli origin. They also have bigger Tallit which they call Joy-Namaz. It is a garment 2-3 meters sq., and it is made to cover the head and part of the shoulders, and is used for prayer by spreading on the ground in the Muslim fashion. It has no fringes.

The Pathans have custom of the Sabbath. The Sabbath is considered a day of rest and they do not labor, cook or bake. The Pathans prepare 12 Hallot (traditional Jewish bread, Leviticus 24:5) in honor of the Sabbath as was done in the ancient temple. One of the significant indicators proving the Israeli origins of the Pathans is the lighting of the candle to honor the Sabbath. After lighting, the candle is covered usually by a large basket. The candle is lit by a woman past her menopause.

Pathans have custom of Kosher, dietary laws same as Jews. Pathans do not eat horse or camel meat, which is most common in their area but of course forbidden to Jews. There is some evidence to their not eating meat and milk together which is also an ancient Israeli tradition. And they have a tradition regarding differentiating between pure and impure birds which means permitted and not permitted birds similar to the Torah.

Some still wear a small box which Jews call Tefillin (phylactery) containing a verse of the Bible. This box resemble Japanese Tokin of Yamabushi's forehead, too. This is an ancient custom of Israel. In the Jewish box there is the verse of Shema Israel, that is, "Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one!" (Deuteronomy 6:4) This custom of Tefillin came from a verse of the Scriptures, "You shall bind them as a sign on your hand, and they shall be as frontlets between your eyes" (Deuteronomy 6:8).

It is interesting to note that the Pathans retain family names of the Lost Tribes such as Asher, Gad, Naphtali, Reuben and Manasseh and Ephraim. Among them there are people who are called by these names, which are of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel. There are also people who are called Israel, Samuel, and so on, which are never found among the Muslims. There are also many areas as locations, neighborhoods and villages with names of places that are similar to names in the land of Israel.

The region has archeological finds testifying to a Hebrew past, and they also resemble Jews of the area and their language Pashtu surprisingly has many Hebrew words. The Pathans are also called Afghans, or sons of the Pashtu which is their language, were mostly called "Bani-Israel" meaning children of Israel even though they live today as devout Muslims.

The external appearance of the Pathans resemble the Jews of the area. Together with their ancient customs and other data there is a definite connection that can be made to the Tribes of Israel.

The Pathans number 6 to 7 million in Afghanistan and 7 to 8 million in Pakistan. They live in the border area between these two countries and about 2 million live as nomads. These Pathans desire for their independence, which is supported by Afghanistan and is a cause of constant tension in Pakistan which does not desire their independence.

Afghanistan is one of the least developed countries of Asia and the majority of the population is illiterate. They work primarily in farming and sheep-raising and other domesticated animals.

Most people still live in villages and some even live as nomads. It is a country that is ruled by Islamic religious law and more than 90 % of the population are Sunni Muslims. But whatever modernization has taken place, it has not reached the mountainous border areas. Here the Pathans continue their centuries old tribal life.

The legal system which is known as Pashtunwali, the law of the Pashtu, is very similar to the Torah, which is the holiest Jewish book and the book of ancient Jewish way of life. There are pages and even complete books among the pathans and they honor greatly what is called Tavrad El Sharif (the Torah of Moses), and they rise at the mention of the name of Moses even though it is not important in Islam.

The Pathans are very healthy, tall, and have strong light-skinned appearance. They are warriors and carry arms from a young age, they are hardworking, wise, truthful and extremely loyal and they also have a worldwide reputation for exemplary hospitality.

The ethnic origin of these Pathans has puzzled people for some time because they are different both externally and in the character traits from the other groups around them such as the Turks, the Mongolians, the Persians, or the Indo-Iranians. It is also difficult to trace their past history in a region in which tens of nations and major tribes of various origins have come and gone.

The personal identification of the Pathan Tribes with their Israelite origin is expressed in various ways. Besides the oral tradition related by the elders of the tribe, there are also interesting testimonies of keeping of scrolls of genealogy among the tribes, reaching back to the Fathers of the Jewish nation.

