Posted on 04/10/2023 5:55:21 AM PDT by Red Badger
Farmington police chief: Officers shoot, kill wrong man
The home at 5305 Valley View Ave., where Robert Dotson, 52, was shot and killed. (Debra Mayeux/The Journal)
The day after Farmington Police Chief Steve Hebbe announced in a video statement that officers shot and killed Robert Dotson, members of his tight-knit neighborhood remembered him as the rope that tied everyone together.
Neighbors were shocked and saddened by an April 5 police-involved shooting that left Dotson dead. He was 52.
Shortly before midnight Wednesday, police officers responded to the wrong house during an investigation of a reported domestic abuse. They were called to 5308 Valley View Ave., but ended up at 5305 Valley View Ave., where Dotson lived with his family.
When Dotson answered the door with a firearm in hand, “officers fired at least one round from their duty weapon(s), striking Mr. Dotson,” according to a New Mexico State Police investigation. Dotson died at the scene.
The Dotsons moved into their home at 5305 Valley View about five years ago and quickly became friends with everyone on the block, according to several neighbors.
“They were awesome, amazing people,” neighbor and friend Krystal Rahm said about the family. “Everyone on the street is close knit. All of our kids know each other. They play sports together.”
Rahm characterized Robert as “super-helpful.”
The home at 5308 Valley View Ave., the correct location of the domestic violence call on April 5 that led to officers mistakenly approaching the home of Robert Dotson, at 5305 Valley View Ave.
Will Richardson, who lives across the street from Dotson, agreed, saying whenever he was out working in his yard, Robert would come over and ask if he could help. “He was a great guy,” Richardson said. “I can’t say enough good things about Kim (Dotson’s wife) and Robert. They were always watching out for everyone.”
Dotson even saved Richardson’s dog. The animal become trapped in an inflatable pool and was unable to escape. Dotson went to the home and managed to rescue the animal before it drowned.
“He was absolutely a great guy,” Richardson said.
On Wednesday, Hebbe said in a video statement on social media that officers made attempts to identify themselves as police officers while trying to make contact Dotson before he was shot.
“Mr. Dotson was not the subject of the call that our officers were responding to, and this ending is just unbelievably tragic. I’m extremely sorry that we are in this position,” Hebbe said.
Police said Dotson’s wife then fired a handgun from the door. Officers returned fire, and she put the gun down and complied with officers’ commands.”
Shanice Gonzales, spokesperson for FPD, said the original domestic violence call was investigated and “everybody is OK.”
Rahm described the scene that shook the neighborhood Wednesday night.
“There were lights everywhere,” she said.
When she left for work Thursday morning, there were “a lot” of police vehicles, both from FPD and New Mexico State Police, that were blocking off the street and nearby roads.
New Mexico State Police and Farmington Police were on scene all day Thursday, and New Mexico State Police was leading the investigation.
The names of the officers involved in the shooting have not been released. Police plan to release body camera video of the incident after officer statements are collected.
I was raised in a very rural area. If someone knocks on your door past 10 pm, you should have a gun in your hand.............
“We gave up on ‘answering the door’ to strangers”
I agree. At MIDNIGHT you open your door? Nuts.
Moving forward, for those of us still alive ...
How do we give legal notice to local PD, local sheriff, etc
Notice that they are not welcome on our property and that the property owner is armed and LEO cannot bring firearms onto my property. Do not expect to knock or no-knock on my property after dark with receiving priority verbal permission on the phone or text.
etc etc
There must be a legal workaround for patriots to avoid this ‘accidentally’ being shot and killed crap we observe here.
The libs want to take all our guns away so we can’t open a door with a gun in our hand ... this will save our lives when they keep us from having any guns. It’s for our safety.
“answered the door with a firearm in hand”
Not enough information. Was he POINTING the gun? or just holding it at his side?
YUGE difference.
“Police said Dotson’s wife then fired a handgun from the door. Officers returned fire, and she put the gun down and complied with officers’ commands.””
Was this a “gun happy couple?
OR
Did this neighborhood warrant such actions?
This story is a POS. Urinalists!
Bullhorns?........................
A Capitol policeman shot Ashli Babbitt and she was holding a flag. He is free as a bird because he knows to many details about the planning of the defense (or lack thereof) of the capitol on J6.
Well, that really wasn’t in “Texas”. It was in Austin...which is like Texas, but only stupider and weirder (by choice)!
> Not enough information. Was he POINTING the gun? or just holding it at his side? <
That’s obviously an important question. Maybe I’m just too suspicious. But if this guy were actually pointing the gun, wouldn’t the cops have made that very clear in their statements to the press?
Jesse jackson/al sharpton didn’t swoop down on the town. There was no riot, no looting. No one tried to burn the police station down. So I can safely conclude that Robert Dotson was White, and that his life didn’t matter.
Many homeowners fail to post their address clearly on the house/ mailbox/ driveway.
People need to understand that first responders—cops, firemen, paramedics— need to find the correct address quickly.
Regardless whether the address was or wasn’t visible, the first duty of cops is always to determine where the threat is located.
The Defund crowd wants cops to have even less training, which virtually guarantees more of these incidents will occur.
“I’m extremely sorry that we are in this position...”
Well that’s comforting but how about hiring literate cops!
I don’t know why the pic won’t post, must be a software block, but the house number is plainly visible right beside the front door. See pic at link..............................
Learn to check who is at your door before opening it!!!
If it had been an armed thug at his door, opening it armed would still be a tactical disadvantage.
Did this neighborhood warrant such actions?
Many homeowners fail to post their address clearly on the house/ mailbox/ driveway.
Next excuse?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.