Posted on 04/28/2025 6:07:02 PM PDT by Red Badger
In a nutshell
* Scientists successfully 3D printed plant-based calamari rings using mung bean protein and microalgae, creating a seafood alternative that closely matches real squid in texture and even surpasses it in protein content.
* The 10% microalgae formulation achieved the best results, producing calamari mimics that were softer, springier, and structurally similar to real calamari, without relying on overfished marine resources.
* This innovation highlights a promising future for sustainable seafood alternatives, leveraging underused crops like mung beans and algae to reduce pressure on ocean ecosystems while meeting growing demand for plant-based foods.
*******************************************************************************
SINGAPORE — Your next fried calamari appetizer might come from a printer, not the ocean. Scientists from the National University of Singapore have successfully 3D printed plant-based calamari rings that closely mimic both the texture and protein content of real squid.
The research, published in ACS Food Science & Technology, involved combining two sustainable protein sources that are currently underutilized: mung beans (small green legumes popular across Asia) and microalgae. The result? A convincing calamari alternative that could help address growing concerns about overfishing, marine pollution, and seafood contamination.
With the global vegan food market expected to more than double from $16.55 billion in 2022 to $37.45 billion by 2030, plant-based seafood remains an untapped opportunity. Currently, seafood alternatives make up less than 1% of the plant-based food sector.
The research team created what they call a “composite ink” by combining protein extracted from mung beans with bead-milled microalgae biomass. This mixture was then loaded into a 3D printer that precisely shaped the material into realistic calamari rings.
3D-printed calamari before and after frying
3D-printed calamari mimic (top image) is battered and deep-fried (bottom image). (CREDIT: Adapted from ACS Food Science & Technology 2025)
To achieve the proper texture, researchers experimented with various concentrations of gellan gum (a food-grade thickening agent), fat content, and microalgae amounts. After extensive testing, they determined that the optimal formula contained 1.5% gellan gum, 2% fat, and 10% microalgae biomass.
The team conducted detailed rheological analyses, tests that measure how materials flow and deform, to ensure their plant-based mixture would move smoothly through the 3D printer nozzle and maintain its shape afterward. They needed an ink with “shear-thinning behavior,” meaning it flows more easily under pressure (like when being squeezed through a printer nozzle) but firms up once that pressure is removed.
How the Fake Calamari Stacks Up
The 3D-printed rings were then battered and deep-fried, just like conventional calamari. When compared to real squid rings in texture tests, the version containing 10% microalgae most closely matched authentic calamari in terms of hardness, springiness, and cohesiveness.
The plant-based alternative actually contained more protein than the real thing. The printed calamari with 10% microalgae delivered 19.61% protein content, compared to 14.21% in actual squid rings.
Ocean Conservation
Environmental concerns about traditional seafood sources are currently mounting. Beyond overfishing and marine biodiversity loss, seafood consumers increasingly worry about contaminants like microplastics and heavy metals.
Calamari. Real fried calamari for comparison. (Foodio/Shutterstock)
Mung beans are widely cultivated across Asia, with processing byproducts often going to waste. Thailand’s mung bean starch industries alone produce approximately 600 tonnes (about 1.3 million pounds) of high-protein wastewater daily. Meanwhile, microalgae can be grown on non-arable land with minimal freshwater requirements compared to both animal and plant proteins.
A study of Singaporean consumers found microalgae-based foods were positively perceived, especially among younger, health-conscious individuals attracted to products labeled as “innovative” and “environmentally friendly.”
There is also a lack of calamari alternatives out there. Researchers found only four substitutes (three vegan, one vegetarian) compared to 140 traditional squid products between 2002 and 2021.
The research team noted that higher concentrations of microalgae (20% versus 10%) actually compromised the structural stability of the calamari rings, particularly during frying. This suggests there are still technical hurdles to overcome before such products reach commercial viability.
3D printing technology, combined with sustainable protein sources, can create customizable, nutritious seafood alternatives that closely resemble the real thing, not just in appearance but also in protein content and mouthfeel. As seafood supplies face increasing pressure from environmental factors, innovations like this could help reduce impacts on marine ecosystems at a time when seafood supplies are in danger of dwindling.
Paper Summary
Methodology
Researchers extracted protein isolate from mung beans by creating a 20% water dispersion, adjusting pH to 8, then precipitating proteins at pH 4.5 before neutralizing to pH 7. They prepared microalgae by bead-milling with ethanol and drying. The composite ink combined these ingredients with varying levels of gellan gum (0.5-2%), fat (1-4%), and microalgae (0-20%). The mixture underwent blending, sonication, heating at 90°C, cooling, and overnight incubation at 4°C before final blending. Researchers analyzed the ink’s rheological properties using a rotational stress-controlled rheometer, conducting several tests including three interval-time thixotropy testing, yield stress determination, and frequency sweep analysis. They 3D printed the calamari rings using a Foodini printer with a 4000 μm nozzle, creating four-layer rings that were frozen, battered, and deep-fried at 180°C for 30 seconds. Texture analysis compared the plant-based mimics to real calamari using compression testing, while confocal laser scanning microscopy examined microstructure.
