Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Affixing blame for the Mountain Meadows Massacre
Patheos ^ | SEPTEMBER 21, 2019 | DAN PETERSON

Posted on 09/22/2019 4:04:02 PM PDT by robowombat

Affixing blame for the Mountain Meadows Massacre SEPTEMBER 21, 2019 BY DAN PETERSON

This is not a photo of the Mountain Meadows Massacre. We have none. So I went for a cheerier note. This is a photo (by James Jordan) of director Mark Goodman working just a few days ago with extras in Old Sturbridge Village, Massachusetts, for the “Witnesses” film project.

I note that I’m being accused by a small handful of people of blaming the Mountain Meadows Massacre on “anti-Mormons.”

First, two preliminary observations:

1) When I write anything for the public, at least some people will misread it in the most negative way that they possibly can.

2) The Mountain Meadows Massacre is, for quite manifest reasons, a controversial topic. And, accordingly, it’s one that some people are strongly inclined to exploit for ideological ends.

Of course, I don’t blame the Massacre on “anti-Mormons.” I blame it on the people who did it.

But the perpetrators interest me very particularly because, overwhelmingly, they do not seem to have been conventionally bad people – thugs, murderers, and the like – either before September 1857 or, for the most part, thereafter.

So the question that puzzles me (in this case as in more than a few others) is, What makes ordinary, decent people commit so extraordinarily horrific a crime?

Reading the Oxford book Massacre at Mountain Meadows, by Ron Walker and Rick Turley and Glen Leonard, when it first came out many years ago, I felt as if I were seeing a Greek tragedy unfold. There was a certain inexorable logic to what ultimately happened – a horrible logic, obviously, but one in which it made a certain degree of sense, after one bad step had been taken, to take the next one. I found myself wanting to scream “No! Stop!” while knowing what the outcome was inevitably going to be.

To me, if we see the people who committed the Mountain Meadows Massacre as utterly unlike ourselves, we’re not only falsifying history (and not merely in the sense that they, like me and many of my readers, claimed membership in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) but refusing to see a lesson (or, more aptly, lessons) in what happened. If they were something of a different species, their cautionary tale can have little if anything to teach us.

In order to understand what they did, we need to understand what factors acted upon them. And, beyond any reasonable dispute, one of the most important of those factors was a prior history of persecution and forced migration.

That doesn’t mean that the Missouri mobs bear legal and moral responsibility for the Mountain Meadows Massacre any more than an abusive father is responsible for the violent acts committed much later by a criminal son. But neither are the two unrelated. Human evils ramify. They do damage, among other things to human psyches.

The Mountain Meadows Massacre certainly isn’t the Restoration’s finest hour. It’s anything but faith-promoting. But it shouldn’t be exploited as a weapon against the Church or against religious belief, either. It’s too complex to be reducible to a self-serving slogan on a partisan bumper sticker.


TOPICS: History; Religion
KEYWORDS: 1857; bookreview; falseprophets; lds; ldschurch; magicundies; massacre; mormonkooks; mormons; mountainmeadows; murderingmormons
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 141-160161-180181-200 ... 341-355 next last
To: wita

Again I should add, I’ve seen worse as far as takeover is concerned.


161 posted on 09/24/2019 2:20:46 PM PDT by wita (Always and forever, under oath in defense of Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 160 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

Agree completely.


162 posted on 09/24/2019 2:21:34 PM PDT by wita (Always and forever, under oath in defense of Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 152 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

(Though that ‘many’ leaves a LOT of wiggle room.)

My comment was only in reference to the men you quoted not an attempt at wiggling.

I do need to address one other issue. I was going to add a caution in my original post about being careful about putting words unspoken in others mouths. I though better of it in order to give benefit of doubt.

