American Idol 2009--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | 3-17-09

[silent_jonny]

.

For Ladyinred

[Wolfstar]

Paula: Authentic ... authenticity ... authentic-tic.

LOLOLOLOL!!!

Matt has talent. He just hasn't picked the right songs for him until tonight. Glad to hear he did good.

[wtc911]

Think Lil Rounds is going home tomorrow night.

----------------------------------------

The producers will not whack the only Black contestant. She's safe for at least six more weeks.

[TonyWpi]

Tonight’s recap is easy:

Best:
Alison
Alexis

Worst:
Adam, Rounds, Megan

Everyone else...somewhere in the middle.

[peggybac]

Just watched the first elimination on DWTS.

[retrokitten]

I’m actually a fan of what is more or less bellydancing music (I blame my Greek genes) and like music with that exotic vibe. BUT, Adam’s song was creepy as all get out.

[freedumb2003]

>>Worst of the night—beyond a doubt: Adam Lambert. What he did to that song was disgusting. The whole thing was evil.

Lil Rounds and Alexis weren’t very good.

My guess is Alexis is in danger of going home.
<<

We can WISH for Adam to go. And, of course, I will be rooting for Little Rounds (LOL) to go asap.

But the voting calculus suggests you are right.

[nufsed]

Ah switching from patronizing to direct attack. Thanx I'll think about it.

OK I did. I didn't ask your permission to come here. I didn't ask the clique to attack me. The moderator has left me here despite your attempt to have me banned.

Here's a deal, don't post to me and I won't post to you. Otherwise mind your own business.

[Miss Didi]

Adam’s Ring of Fire was hideous.

[silent_jonny]

Glad you found us, LOL

Are you on the ping list?

[nufsed]

I would put Scott near the bottom. His voice has been consistently weak. I think his best performance was the orignial audition.

[silent_jonny]

Aaahhh.... love that new thread smell.

LOL!

[TonyWpi]

Vote for Alexis...

She was great and deserves saving!

[kjam22]

Watching that again now. If Zepplin had done that we’d all be thinking it was a great remake. The kid is a flamer... but that was a cool remake. Now Mrs KJAM22 hated hated hated it. I think it was pretty creative.

[TurtleStink]

dial idol has alexis with a big lead.

[Wolfstar]

Worst of the night--beyond a doubt: Adam Lambert. What he did to that song was disgusting. The whole thing was evil.

Jonny, there is truly a very dark, scary side to Lambert. It's obvious in his eyes. Something dangerous is there.

[nufsed]

Your 620 is an example of what’s seriously wrong with you. You need to check yourself out. I apologized to someone else. You must have a very high opinion of your self to judge that and respond. You’ve called me names and tried to scoot me out. Here’s an idea STFU!

[Lil'freeper]

Michael Sarver I really enjoyed the harmonica.

Allison The Red Iraheta Reba, eat your heart out. This gal's a talented cutie. Solid performance

Kris the Tender Dawg huh? I stepped out of the room and missed it. Except that I didn't really miss anything.

Big Rounds Her dress looks like a folded dinner napkin. Nice performance. Would be completely forgettable if it weren't so funny that a likely Obama voter was singing one of Hannity's theme songs.

Flambert Haha... Randy had to roll out the ol' Paula line: You look beautiful. The whole performance was derivative of the Cure + late 80's angsty alternative. I kinda liked it.

Scott MacIntyre I like the piano - but it's a huge crutch for the flaws in his voice. He will have a niche on Christian radio if AI doesn't pan out for him.

Alexis Grace I so love that pink hair. The accompaniment was bizarre. It needed a bit more energy and didn't support her vocals at all.

Danny Downey Jr. When he sang "I'm letting go", I really felt it. Kind of sloppy in places, but I liked it.

Anoop Dawg zzzzzzzzzZZZZZZZ..... I kept waiting for the Pet Shop Boys loops to kick in.

Tattoo Joy Good Lawrd, what is she wearing?? A tie-tyed boob sling? With glitter. I didn't hear a note she sang. I was mesmerized (and not in a good way) by the carwreck tata's and tatt's combo.

Matt Giraud Solid. Darkhorse. FTW

Best o'the evening: Matt and Allison

Full of Fail: Megan, Alexis, Lil

[Miss Didi]

Randy Travis is in the audience. He still doens't know what to say.

He, like my mother, is still traumatized by the black nailpolish.

[silent_jonny]

BTW love the pic of Randy Jackson that dog is molten hot!!!!!!!!

Thank you very much :)

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Fawn :)