These scrolls are well preserved and some are written in gold on the skins of a doe. No less interesting and significant are the names of the tribes which bear close resemblance to the Tribes of Israel. The Rabbani Tribe is really Reuben, the Shinware Tribe is Shimon, the Lewani Tribe is Levi, The Daftani Tribe is Naphtali, and the Jaji Tribe is Gad, and the Ashuri Tribe is Asher, The Yusefsai Tribe is sons of Joseph, and the Afridi Tribe is really Ephraim. These are the names of the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel.

The Pathans themselves point out the differences between the original names of the tribes and their present names are because of the different dialects of the languages so that, for instance, Jaji was actually called Gaji for the tribe of Gad.

There are some Jews of Afghanistan today who count the Tribe of Israel among the Pathans. The physical similarity between the Pathans and other Jews is exemplified by the British ruled Afghanistan for a great length of time and called the Pathans Jews. When not wearing their traditional clothing Pathans are indistinguishable from other Jews of the area. Among the 21 nations of Afghanistan only the Pathans and the Jews have Semitic features, their faces are longer and lighter, and some even have blue eyes. Like the Jews of the area, Pathans grow beards and sidelocks which further serve to make them indistinguishable from Jews.

Their wedding is like Jewish. Wedding ceremony with the Pathans includes a marriage canopy and rings similar to the Jewish custom.

Women of the Pathans keep laws similar to the Jewish laws regarding menstruation. During this time and for 7 days after, no contact is allowed with the husband. After this period, the woman immerses in a river or spring or in a bathhouse if a natural spring is not available. This is exactly the same as the Israeli tradition going back to the days of the Bible.

Pathans have custom of levirate marriage, which is the custom when a husband dies without children, his brother marries the widow to keep the name of the house. This custom no longer exists today, but was an ancient Israeli custom mentioned in the Bible (Deuteronomy 25:5-6).

The commandment to honor one's parent is kept in exemplary manner in these tribes. The son must obey the parents in all matters. When the father enters the room all stand and bow their heads in his honor. This was a Israeli tradition as well.

Pathans have custom of Yom Kippur. We know of some of the members of the Lewani Tribe who came to the Jewish synagogue on Yom Kippur each year in Afghanistan. He would stay there until sundown without uttering even one word. He spoke of the tradition of the Temple on this day and of the high priest and his work there.

One year he erred in his calendar and did not come, he wept bitterly for one week for missing the observance of this day.

The Pathans have custom of scapegoat. In ancient Israel there was the custom to put sins of the nation onto a goat and send the goat away to desert. This custom of scapegoat was done to atone the sins of the nation (Leviticus chapter 16). Similar custom is found even today among the Pathans.

The Pathans usually pray in mosque. However some pray towards Jerusalem which is most unusual. There are some very old synagogues in their area and Pathans come to these synagogues on special days in times of great stress or tragedies or for special prayers. The individual who seeks help comes there to touch the lock and to pray. There are those who say that these places once contained scrolls of the Torah. This is interesting because today they are actually devout Muslims.

At the time of plague the Pathans slaughter a sheep and sprinkle its blood on the doorpost of their homes. This is what the Israelites did in ancient Egypt during the plagues that occurred there.

An interesting testimony relates to the placing of a wrapped book of Psalms of the Bible under the pillow of the ill in order to heal that person.

There are those who have said that there are Amulets written in Hebrew. Some contain the phrase "Shema Israel" and it is secretly written by the head of the tribe and it is forbidden to open it.

And the symbol of Shield of David (Star of David) is found in almost every Pathan house. The wealthy make it out of expensive metals and the poor out of simple wood. It can be seen in towers, in schools and also in tools, bracelets, and jewelry. I saw it at least 20 times in a variety of places. In Minerajan, the center of Afghanistan, there are even schools that have the Shield of David on the door or in the stone above the door.

There is one aspect about this our Heavenly Father set it about for what took place to those "LOST" children, He knows who and where they are.

The Assryian King was a "servant" of our Heavenly Father, and what took place was exactly what our Heavenly Father set in motion.

Remember what Christ said Matthew 5:6 These twelve Jesus sent forth, and commanded them, saying "Go not into the way of the Gentiles, and into any city of the Samaritans enter ye not:

6. But go rather to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.

This is a huge clue, consider who it is that Christ was taught to from that point forward. Follow the "birthright" and the "BLESSINGS".

