Posted on 09/14/2023 1:49:09 PM PDT by nickcarraway
Whether it is a lion prowling the African savannah, a tiger catching prey in a forest in India or a domestic feline searching for mice in a back garden, cats are renowned as hunters – and carnivores.
Yet a newly published study claims domestic cats fed a vegan diet may be healthier than those who eat meat.
Prof Andrew Knight, a veterinary surgeon and professor of animal welfare at Griffith University in Australia, who led the study, said that “for every single general health indicator studied”, the cats included in the study “had better health outcomes when fed vegan diets”.
“It indicates that pet food manufacturers are now designing and creating vegan pet foods to include all necessary nutrients, but with fewer of the dietary hazards that are prevalent within meat-based pet foods,” he said.
Based on results from 1,369 cats, the research found that cats fed a vegan diet had seven per cent fewer visits to the vet, needed to be given 15 per cent less medication, were four per cent less likely to be assessed as unwell by a vet, and were eight per cent less likely to be recorded as seriously ill by a vet.
They were also 55 per cent less likely to be transitioned on to a medical diet because of health problems, were assessed as seriously ill by their owner 23 per cent less often and had 16 per cent fewer health disorders if unwell.
None of the reductions were statistically significant, but Prof Knight said that the findings nevertheless “reveal a strong trend”.
The results come despite advice from some veterinary organisations that cats should be fed meat or animal products.
Debate rages
In 2021, in response to a spike in media interest, the British Veterinary Association issued a statement saying that cats were obligate carnivores and should not be fed a vegetarian or vegan diet.
“They require animal-sourced ingredients to provide essential nutrients, such as taurine [an amino acid] and preformed vitamin A, which are minimal or even absent in plant ingredients,” the organisation stated.
Prof Knight said that vets “were understandably cautious about unconventional diets of all kinds” and is set to present what he described as “the wealth” of recent research on vegan diets for pets to the BVA.
Rather than requiring meat or other particular ingredients, he said that pets needed specific nutrients, so cats fed commercially available food labelled as being nutritionally complete for them should receive everything necessary.
Vegan food for cats is available and typically will contain taurine produced synthetically instead of being derived from animal ingredients.
“Manufactured nutritional supplements are designed to have the same nutritional content as those naturally occurring. Indeed, they may be of greater purity, with less contaminants,” he told The National.
In 2021 a study by other scientists looking at more than one thousand cats, some fed a vegan diet, found that levels of gastrointestinal and liver disorders were lower in the vegan animals. These pets also had better body condition scores.
Aside from possible health benefits and animal welfare concerns over livestock farming, Prof Knight said that a vegan diet for cats may also be preferable because of the environmental impact of rearing animals.
The UN’s Food and Agriculture Organisation has reported that livestock farming contributes 14.5 per cent of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions.
“The global population of kept cats has been estimated at 373 million. Such a huge population has a major ‘ecological pawprint’ when fed meat,” Prof Knight said.
“There are very large environmental benefits offered by vegan pet food, as well as better health outcomes.”
Eat recycled food. It’s good for the environment and ok for you!
Try it and they will kill you in your sleep
There is no debate. Cats must eat food made from other animals. The study has no value. Just ask your cat.
TOTAL COMPLETE BS! As a cat person for a long time this story has NO merit.
Yeah, no.
Kitty litter
I had a mouse problem. My traps were catching mice every single week. I had always had stray cats, but always ran them off. I stopped doing that. I don’t feed them, but they have the run of the place.
No more mice. None.
I recently learned that there are vegan options in nail polish. They cost about twice as much, and I use nail polish to make fishing lures more enticing, so it’s a “no” from me.
I read several years ago that feral domestic cats “wild” diet was about 70% grasshoppers because they were easy to catch and actually nutritious.
Hey, if the left can reprogram nature and turn boys into girls, then the EnviroKooks can reprogram nature and turn cats into herbivores.
If you want it to happen, believe it will happen, and it will happen. That’s how leftist reality works.
Oy vey.
Cats are carnivores
What are we supposed to be saving cows pigs and sheep for? Assisted living? A quality existence in their golden years? Extinction?
So misguided
Jesus ate meat. He is the Lamb of God sacrificed for our watched souls sacrificed like people of that time who raised, killed and ate sheep
We’ve evolved? Cats are evolved? We can teach Jesus a thing or two?
We are constantly finding out new things which change our previous views. Consider baby formula: when they started it in the 1920s, they didn’t know about a gazillion things that are in breast milk. We learned more, improved the formula, and still babies do better if they are breastfed.
The inclusion of actual stuff the pets eat, such as meat and fish in cat and dog food, sanahorias para los conejos, etc. will probably be shown to be better in the long run. I notice the study did not say they took differences in environment, etc., into account.
Correct. As the result of a relatively short digestive tract (compared to the canine group), they need animal protein as a majority (70+%) of their food source. Their systems cannot process vegetable protein very well.
Fake study by fake people.
You absolutely know my Daisy, little witch of a cat. Her way or the highway. Plus she bites me when I disobey. I’d be rendered to hamburger meat if I gave her a carrot or cheerios.
IIRC, they eat grass to make themselves puke up them hairballs.
It’s why they have the teeth they do
Bull crap. When I was a child we had a cat that was indoors at night and outdoors during the day. We stopped feeding him because he no longer ate inside. I was the one stuck with “remains removal”, as he would take his kill home to the back patio and I had to clean up what was leftover. That was a domesticated cat. I highly doubt wild cats are much different.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.