Your quote: ( Remember fellow Christians: the Mormon’s criticize US because they’ve been taught that they CAN’T criticize ANY of their leaders; so they HAVE to vent somehow! )

Can’t is not found in that quote. The quote is “It is wrong to criticize...” I don’t see that as a prohibition. We are cautioned that it can be a poison dangerous to our faith if carried to extreme. The Gospel of Jesus Christ is all about personal agency. We are commanded by the Gospel of Christ, but no one is standing over us other than our conscience or the Holy Spirit to guide. You have concentrated on the words of the dead members of the Church of Jesus Christ which is why I suggested you might try with the living members, and I applaud your effort in that regard.

You did manage to paint with a broad brush accusing Mormon’s in general of criticizing Christian’s while divorcing said Mormon’s from the Christian family. I’ll accept some Mormon’s are critical, but certainly not all and it is strictly you opinion on whether We belong to the Christian family or not. I would say any LDS members on FR are already sufficiently warned by their opponents if they haven’t already left this site because of the constant harangue by so called Christian’s. Frankly, I don’t think you have helped JR maintain FreeRepublic, by driving away those who agree in principle with FR but rightly refuse to put up with the crap you folks are so good at delivering. Just my maybe not so humble opinion.

I tried my best to keep it civil but didn’t want to completely whitewash my comments. Now that I have spent this time I still haven’t forgotten the polygamy repeal. Later I guess. Maybe I should just point out God’s repeal of the Garden of Eden, and then mankind sorta got repealed because of corruption around the time of the flood. Noah and family started the recovery. The Law of Moses was repealed by Christ. The Jews themselves went from chosen to not so chosen, repeal of the present status of this planet is also due sometime in the future. IOW repeals are not that unusual. Stoning, and an eye for an eye would not be appreciated in today’s society but were certainly a part of early Christianity. I’m sure there are more.


163 posted on 09/24/2019 4:36:33 PM PDT by wita (Always and forever, under oath in defense of Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 153 | View Replies]

To: Jamestown1630

So true; and I am darned proud of it; too!


164 posted on 09/24/2019 6:42:59 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 157 | View Replies]

To: Jamestown1630

Can’t disagree with that!


165 posted on 09/24/2019 6:43:36 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 158 | View Replies]

To: wita
You have concentrated on the words of the dead members of the Church of Jesus Christ which is why I suggested you might try with the living members, and I applaud your effort in that regard.

Oh?

Why?

Why should the living bring a different message than the dead?

When did GOD bring this new message?

Where is it recorded?

166 posted on 09/24/2019 6:46:31 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 163 | View Replies]

To: wita
I tried my best to keep it civil but didn’t want to completely whitewash my comments.

You've done a good job.

I know it's hard trying to reconcile the past with the present; when there is so little data to derive stuff from.


 
 
Kinda makes me wonder when GOD changed his mind about these old questions and decided to implement the current new ones.
 
 
 

Temple Recommend Questions: 1857

 1. Have you committed murder by shedding innocent blood, or consenting thereto?
 2. Have you betrayed your brethren or sisters in anything?
 3. Have you committed adultery, by having any connection with a woman that was not your wife, or a man that was not your husband?
 4. Have you taken and made use of property not your own, without the consent of the owner?
 5. Have you cut hay where you had no right to, or turned your animals into another person’s grain or field, without his knowledge and consent?
 6. Have you lied about or maliciously misrepresented any person or thing?
 7. Have you borrowed anything that you have not returned, or paid for?
 8. Have you borne false witness against your neighbor?
 9. Have you taken the name of Deity in vain?
10. Have you coveted anything not your own?
11. Have you been intoxicated with strong drink?
12. Have you found lost property and not returned it to the owner, or used all diligence to do so?
13. Have you branded an animal that you did not know to be your own?
14. Have you taken another’s horse or mule from the range and rode it, without the owner's consent?
15. Have you fulfilled your promises in paying your debts, or run into debt without prospect of paying?
16. Have you taken water to irrigate with, when it belonged to another person at the time you used it?
17. Do you pay your tithing promptly?
18. Do you teach her family the gospel of salvation?
19. Do you speak against your brethren, or against any principle taught in the Bible, Book of Mormon, book of Doctrine and Covenants, revelations given to Joseph Smith the Prophet and the Presidency of the Church as now organized?
20. Do you pray in your family night and morning and attend to secret prayer?
21. Do you wash your body and have your family do so, as often as health and cleanliness require and circumstances will permit?
22. Do you labor six days and rest, or go to the house of worship, on the seventh?
23. Do you preside over your household as a servant of God, and is your family subject to you?
24. Have you labored diligently and earned faithfully the wages paid you by your employers?
25. Do you oppress the hireling in his wages?
26. Have you taken up and converted any stray animal to your own use, or in any manner appropriated one to your benefit, without accounting therefore to the proper authorities?