This is the BIGGEST FRAUD AND HOAX OF HISTORY! The Kashmiris have no Semitic origin. Hindu Kashmir had only Aryan gods, Aryan religion and Aryan traditions being followed in Kashmir. The Semitic names have come to Kashmir after the 14th century with the advent of Islam. Kashmir and Afghanistan have been a part of greater India, that is Aryavarta. Ancient name of Hindu-Buddhist Afghanistan before Arab invasion of Afghanistan is Ariana. We laugh at these fabricated stories.

salam and hello, i would like to say that we were not descendants of israelis most importantly jews, as someone stated there are stars of david in every house, this is 100% false. i am half kashmiri half pathan as it happens my self and i strongly know my culture. this person needs to read up on history, we have also had a claim that we are european descendant which is not middle eastern as israel is. also what does the person mean we sympathise for jews? this person seems to be a jew himself! we are simply us, the climate around us is different to the rest of pakistan and so we are fairer. please do not be offended anyone its just the the truth. thank all for admiring our warrior spirit but no one owns us. i belong to islam and i belong to my land, thankyou

You are a new poster. Welcome.

I suggest you follow all the links, do all the research, and receive all the facts. Line up all the facts and meditate upon just the facts. Then make a decision.

What is a fact? The dictionary defines "fact" as "something that has actual existence."

firstly thank you for the welcome,
secondly i refuse to look at the junk which you and other jews seem to be conjuring up, look to make it clear if you believe in this theory then you must believe in islam as the truth as such warriors like us accepted islam. we did not just accept it like that, and if we held any doubt we would fight. your question has been answered so you may aswell just say the shahadah now my friend, thanks again and take care
p.s do NOT post anything saying that we were forced onto islam as i will get very angry as we know this is a pathetic attempt to regain ones dignity

do not tell me what we are, i am starting to get angry now at the stuid comments of some here. dont tell me where i am from. there is another tribe i have come across which has greek origin with an extremely small pagan population amongst them no jews or christians alhamdulilah, nice people i have met mashallah. we do not look anything like jews alhamdulilah and we are not in any way alike. for the christians who are joining on this conspiracy my suggestion is to find another country to victimise and make you assumptions too!

shahadah

What is a shahadah?

Also, I am Christian and not Jewish.

Most all cultures that are today Islamic were forced into Islam during the eras of Islamic conquest from about 650-1400 AD. That is a matter of history.

If you grew up in an Islamic country, then the odds are that you were not forced into Islam, but simply were born into it.

The 3 is true.

"The point is this: what is God doing in this age? Is all this occurring as a step in His plan to reunite the tribes? Is this all mistaken research? I don't know. But I'm not going to ignore it."

You ask what "is God doing in this age"? I will ask you "have you not read", it is written, Christ said he foretold us all things.

It is also written that not all will understand what is written.

"IF" you will read very very carefully there are some "hints" within this article.

salam to all muslims in this forum, and hello to non muslims. hi mr xzins.

the shahadah = declaration of belief ~ LA ILAHA ILLALLAH MUHAMMAD DA RASULLULLAH ( there is no god worthy of worship other than ALLAH and muhammad is his final messanger)

i have found your lost tribe some time back who do not claim to be our descendants! how many people claiming its hillariuous! they are known as gypsys who have same look as jews. they are scattered in europe and fled many centurys ago. i have actually met some and they resemble your claims. they are probably the descendants of the lost tribe. your anscestors were forced to christianity thats why you were born into a christian family my friend, your racist views are getting truely out of hand that we were forced to islam like other muslims around the world. do you remember the spanish war? even the jews and and the christian minority refused to fight the muslims and remained loyal due to the kindness and protection we gave them in our rule. they too were slaughtered along with all the spanish muslims who were forced into christianity. let me tell you about your origins sir and you will read upon them by sites given by other biased people like me. you will have no say in where i decide you are from, i will think and give you a descision at what i think. tell me your origins and i will calculate your anscestors mate.

As with all theories, one looks at the facts and considers them. The facts regarding the tribes in Afghan and Pakistan indicate a possible Israeli connection. It is simply something to look at without emotion, and acknowledge those items which are facts.

I am Christian. My ancestry is German, Scottish, English, Irish, Native American. That encompasses a variety of religions depending upon how far back one goes.

The difference, of course, is that Jesus never led an army and did not think a forced conversion to be valid. The only valid conversion is a conversion which one truly believes.

