Skip to comments.Nuclear disaster: How prepared are we?
Posted on 01/04/2020 9:22:35 PM PST by BenLurkin
Perhaps the newest and most relevant is the higher probability of a nuclear weapon falling in the hands of a terrorist group or rogue state, such as Iran or North Korea, as opposed to a nuclear attack by another recognized nuclear weapons state. As Dr. Irwin Redlener, a professor at Columbia Universitys Mailman School of Public Health, explained: the rogue state and the terrorist detonation remain a possibility and should be considered among the most serious disaster threats that the United States faces. Despite the reality of such a nuclear attack, the United States remains largely unprepared.
In 1950, United States Congress created the Federal Civil Defense Administration (FCDA), to guide states actions in regards to civil defense policy. As such, FCDA was largely responsible for the first nuclear shelters. In 1952, the FCDA - with the help of the Ad Council - created nine different short films about preparedness. These films included the famous Duck and Cover drill with Bert the Turtle, which portrayed students saving themselves from a nuclear attack by hiding underneath their school desks. Today, these films are seen as ill-informed, and even were used to make a 1982 satirical film, Atomic Cafe, about the misinformation the United States government gave to American soldiers and citizens in the early years of the Cold War.
During the early 1950s, the FCDA also encouraged Americans to begin building at-home nuclear fallout shelters. Each shelter was supposed to have at least two weeks of supplies, the recommended amount of time for staying in the shelter after an attack. At the time, however, Congress and the Executive Branch did not directly support this initiative due to the prohibitive cost of creating a system of nuclear fallout shelters across the country.
Following the Soviet Unions test of the hydrogen bomb in 1953 and the release by the United States of the effects of its first thermonuclear bomb (hydrogen bomb) test, Mike, detonated in the Enewetak Atoll in the Marshall Islands in 1952, the Eisenhower administration determined that shelter programs were no longer effective and instituted evacuation plans instead. Both hydrogen bomb tests effects seemed to convince the public that it was not possible to survive a nuclear detonation, unless people were warned in advance of the attack. Evacuation planning over shelter planning was, though, only proposed by the FCDA until March 1954, right after the United States tested its most powerful hydrogen bomb, Castle Bravo. Bravo was tested on Bikini Atoll in the Marshall Islands and had a yield 1,000 times higher than the Hiroshima bomb. The testing resulted in severe radioactive contamination of numerous islands, which continues to impact the Marshallese society today. This occurrence led Congress and the FCDA to determine again that shelters were necessary for citizens protection.
The FCDA proposed a National Shelter Policy, which according to Homeland Security would have cost around $32 billion. The necessity of this policy was supported by the Gaither Report, commissioned by President Eisenhower in 1957, and, the Rockefeller Report in 1958, lead by Henry Kissinger. Evidence presented in these two reports, though, was not enough for President Eisenhower, who refused to take action towards enacting the policy. Instead, he replaced the FCDA with the newly created the Office of Civil and Defense Mobilization (OCDM), which eventually became the Office of Civil Defense (OCD) and the Office of Emergency Planning (OEM).
With the election of a new president, John F. Kennedy, shelters resurfaced as an important element of civil defense against a nuclear attack as the United States government directly advocated for and funded nuclear fallout shelters. In September of 1961, The Community Fallout Shelter Program began, following an extensive survey to determine shelter locations. Each shelter had to be able to serve at least fifty people, who were given a storage space of 1 cubic foot. The program set out to supply local shelter sites with materials to defend against the effects of radiation. The OCD allocated water drums, food rations, sanitation kits, medical kits, radiation detectors, and package ventilation kits to each of the shelters, which were directly run and maintained by local governments civil defense offices. In October, Kennedy asked Congress to allot $100 million to create public fallout shelters across the country. By the end of 1961, the Department of Defense had created a 46-page booklet about the shelters, including instructions of what to do if a nuclear attack occurred. These booklets were distributed to post offices across the country. According to the Department of Homeland Security, by the end of 1963, nine million public shelters had been identified and supplied.
On October 6th, 1961, President Kennedy also encouraged American families to begin building private nuclear bomb shelters in their homes. This effort arguably proved less successful than the public shelters effort, since only about 1.4% of American families implemented President Kennedys message.
During President Lyndon B. Johnsons administration (1965 to 1969), the shelter program and civil defense initiatives began to suffer. The Vietnam War drew money away from these preparedness programs and initiatives, and the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction (MAD) became more popular. If a country decided to initiate a nuclear attack on another country, both countries would end up annihilated based on this theory of deterrence and retaliation.
Initiatives to directly protect civilians did not re-emerge until President Gerald R. Fords administration. The 1974 Crisis Relocation Plan (CRP) created evacuation routes for those who lived in the cities to escape to rural areas. Unfortunately, CRP had many flaws, since multiple days notice of an attack would have been required for it to work effectively. Additionally, urban infrastructure would not have supported mass evacuation from cities.
