Posted on 06/06/2023 11:29:33 AM PDT by Jan_Sobieski
A federal judge sided Tuesday with families who sued over Florida’s ban on gender transition procedures for minors, declaring that “gender identity is real.”
A group of families, backed by several LGBT activist groups, sued Florida in March shortly after the rule restricting minors from accessing surgical sex change procedures, puberty blockers and hormone therapy took effect. Northern District of Florida Judge Robert L. Hinkle, a Clinton appointee, granted a preliminary injunction against the law to prohibit it from being enforced against the plaintiffs, arguing that the “great weight of medical authority supports these treatments.”
Hinkle repeatedly stressed the reality of “gender identity” in his ruling.
“With extraordinarily rare exceptions not at issue here, every person is born with external sex characteristics, male or female, and chromosomes that match,” he wrote. “As the person goes through life, the person also has a gender identity—a deeply felt internal sense of being male or female...”
(Excerpt) Read more at wnd.com ...
Judge Hinkle, DNA denier.
I think this is the ruling that actually has, in writing, the verbiage “put up or shut up”. A judge (Clinton-appointed, I think) wrote that. How not professional.
Gender identity is NOT real!
Nomoreso than Napoleonic identity is “real”
Feddy “judges” always side with the far-left, sicko, cuckoos against the decent people. Their “decisions” have nothing to do with the laws or morals. They are just a bunch of “if it feels good, do it” lowlifes.
What an idiot judge. He is making an unqualified declaration. How can such a ruling stand? He should be dragged out of town.
“gender identity is real.”
Then the delusions of madmen must also be real. So the next time someone declares themselves to be Napoleon Bonaparte, we must honor our treaty obligations and go to war against his enemies...
So I guess this clinton appointed judge, would say if a kid identified as as a duck ,he would write “duck identity is real”.
Norway joins other countries banning so-called gender-affirming care
“I see this kind of thing as a major camel nose in the tent for something. And whatever that something is, it isn’t good in any way, shape, or form.”
That something will be “But your honor, the seven year old consented to have sexual relations with me. I have it right here on video!”
In all cases where a State is a party to the action, the Supreme Court SHALL have Original Jurisdiction.
Tell the judge of the inferior court to POUND SAND then go to a Grand Jury and INDICT him for usurping the Rights of a Free State in direct violation of the US Constitution.
I guess the answer to that is : prove it.
That is your opinion judge. You can’t rule on your opinion.
Impeach and disbar the idiot.
Your honor, I have substantial reasons to doubt my masculinity. I was shortchanged in the genetic shuffle, therefore I have a mental need to carry a big, long rifle.
The state law requiring me to pass a background check impedes my ability to do so. The State of Florida says I have a severe mental illness and says I should have mental treatment instead of a big, long rifle.
It is real, but it is a mental illness.
Said judge should be hung by the neck until he is dead, Dead, DEAD.
Enough of this nonsensical BS. It’s time for a Hot Civil War. There are just a bunch of freaks that need killing, IMO.
Does the federal judge really mean to say that gender identity is a real mental disorder?
There are two sexes, male and female. The word gender melds a range of temperaments and personalities into a confusing array of meaningless categories.
Perhaps the judge wants to be like the recent supreme court member who cannot define what a woman is because she did not take a course in biology or something like that.
Should this judge recuse him or herself?
States can regulate medical treatment.
Many states have outlawed gay conversion therapy.
States can prevent a doctor from opening up a hospital.
States can outlaw doctor-assisted suicides.
States can and do quite often block doctors from giving the most effective pain-relieving drugs to people in pain.
States can block a doctor from giving opiates to a drug addict to prevent opiate withdrawal distress.
States regulating opiates helped cause over 100,000 excess deaths from fentanyl in the past few years.
The states were fundamental to the crafting and envelope of our Constitution.
They held a place so important that any case involving them went right to Scotus.
Except, now they don’t.
Repeal the 17th Amendment to restore the Framers’ Constitution.
The left will soon be unable to reproduce in another generation or two, which will end this topic of insanity.
Years ago I watched a very powerful documentary from Sweden. Much more poised and serious than Matt Walsh’s “What is a Woman”. But it had several of the same themes - talking to gender “experts” and how ridiculous their claims were.
Had a detransitioned girl (girl to boy to girl again) as a continual thread linking the film together. Below is the film. Professional filming, English subtitles, REALLY well done (about an hour long).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDV-ZL6-Gu0&t=313s
It was THAT video that caused Sweden to take a step back from transitioning people so quickly. I believe that one can still do it if they go through a long period of REAL pyschotherapy. (What is now outlawed in many states in the USA and considered “conversion therapy”.)
I pray that as these European countries were some of the first to go all in on medical transitioning but are now putting the brakes on it, the USA will follow. The recent new laws in various states to stop it are promising.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.