This makes sense to me as to why Jesus never led an army to force conversion. His example comes down to his followers. They can judge their behavior by his behavior.

Mohammed did lead armies, and he did cruelly kill people in order to force conversions. His example carries on to his followers. They will judge their behavior by his behavior.

how dare you insult our prophet,
one looks on how prophets were, muhammad did not attack other but he defended his followers from the pagans etc. no
christian i have seen in the past history from all sources i have seen has been peaceful to muslims, its been convert or die, move jesus who was our prophet out the equation and look at his so called followers or lets say worshippors and drunken colleagues who he himself would be infuriated with. tell me what are the connections between pakistan and israel you fool? i have been commented i look spanish when im pakistani, ones intellectual level must be balanced and not reduced to the simple facts of apearances of others. come on thats the way a premature child would think, o they look similar when in fact they dont so they must be the same. this world is a big one and many people may be alike. dont dare insult my prophet again or the next post will be full of swearwords a very unorthodox manner.

There is a good video on this, believe it or not, done by a Jewish gentlemen who actually went to many of these places.

"Quest for the Lost Tribes" by Simcha Jacobovici, Elliott Halpern - available on the web. I have a copy of this at home and it is rivetting. Could not begin to say enough good things about it.

You are not stating the case properly are you. The three tribes of Judah were of Judah - not Israel. And Jesus flatly stated he came not but to the lost sheep of the house of Israel. This is right on the mark. The deportation by the Assyrians is a matter of historical record. Methinks you either haven't read or are pushing some agenda lol

Another problem with this is that the Jews freely spread all over under Persia and then the Hellenized world. There were significant populations of them in many places. I don't think there are any "lost tribes." What was lost was the hereditary possession of the land. After that, they wandered far and wide, along with their brothers from Judah, and lost their distinction as separate tribes.

I have a contention, though, with this article's premise that these guys are still Jews. Any Jew who converted to Islam is a Baal worshipper.

khaqan_khawaja, the Gypsys have been proven to be related to India, not Israel.

It's hard to insult a dead guy. Therefore, it's not him who's insulted; it is you.

In the meantime, it behooves you to investigate the truth about Jesus of Nazareth rather than listen to anyone else's words. Read about Jesus for yourself. Study his words.

You will see the difference.

He was the light who enlightens everyone who comes into the world. Anyone at all who calls on the name of Jesus will be saved.

Israelites are still israelites and the chosen people even if they are off whoring around in other religions as the OT put it. Their response to God doesn't determine their lineage. but it does cause a proper response from God. When Christ rode in on the ass, he pronounced judgement on Israel in the prophecy that Jarusalem would be raized to the ground and not one stone left sitting on another because they failed to recognize Jesus for who and what he was. Judgement did not stop them being Israelites. On the other hand, the Church has been grafted in as a member of the chosen.

The lineage of Israel is important to such an extent that a number of groups have a lot to gain in trying to discredit and disown Israel, their history, etc. I'd tread very carfully with pronouncements. These are God's chosen and to be judged by him - not by us. He is both just and merciful and there is still a great deal of prophecy to be fullfilled - including the mass conversion of Israelites that is to come. ;)

Might be interesting to take note of who protests the story and from what religion they come. I can tell you three religions off the top of my head that have a real problem with this. Islam and Roman Catholicism are the two biggest.
Presents a real problem for their Peter went to Rome claim. Moslems deny the chosen status and merely wish to dispute that israelites even really exist. Mormons seem to have a mixed reaction. Jehovah's witnesses are into the replacement theology concept that Rome once embraced in error. You could write a book on the reaction to other religions to the house of Israel.

There is more to it than just that. In the video version of this story, Simcha interviews some from among the Pathans and makes a pretty good case. Some may have fled to the south of india after the destruction of the second temple. But scripture tells us that the 10 tribes had long since been in that region. Simcha deals with the names of places listed in scripture and draws comparison to the modern names which still bare up under comparison to the hebrew counterparts. He goes into enough detail to be quite convincing. It isn't really a common sense notion that Muslims would take on the practices of Israelites whom they bare a rather extreme hatred for. I think you'd have a pretty difficult time selling that. So I guess I'd say, try to keep an open mind - if you can.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.