Results
The optimal formulation contained 1.5% gellan gum, 2% fat, and 10% microalgae biomass, which provided the best combination of printability, structure stability, and texture. The 10% microalgae formulation achieved a protein concentration of 19.61%, exceeding real calamari’s 14.21%. Texture analysis showed that 10% microalgae samples (192.83g hardness) more closely matched real calamari (180.85g hardness) than control samples without microalgae (311.09g hardness). Microscopy revealed that microalgae created a more discontinuous protein matrix with voids that mimicked calamari’s softness and elasticity. The calamari mimic maintained thermal stability during frying, with minimal differences in thermal transitions between formulations.
Limitations
Higher concentrations of microalgae (20%) compromised structural stability during frying. The commercial microalgae biomass used had undergone spray-drying, which caused protein denaturation and reduced solubility (1.14% compared to mung bean protein’s 85.6% solubility). This made the microalgae function more as a filler than a fully functional protein. The research did not assess flavor profiles or conduct consumer acceptance testing, which would be necessary before commercial application.
Funding/Disclosures
The research was supported by the National Research Foundation (NRF2020-THE003-0004), Prime Minister’s Office, Singapore under its Campus for Research Excellence and Technological Enterprise (CREATE) programme. One author acknowledged support from the Commonwealth Research Scholarship. The authors declared no competing financial interests.
Publication Information
The study, titled “3D Printing for Seafood Mimic: Factors Impacting the Rheology and Texture of Microalgae and Mung Bean Protein Composite ink,” was published in ACS Food Science & Technology on March 22, 2025. The authors were Poornima Vijayan, Zhixuan Song, Melody Ru Yee Yap, Dingsong Lin, and Dejian Huang from the Department of Food Science & Technology at the National University of Singapore and the National University of Singapore (Suzhou) Research Institute.
Inaccurate title: plant-based “calamari” is not calamari.
I’ve read that you have to cook the real stuff very quickly; overcooking turns it into rubber bands.
I’ve never found it very edible even in somewhat ‘nicer’ restaurants; besides the rubber-band texture, it has never seemed to have much flavor, to me.
That is not true. Ever heard of eating rice and green peas? Sheesh - in many ways FR is where facts go to die. I eat meat often as well, but come on, at least try to be correct.
no no no no no no no!!!!
Rings, are 85 to 90% of the time going to be like chewing on a tire... ALWAYS cut em in strips like they do the main body!!
Sautéed or acid cooked as part of a seafood salad ceviche.
Text book example of “Ultra-Processed Food”.
Calamari... y’know, I think I graduated a year behind Cal...
That’s not calamari.
Fifty years ago, when I was a starving college student, I ate quite a bit of squid because it usually cost only 29 cents a pound (and because I liked it). Then, practically overnight it seemed, squid was being sold as “calamari” for $1.99 a pound. Oh, well.
And you’re right about cooking squid. A quick sear in a hot skillet is best. Cook squid a few seconds too long and you’ll be chewing it half the night.
Hard pass
Just what the World needs, MORE NASTY BAIT !!!
Sigh why lie, we get it bro you hate vegans at least argue from a standpoint of facts.
Literally first result from Gemini less than 2 seconds of asking.
Complete plant proteins are sources of protein that contain all nine essential amino acids that the human body needs but cannot produce on its own. Examples of plant-based complete proteins include quinoa, soy products (tofu, tempeh, edamame), hemp seeds, chia seeds, amaranth, buckwheat, and spirulina.
The list is much more extensive. You can also extract complete proteins from leavesstems and roots via alkaline hydrolysis. It is factually incorrect to say you cannot get complete protein from plants that is scientifically wrong period full stop. Half a billion Indians in India also would smack you down with that fact as well.
We get it you like meat fine but don’t lie it a bad look for the right. I am a and hunter, and a descendent of coming on 300 years of continuous cattle people in South Texas I have never bought store beef always from familia’s herd so by no means vegan.
I am a scientist and understand math with 8 billion and growing there is not enough land, feed or water for the 6 billion people in chronic protein deficiency to eat animal protein at even half of western levels of consumption this is just cold hard mathematical fact. To eliminate this global issue , cultured products, precision fermentation and biotech is the only way. It’s going to come down to competitive price what can you afford to eat vs what the world is willing to pay for limited resources. As the global economy expands abd more and more humans have middle class money the PPP of that currency will determine where resources get sent too. Again it’s mathematical which doesn’t care about politics, feelings or beliefs. The products will flow to the highest bidders.
You need to print the Parmesan cheese.
It keeps clogging up the injectors............
Can’t you combine plant stuffs such as beans and corn. Does not the corn fill in the missing amino acid?
BARF to BOTH!
Frankenfood.
I ordered Calamari in a restaurant in Berlin one time and they brought out a platter that would have fed a family of four!.............
I pass.
Yes, you can combine plant proteins to get complete amino acids but it’s not necessarily usable or digestible.
For example, beef not only provides protein but the B vitamins and iron are combined and digested in a way you cannot duplicate with plants, powders or pills.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.