 

167 posted on 09/24/2019 6:50:43 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 163 | View Replies]

To: teppe

I know what a ‘genius’ is, but I am uncertain what a ‘Genious’ is. Are you a ‘Genious’? Could you explain this new word?

Both ‘islam’ and ‘mormonism’ ARE cults! One is the cult of a male who committed fraud, conspired to murder others, committed adultery, married an underage female, claimed to be the ‘last prophet from God’, and claimed he hot all thos information from a most high angel. The other is the cult of mohamed hence, mohamedanism. No greater a man than Sir Winston Churchill referred to that religion as ‘mohammedanism’. I defer to his judgement.

As far as my words, I’ll leave the judgement up to Jesus, thank you very much.


168 posted on 09/26/2019 10:45:56 AM PDT by A Formerly Proud Canadian (I once was blind but now I see...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 46 | View Replies]

To: teppe
These same Mormons had been run from NY to Ohio to Missouri to Illinois and then to Utah from religeous persecution and were unwilling to run again.

I'd hate to call you a liar; so I won't; but the FACTS of this statement are plainly; at least; incorrect.

Many 'Mormons" were NOT run from Missouri. The fearful ones who CHOOSE to follow a false prophet to their deaths on the trek west to Utah, are the ones who RAN.

(A 'true' prophet would have at least WARNED them of the dangers of leaving ).

The ones who DID NOT LEAVE, became the owners of all of the land and possessions left behind.


Stop off in NAVUOO some day and see the history.



169 posted on 10/30/2019 3:38:07 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: teppe
If this incident was somehow consistent with LDS teachings, as some claim .... how come it has never been repeated?

Beats the SHIZ outta me!!

170 posted on 10/30/2019 3:44:06 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies]

To: teppe
If this incident was somehow consistent with LDS teachings, as some claim .... how come it has never been repeated?

I seem to remember that Joseph Smith claimed that GOD wanted him to 'correct' the errors in the KJV of the bible.

And; according to well documented LDS source; Joseph did that very thing.

Now; if GOD wanted the eroors eliminated; why hasn't a Living Prophet® since Smith been commanded by GOD to actually call the Inspireved Version 'scripture' and get in published and replace the error prone (we're told) KJV in the QUAD??

How come THAT has never been done?

GOD change his mind yet again??

171 posted on 10/30/2019 3:47:41 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies]

To: aMorePerfectUnion

BDS: Buchanan Derangement Syndrome


172 posted on 10/30/2019 3:50:28 PM PDT by Bubba Ho-Tep ("The rat always knows when he's in with weasels."--Tom Waits)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 32 | View Replies]

To: SkyDancer
You wonder why they don’t wear little Golden Plates on a necklace.

Why?

They've got CTR stuff!


Although I guess some enterprising MORMON could decide to scale down THIS an make jewelry out of it...


https://www.google.com/search?q=caracters+lds&nfpr=1&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiDwpyqicXlAhWkmeAKHajbBsoQvgUITSgB&biw=1366&bih=614

173 posted on 10/30/2019 3:52:57 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

A paper with numbers and letters all modern.


174 posted on 10/30/2019 3:56:19 PM PDT by SkyDancer ( ~ Just Consider Me A Random Fact Generator ~ Eat Sleep Fly Repeat ~)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 173 | View Replies]

To: Elsie

Oh and there is no such language as Reformed Egyptian.