Preparedness for a nuclear disaster became a top priority for a final time under President Ronald Reagans administration (1981 to 1989). Following the creation of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) under President Jimmy Carter, President Reagan made nuclear disaster preparedness plans and evacuation routes a top priority, by asking Congress to allocate $4.2 billion for civil defense spending. While congress only allocated $147.9 million to the cause, this push for civil defense nuclear planning became the last of its kind to this day, following the end of the Cold War shortly after the end of the Reagan administration.
In the post- Cold War era (1991- today) the United States, along with other nations, faces a new kind of nuclear threat. During the Cold War, the United States main nuclear opponent was the Soviet Union. Today, the United States faces a threat of a nuclear disaster not only from other countries, such as North Korea, Iran, or other rogue nations, but also from terrorist groups, who could easily access the materials and information necessary to construct a nuclear weapon. In addition, one cannot dismiss the possibility of a disaster stemming from accidental use of weapons currently in the United States own arsenal or other countries arsenals.
One threat facing the world today is missing weapons-grade materials from the old Soviet nuclear stockpile. In order to build a nuclear weapon, one would need plutonium (Pu 239) or highly-enriched uranium (HEU), uranium with a concentration of U235 higher than 20%. During unstable economic times, former Soviet nuclear personnel used to sell HEU on the side. The Soviet Union never created an inventory list of its nuclear materials, so most of the material that was and is stolen during and after the Cold War isnt known to be missing. Between 1991 and 2002, there were fourteen confirmed cases of theft of weapons-useable nuclear material from Russias nuclear stockpile. Russia currently has 680 metric tons of HEU, over half of the total amount that exists in the world. According to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), a significant quantity of HEU, meaning the approximate amount of nuclear material for which the possibility of manufacturing a nuclear explosive device cannot be excluded, is 25 kg or 55.1 lbs. Since Russia does not disclose its plutonium stockpile to the IAEA, it is unknown how much the nation currently possesses. According to the IAEA, a significant quantity of plutonium is 8 kg or 17.6 lbs.
The uncertainty surrounding unguarded weapons-useable nuclear material is not limited to Russia. In 2007, six nuclear warheads were accidentally flown from an Air Force Base in North Dakota to Louisiana. The warheads were missing for 24 hours before officials in Louisiana discovered the error.
According to the Federation of American Scientists, there are over 14,000 declared nuclear warheads in the world today, and given the yet to be successful intentions for a world free of nuclear weapons, the threat of a nuclear disaster still looms large. As Dr. Redlener states: There is no putting the toothpaste back in the tube here. . I cannot imagine circumstances where we can get verifiable information of elimination of all nuclear weapons on the planet. I think we do have to come to grips with that and make sure that we have done everything possible to control any situation that might result in a nuclear detonation.
While it may seem unlikely that a person could survive a nuclear attack, there are seven simple actions that one can take to save his or her life - assuming that one is far enough (more than .5 miles away) from the core of the explosion. They are: (1) Do not stare at the light from the flash because it will blind a person instantly, and keep your mouth open to handle the pressure released from the initial blast. (2) Decide to move ten to twenty minutes walking distance away from the blast site or seek shelter either below ground or above the 9th floor of a building, to avoid the effects of fallout from the mushroom cloud. (3) Move crosswind from damaged buildings if you choose to leave, but only for 10-20 minutes. (4) Keep your mouth, skin, and nose covered as much as possible. (5) Remove your clothes, rinse off with a hose, while holding your breath. Seek medical care if possible. (6) Stay in the shelter for 12-24 hours after an attack to avoid the initial massive amount of exposure to radiation after a nuclear attack, or as long as instructed by the government. Only leave shelter once you know the direction to move.
Despite the fact that cities and citizens remain unprepared, research has been done on the effectiveness of these steps. According to Dr. Redlener, Brooke Buddemeier at Livermore National Labs in California has done a great deal of research on this subject [nuclear preparedness and survival]. He suggests that if a single-weapon detonation occurred in New York City, some 200,000 or more lives could be saved, if people knew how to protect themselves. That means knowing how and when to find adequate shelter and when its safe to leave the shelter.
In order for these steps to be as effective as Buddemeiers research suggests everyone would need to know them before an attack occurred. According to Dr. Redlener, Its all about understanding and following the basic message: Get as far away from the blast as you can in the first 10 20 minutes after the flash of light and explosion, go to a safe shelter, away from windows with lots of shielding between you and the outside and stay there for 12 24 hours or until officials say its safe to exit. Make sure you have a battery operated radio in order to receive those messages! But as Dr. Redlener points out, even getting that message out there is something that, if it was going to be effective, it would have to be repeated multiple times and with lots of reminders going out overtime. You would need a campaign, and posters, and public service announcements, elected officials talking about it. I don't think that anyone is in the frame of mind to do that.
