Posted on 06/17/2024 10:27:37 AM PDT by CaptainK
On Friday the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a law established by Congress requiring the deportation of foreign nationals who illegally enter the country. It's a blow to President Biden's lax enforcement of deportation laws.....
The illegal aliens sued. They demanded that their deportation orders be rescinded. They claimed that they didn't receive proper written notification. They also made technical arguments, such as challenging the definitions of the word 'change' in the order they received. In other words, they were hoping to stay because of technicalities in their paperwork.
A majority of Supreme Court justices didn't see it that way. The vote was 5-4. Justice Alito wrote the majority opinion. Chief Justice Roberts, and Justices Thomas, Kavanaugh, and Barrett concurred. Justice Gorsuch joined with Justices Ketanji Brown Jackson, Sotomayor, and Kagan in the dissenting opinion
(Excerpt) Read more at hotair.com ...
A judicial ruling against the leftists. Appeal and delay. Another judicial ruling against the leftists. Appeal and delay. Yet another judicial ruling against the leftists. Appeal and delay *and* a middle finger from the leftists. America surrenders.
Illegal aliens should never have “standing” in a US court—because they are here illegally.
Well we’re going to do it anyway. No joke!
I think the plaintiffs, illegal aliens sued the government. The government won. Biden administration won.
So Gorsuch is an idiot.
When can we start deporting leftists?
Can’t believe Gorsuch voted this way. But the important thing is, we won.
Gorsuch has been cowed by the maoist left.
These rulings make you wonder why the liberals attacked Gorsuch so hard.. seems he’s on their side as often as not... what a waste.
The illegal aliens didnt need ‘written notification’
They knew it was illegal to enter another country without permission/visas...
I cant just waltz into Mexico or Canada..
I have to stop at the border and be processed, passport and all...
If I fly there, same thing...
I dont get out of the airport without going through Immigration even though I’m just visiting...
As soon as President Trump is sworn in.
He will act immediately to remove the violent criminals FIRST.
>>Gorsuch has been cowed by the maoist left.
I’m not sure this case was right -vs- left. It’s more a “dot the ‘i’s and cross the ‘t’s kind of argument”. The govt sent court summons’ with a date and place TBD, then an updated letter with the actual place and time. The aliens were claiming that the summons should have had the date on it and was thus invalid.
Perhaps, Gorsuch was just being overly pedantic here.
“Justice Gorsuch” is not in the class of Alito and Thomas, nor in the Roberts/ACB/Kav clique.
Intriguing that the case got this far. The immigration judges must not have ran this past the DOJ brass. The illegals ignored orders to appear, but so do something like 90% of them. Apparently, they sued before their cases had a chance to just fade away as most seem to do.
Final paragraph starts, “Will the Biden administration carry through with these three deportations?”
That is the question.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
MY thoughts exactLy.
The Supreme Court upheld the Fifth Circuit's judgment which reversed the Ninth Circuit's judgment on Mendez-Colin and vacated Singh's judgment.
There was also a previous 2022 ruling debunking the plaintiffs’ claims, which Justice Alito cited.
Will the Biden administration carry through with these three deportations? Maybe they will fall under Biden's amnesty for those who will benefit from his announcement tomorrow. As long as laws are not followed and illegal aliens sue the United States with impunity to stay, it is a magnet for more to come. Nothing will change until we get a new president.
Very disappointed in Gorsuch. He was supposed to be Scalia’s replacement. Not even close. Maybe there is no one close anymore.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.