175 posted on 10/30/2019 3:57:28 PM PDT by SkyDancer ( ~ Just Consider Me A Random Fact Generator ~ Eat Sleep Fly Repeat ~)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 173 | View Replies]

To: teppe
If you call yourself a Christian ... then please cat like one.

....and there isn’t such a thing as mohamedanism, Genious .... its called ‘Islam’


If you call yourself a member of The Church of JESUS CHRIST of Latter-day Saints ... then please act like one.

....and there IS such a thing as SPELLCHECK -->; Genious .... try using it.


Oh, BTW; thanks for showing what Mormon Apologists think about their quarry.

176 posted on 10/30/2019 3:59:13 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 46 | View Replies]

To: teppe
Please .... your ability to find comparisons between different things rivals the abilities of my neighbors 6 year old!

I hear that now SLC wants to place Hill Cumorah somewhere in Central America.

Is that true??


https://www.funforlesstours.com/category/book-of-mormon-cruises-tours/


Cultural appropriation??

177 posted on 10/30/2019 4:08:20 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 46 | View Replies]

To: teppe
Take a break from your religious bigotry and take a cup of coffee!

Can a Temple Worthy® Mormon even SAY the word 'coffee'???


Green indicates updated linklinks: October 2019
 
Orson Pratt proclaimed:
"Both Catholics and Protestants are nothing less than the 'whore of Babylon' whom the Lord denounces by the mouth of John the Revelator as having corrupted all the earth by their fornications and wickedness. Any person who shall be so corrupt as to receive a holy ordinance of the Gospel from the ministers of any of these apostate churches will be sent down to hell with them, unless they repent" (The Seer).  
Page 273 found HERE https://www.freewebs.com/iglesiadejesucristodeltiempodelfin/Orson%20Pratt%20-%20The%20Seer%20%281854%29.pdf
More confusion:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_and_abominable_church#LDS_Church_publications
 

Questions put to Joseph Smith:
"'Do you believe the Bible?' [Smith:]'If we do, we are the only people under heaven that does, for there are none of the religious sects of the day that do'. When asked 'Will everybody be damned, but Mormons'? [Smith replied] 'Yes, and a great portion of them, unless they repent, and work righteousness." (Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, p. 119). 
Found in section 3 --> http://www.boap.org/LDS/Joseph-Smith/Teachings/T3.html  (search for 119)
 
 
"for the teachers of religion of the different sects understood the same passages of scripture so differently as to destroy all confidence in settling the question by an appeal to the Bible" (from Pearl of Great Price 1:12).
Found here --->  https://books.google.com/books?id=PkNOAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA74&lpg=PA74&dq=different+sects+understood+the+same+passages&source=bl&ots=17G4-8kYsz&sig=ACfU3U0v-r6iFwZgZnOdUB1_ivzkhFiirQ&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjq0YqUpajlAhUGUK0KHbHxDNUQ6AEwCXoECAoQAQ#v=onepage&q=different%20sects%20understood%20the%20same%20passages&f=false
 
"What is it that inspires professors of Christianity generally with a hope of salvation? It is that smooth, sophisticated influence of the devil, by which he deceives the whole world" (Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, p.270).
Found in section 5 --> http://www.boap.org/LDS/Joseph-Smith/Teachings/T3.html  (search for 270)
 
 

Brigham Young stated this repeatedly:
"When the light came to me I saw that all the so-called Christian world was grovelling in darkness" (Journal of Discourses Section 5 page 73);
"The Christian world, so-called, are heathens as to the knowledge of the salvation of God" (Journal of Discourses  Section  8 page 171);
"With a regard to true theology, a more ignorant people never lived than the present so-called Christian world" (Journal of Discourses Section  8 page 199);
"Should you ask why we differ from other Christians, as they are called, it is simply because they are not Christians as the New Testament defines Christianity" (Journal of Discourses Section 10  page 230).
"And who is there that acknowledges [God's] hand? ...You may wander east, west, north, and south, and you cannot find it in any church or government on the earth, except the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints" (Journal of Discourses Section  6 page 24);
 
 
 
 

Orson Pratt also said:
"This great apostasy commenced about the close of the first century of the Christian era, and it has been waxing worse and worse from then until now" (Journal of Discourses , Section 18, page 44);
"But as there has been no Christian Church on the earth for a great many centuries past, until the present century, the people have lost sight of the pattern that God has given according to which the Christian Church should be established, and they have denominated a great variety of people Christian Churches, because they profess to be ...But there has been a long apostasy, during which the nations have been cursed with apostate churches in great abundance" (Journal of Discourses , Section 18 page 172).

