Posted on 07/10/2020 9:44:25 AM PDT by Signalman
The superintendent of the City Schools of Decatur, a district of metropolitan Atlanta, secretly instituted a gender identity policy in 2016 allowing students of both sexes to enter any bathroom they chose. In November 2017, a kindergarten girl was allegedly sexually assaulted in her Decatur school bathroom by a boy who was allowed to be there because of that policy.
After reporting the assault to district officials but getting little response, the girl’s mother, Pascha Thomas, filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR). OCR’s recently released findings illustrate the dangers and deception inherent in maintaining trans-promoting school policies that defy scientific reality and common sense.
On June 19, 2020, OCR concluded that the Decatur school district had violated Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 by failing to investigate and respond appropriately to Thomas’ sexual assault complaint. OCR’s findings reveal school officials were so deeply invested in transgender ideology, they failed to investigate the assault, tried to sweep the problem under the rug, and actively misled local parents about what had happened and what it meant for their children’s safety.
Under Title IX, a school district must investigate all claims of sex discrimination, including sexual harassment and assault, in its schools. This duty is non-delegable. In other words, the district can’t push it off on some other entity and wash its hands of the matter. But, as OCR found, this is exactly what the district had done.
A Flimsy Investigation Rather than investigate the complaint, the district notified the Georgia Division of Family and Children Services (DFCS) and the police via the school resource officer. But DFCS’s legal mandate is to investigate child abuse and neglect in the context of caregivers, not schools.
So DFCS limited its inquiry to investigating and dismissing the school’s allegations that the victim’s mother provided inadequate supervision — a shameful attempt by educrats to deflect attention from the school assault. The police also immediately declined to pursue an assault case because of the ages of the children involved.
This was the extent of the investigation the victim received. As OCR found, “The District then took no further steps to determine what occurred” and “failed to ascertain anything about DFCS’s findings concerning the alleged incident.” Nor did it even notify Thomas about the outcome of these supposed investigations: “Apart from a general public announcement [denying it happened] … the District has never communicated to the parties the outcome of any investigation” into the incident.
The district contented itself with transferring the alleged victim, not the perpetrator, from the classroom and then to a different school and declaring the problem resolved. Maybe district officials gambled that they could simply ignore the complaint, that an African-American single mom of limited means, faced with the cold intimidation of educrats with big titles and big offices, would just go away. The goal of preserving the politically correct but reckless policy was apparently worth the risk.
And what about that policy? From the beginning of this drama, the district has insisted the policy was irrelevant, that the boy was never in the girls’ bathroom. But as OCR found, even his parents told school officials he may have been there because he used the girls’ bathroom in the past, with no objection by the officials. Indeed, his parents claimed he had been harassed in both the girls’ and boys’ bathrooms but that school officials had ignored his complaints as well.
All of this suggests a Wild West approach to district schools’ allegedly private facilities that OCR found troubling:
In light of this danger, OCR slammed the district’s indifferent response to multiple complaints about abuse in the school bathrooms:
Given the serious nature of the reports of harassment reportedly occurring in school bathrooms, one might have anticipated the District would be extra vigilant in providing a proper response under Title IX. Instead, OCR found no evidence that the District assessed the existence of sexual harassment despite the incident reflected in the Report, the concerns of parents expressed in the aftermath of the Report, and the allegations that [the boy] had been harassed in the boys’ bathroom.
Roots of Deceit Perhaps as troubling as the district’s non-response to the sexual assault complaints of Thomas and others was its actively misleading communications with other alarmed parents and the entire school community.
The district’s problematic bathroom policy was grounded in deception from the beginning. The superintendent conceived and implemented the policy in the dark, with no formal notice to parents and no public discussion or vote by the local school board. OCR found that when the alleged kindergarten assault occurred and parents demanded answers about their children’s safety, the district continued to mislead.
One parent was told “the rumors regarding an assault were not true.” Another parent, who was so concerned she checked her daughter out of school, was told “the ‘event’ had been investigated and ‘found to not have taken place.’” But as OCR concluded, no one — especially no school official — had even investigated the incident, much less determined it had never taken place.
The school principal’s public statement to the school community continued the mendacity. “Although an incident was alleged,” the principal wrote, “a thorough investigation involving [school] administrators, central office staff, law enforcement, and social service agencies led us to confidently determine that the allegation was unfounded.” This statement was flatly untrue.
Reacting to the OCR findings, the district still clings to its dangerous bathroom policy by saying OCR failed to substantiate the claims of the young victim. OCR never said this, however. Instead, OCR cited conflicts in determining the precise date of the incident, which it could not resolve given that the assailant’s parents could not be contacted and the incident was never investigated at the time it happened.
OCR was sufficiently persuaded of the mess in district schools, however, and mandated the district thoroughly investigate and document all “alleged incidents of sexual harassment of students in School bathrooms, including any allegations of harassment associated with the Policy” during the two-year period including and following the incident.
See You in Court OCR’s finding of a Title IX violation will bolster Thomas’ federal lawsuit, the first suit in the nation seeking to hold a school district accountable for demonstrable harm inflicted on a girl because a biological boy was allowed into her private space. The parents of City Schools of Decatur students warned this kind of thing would happen, and now it has.
Policies founded in untruth cannot be maintained in an open and honest environment. They must be cloaked in deception to prevent backlash from parents who don’t want their children sacrificed to political correctness. Thomas has been lied to enough, and now she’s fighting for her daughter in court. School officials everywhere, take note.
All I can say to this is, they are lucky it was not my grand daughter because whether or not they will be held responsible would not be settled for them on this planet.
Everyone pray for our nation and our children. I am sickened by this. Everyone should be!!
At my son’s school, they changed all the boy’s bathrooms to coed but not the girls’.
When I complained, the headmaster said it was to minimize lawsuits in case something happened to the girls’ bathroom.
IN the girls’ bathroom.
Oh well...boys (who say they are girls) will be boys after all! Just a harmless little game of “doctor”. Nothing to see here. /sarc
I knew of a case of rape in one of the high schools near Houston. The principal wanted to deal with it as a school discipline issue. Did not inform the police. He did not want the rape recorded under his watch.
No Shit!
The Left is quite willing to sacrifice children at the alter of its LGBTetc gods.
Yeah, but trans is part of the LGBTXYZ crowd which is very much in favor with the democrat party, so a few raped kids don’t matter to the dems. And they’ll put you in jail if you object to using their preferred pronouns.
BFL
keep letting democrats get their way and our world is doomed. This is a good example.
This nonsense will continue unless the scum that created this policy are fired and destroyed! We need myriad examples of scumbags who are fired, sued, and destroyed. You know. Like the rats do.
One more thing. Nobody can be allowed to resign from a criminal investigation! Never! EVER!
I was in the City of Decatur schools in the mid to 1960s and they were very liberal at that time too. They went from still segregated at the end of the 64-65 school year to hard core liberal as soon as integration began slowly in the 65-66 school year.
Unpossible! We were promised this would never happen & called bigots for mentioning the possibility.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.