Posted on 05/03/2006 5:13:08 AM PDT by SheLion
BATON ROUGE (AP) Louisiana restaurant patrons who want an after-dinner smoke should be forced to leave the dining room before lighting up, the full Senate decided today.
Senators approved Sen. Rob Marionneauxs plan to prohibit smoking in all restaurants dining areas but allow smoking in bars and casinos, cigar shops, and hotel and motel rooms. Marionneaux cited several polls conducted by anti-smoking groups showing that a majority of residents in Louisianas cities support such a ban.
Lets afford our citizens the right to have dinner with their families without the bother of second-hand smoke, said Marionneaux, D-Livonia.
The measure passed on a 36-2 vote. Sens. Heulette Clo Fontenot, R-Livingston, and Max Malone, R-Shreveport, opposed the bill, which now moves to the House.
If the bill becomes law, smoking would be outlawed in restaurants beginning in 2007.
Sen. Ken Hollis filed an amendment to allow smoking inside restaurants bar areas, if those bars are walled off from the dining area. Hollis said suddenly banning smokers from those areas could drive restaurants out of business, because their customers will go to bars where smoking is allowed.
This will hopefully keep some of our restaurants from going out of business, said Hollis, R-Metairie.
Marionneaux opposed the amendment, calling it a veiled attempt to kill the measure, by drawing further opposition from the restaurant industry. Restaurant owners have complained that the bill even without Hollis amendment gives tavern owners special treatment.
Senators approved Hollis amendment with a 23-15 vote, sending it to the House.
The bill was also amended by Sen. Diana Bajoie, D-New Orleans, who added an exemption aimed at helping New Orleans convention center attract business. The amendment would allow smoking at convention space during tobacco industry trade shows.
It would also allow smoking during Mardi Gras krewes parties held at a convention center.
Marionneaux introduced a similar plan last year that was voted down by the full Senate, partly because it included a provision to also outlaw smoking in casinos. This years version exempts casinos, eliminating opposition from the powerful gambling industry and improving its chances of eventually becoming law.
Point well taken. But I must say, I am in the health care industry and I see every day the toll smoking takes; in lives, health and yes cost. Its enormous. Any yes, I also see what the illegals are costing us by using the ERs as doctors offices.
Well, Maine forced a total smoking ban a few years ago, and lots of us do not go into restaurants or bars anymore. And a lot of businesses have closed. And that doesn't make the anti's reconsider. They could care less if a business can't make it or not. The won just by getting the ban through.
Well, I smoke and have for a long time. I enjoy it and I have my own health care insurance. If I ever get sick, no one will pay for me but me! Oh yes! Cigarettes are still legal. :)
Well, I don't know. The winters up here are long and hard. Makes it very difficult to go stand outside for a cigarette.
My front yard and a road on the other side of the tree.
You put the snow together with 60 mph bitter cold winds, and smoking outside becomes impossible.
You DO remember the takings clause from the Constitution, right?
Sure do. I think these owners should be reimbursed. Too bad the smoking fanatics disagree, they would at least have some progress on that front. I think they secretly want to lose this battle because they sure don't adopt winning strategies.
You forgot the part about a taking needing to be for a public use. There is NO constitutional allowance for these laws.
Sure there is. It is called states rights.
OHMYGOD! YOU DID IT! You surpassed even my expectations for greatness!!!!!HOW DO YOU DO IT?
I WANT YOU TO DO MY TAXES!
I get a red X from the picture.
From the previous post, you are saying that the bill of rights does not restrict the states' ability to take property (Kelo notwithstanding)?
Wow.
The constitution addresses property rights and states.
At least they can still smoke in bars.
At least that is something, right? Maine even took away smoking in bars. :(
Same here in Mass. I used to go into the bar area for a smoke.
"I think that if smokers were more courteous. non smokers would be more tolerant"
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.