I have a pack of those potassium iodide pills so I’m good. They even protect me from a direct H-bomb hit I think.
But the rest of you are screwed.
031-503-1018 (SL1) - React to Nuclear Hazard/Attack
Conditions: You are in a tactical situation or an area where nuclear
weapons have been or may have been used and
are given load-bearing equipment (LBE), a
piece of cloth or similar item, a brush or a
broom, shielding material, Field Manual (FM) 3-3-1,
and one of the following situations to
You see a brilliant flash of light.
React to a nuclear hazard or attack without
becoming a casualty of a nuclear attack with
or without warning.
Identify radiological contamination
markers with 100 percent accuracy, and
notify the supervisor.
Start the steps to decontaminate
yourself within 1 minute of finding
Decontaminate your individual
equipment after you completely decontaminate
1. React to a
nuclear attack without warning.
Close your eyes
Drop to the ground in a
prone, head-on position.
If you are in the hatch of an
armored vehicle, immediately drop down
inside the vehicle.
More at link
Don’t look at the explosion.
Piece of cake.
Nothing to see here anyway :)
Instinct to see what the heck is going on before you know it’s a nuke will be troublesome.
I appreciate its always good to be refreshed on this stuff. But Iran would only nuke Israel. It would be easier and they could take a lot of Jew with them. Arabs too. But who ever they hit, Tehran would be a parking lot within an hour.
The next narrative: Trump is making the world unsafe for your children.
Grab your cell phone take a selfie of yourself kissing the camera. Check to make sure you got a good pic, then stick it in your back pocket and have a beer. Oh and say good night dick
Psst. Sorry to break it to you. You got the placebo. Everyone else got the real thing. But we needed a guinea pig.
One does not prepare for horrendous catastrophe. One finds ways to live through it, or not.
Why, flash is the savior of the universe. Ah ah!
*sigh* I miss the good old days, when a nuclear attack was such a simpler thing to deal with. Some dry goods, a root cellar, a bolt action rifle, SPF 5000 sunscreen........even the blast was in black and white.
I apologize in advance for any earworms. This is advanced brain control going on right here.
Here Comes Flash
Dirty bombs come in next, more a weapon of fear than actual deaths. And damn easy to make to cause a heck of a lot of fear.
These are all in the terrorists’ play books, have been used by both individual cells and nation states, and with our borders so porous to fuel the cheap labor express (as well as the war on drugs - hard to have a war without something to fight over...) it'd be dang easy to import whatever can't be bought at the local salvage yard or chemical warehouse.
Oh, yes, of course there's more elaborate plans; we know because we've caught some of them already. People checking out dams and power plants, checking out infrastructure lines that form the backbones of the internet and communications, server farms - heck, even national currency repositories.
But odds are it'll be some cheap stolen van bought on Facebook that’ll deliver a mass casualty event to a heavily populated urban area (and even more likely two or more at the same time.)
The nuclear attack option is great for Hollywood and strategic planning groups. You can even pick likely locations for attack and do as we've done, set up radiation monitors to hopefully detect a bomb before the attack.
But it is also the least likely form, as so much of it requires specialized equipment and knowledge. And while a ‘Broken Arrow’ type incident is possible, security around everyone’s nuclear weapons makes it improbable.
But how hard would it be to get a van with mustard gas down Colorado Blvd while hundreds of thousands gather overnight before the Rose Parade? Or to deliver sarin to the mass of lines waiting to get into the Super Bowl?
Civil defense means that everything else has failed. Our border security, our intelligence services, even our police forces - all have to utterly fail before CD comes into play. FEMA’s known about the risks; if you actually review the material on FEMA’s site about protecting your home during an incident, it isn't about protecting against nuclear radiation, but from dirty bombs and gas delivery systems.
And truth be told, even the most aware person will gain little by having intimate knowledge of all these procedures. The greatest damage will be done in the first few minutes and be very binary, either you were severely injured or killed, or you made it out alive.
If we're to invest in anything, it isn't pamphlets about emergency preparedness, it is in identifying those who intend us harm and getting that knowledge to authorities who will act on it.
** I have a pack of those potassium iodide pills so Im good. They even protect me from a direct H-bomb hit I think. ***
No, no. I spent part of my childhood at Sandia. You just need to get under a desk, place your right arm, and hand across the back of your neck, close your eyes tightly, then place your left hand over your closed eyes.
Also, drink the water from the toilet tank, and eat the canned goods from the lead box in the garage.
What are those funny little can openers called that go with the food in the drab olive green colored cans?
I know the army would not have lied to all of us at Wherry School.
Yep, not a big deal. Mapped out the sewers and overpasses, even the ditch with the old tree to block the blast from the DC direction if I couldnt product the timing and needed to dive where I could around where I lived. I was 8. Still do today. Lol
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.