 
President John Taylor stated:
"Christianity...is a perfect pack of nonsense...the devil could not invent a better engine to spread his work than the Christianity of the nineteenth century." (Journal of Discourses , Section 6 page 167);
"Where shall we look for the true order or authority of God? It cannot be found in any nation of Christendom." (Journal of Discourses , Section 10 page 127).
 

 
James Talmage said:
"A self-suggesting interpretation of history indicates that there has been a great departure from the way of salvation as laid down by the Savior, a universal apostasy from the Church of Christ". (A Study of the Articles of Faith, p.182).
 

 
President Joseph Fielding Smith said:
"Doctrines were corrupted, authority lost, and a false order of religion took the place of the gospel of Jesus Christ, just as it had been the case in former dispensations, and the people were left in spiritual darkness." (Doctrines of Salvation, p.266).
"For hundreds of years the world was wrapped in a veil of spiritual darkness, until there was not one fundamental truth belonging to the place of salvation ...Joseph Smith declared that in the year 1820 the Lord revealed to him that all the 'Christian' churches were in error, teaching for commandments the doctrines of men" (Doctrines of Salvation, vol. 3, p.282).
 

 
More recent statements by apostle Bruce McConkie are also very clear:
"Apostasy was universal...And this darkness still prevails except among those who have come to a knowledge of the restored gospel" (Doctrines of Salvation, vol 3, p.265);
"a perverted Christianity holds sway among the so-called Christians of apostate Christendom" (Mormon Doctrine, p.123);
"virtually all the millions of apostate Christendom have abased themselves before the mythical throne of a mythical Christ whom they vainly suppose to be a spirit essence who is incorporeal uncreated, immaterial and three-in-one with the Father and Holy Spirit" (Mormon Doctrine, p.250);
"Gnosticism is one of the great pagan philosophies which antedated Christ and the Christian Era and which was later commingled with pure Christianity to form the apostate religion that has prevailed in the world since the early days of that era." (Mormon Doctrine, p.290).
 
 
 
President George Q. Cannon said:
"After the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints was organized, there were only two churches upon the earth. They were known respectively as the Church of the Lamb of God and Babylon. The various organizations which are called churches throughout Christendom, though differing in their creeds and organizations, have one common origin. They all belong to Babylon" (Gospel Truth, p.324).  <-- can't find an onlink link, but there ARE a lot of hard copy books for sale tha tinclude this quote.
 
 
President Wilford Woodruff stated:
"the Gospel of modern Christendom shuts up the Lord, and stops all communication with Him. I want nothing to do with such a Gospel, I would rather prefer the Gospel of the dark ages, so called" (Journal of Discourses Section 2, page 196).

178 posted on 10/30/2019 4:11:55 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 46 | View Replies]

To: teppe
If you want to be a Christian .... start by acting like one.

If you want your claims to be accepted; then you'd better start posting some FACTS from what you 'reference'!


Frankly I have a copy of the Brigham Youngs discoursse ....

179 posted on 10/30/2019 4:13:36 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 50 | View Replies]

To: teppe
Do you have any sympathy for the Mormons murdered in NY, Ohio, Missouri and Illinois?

I guess that 'turn the other cheek' thing in your QUAD was part of the bad translating hinted about in the Mormon CREED.

180 posted on 10/30/2019 4:15:00 PM PDT by Elsie (Heck is where people, who don't believe in Gosh, think they are not going...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 51 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 141-160161-180181-200 ... 341-355 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson