Posted on 08/24/2003 3:58:57 AM PDT by JustPiper
COMING TO AMERICA
$7.4 billion expense hurting American kids, group says
An immigration reform group says in a new study it costs states more than $7.4 billion a year to educate illegal aliens, with budget-busted California spending more than any other.
Worse, warns the Federation for American Immigration Reform report, the extra expenditures are taking funds away from American children at a time when "public schools throughout the country are facing some of the most significant decreases in state education funding in decades."
Many Mexican children cross into U.S. from Mexico daily to go to school. (Jon Dougherty/WND photo)
"With state budgets in crisis and children taking the hit, communities' limited tax dollars are being diverted to accommodate mass illegal immigration," said the report. "In some states, the amount of money spent to educate illegal alien children accounts for a substantial portion of the state budget shortfall; in New Jersey, for instance, it accounts for 28 percent of the total state budget deficit."
FAIR says almost two-thirds of states either have cut back or proposed reductions in their child care and early childhood programs.
"In some states, drastic cuts mean lay-offs for teachers, larger class sizes, fewer textbooks, and eliminating sports, language programs and after-school activities," the report noted.
The total cost, FAIR says, is "enough to buy a computer for every junior high student nationwide."
Other immigration reformists have said the cost of providing education and other public services to illegals has steadily been on the rise.
Adding to those costs, says Jim Boulet, Jr., head of English First, a group pushing English as the nation's official language, are translation costs to schools that must hire interpreters for Spanish-only immigrant students.
Plus, Boulet told WorldNetDaily, "Cuban Spanish, Puerto Rican Spanish, Chicano Spanish, and additional forms of Spanish all exist within the borders of the U.S., creating vast potential for cross-cultural confusion" and, of course, extra expense, despite "California being an official English state."
According to the FAIR report, California spends the most – $2.2 billion – to educate illegal immigrant children. Ranking second and third, respectively, are Texas and New York.
FAIR analysts said each state's per-pupil expenditure was reported by the U.S. Department of Education. The group said it based its figures on the Urban Institute's estimate of 1.1 million school-aged illegal immigrant children currently residing in the U.S.
The report also says there are efforts underway in several states and Congress to allow illegal aliens to pay deeply discounted, in-state tuition rates at public colleges and universities – rates not available to American citizens from out of state.
"As states cut school funding left and right, all of our children – native-born and immigrants alike – are receiving a poorer education as a result of the federal government passing its immigration law enforcement failures on to the states," the report concluded. "The implications for the coming generations of workers, our future economy and our long-term competitiveness in the world cannot be ignored."
Supporters of immigration say the cost to educate immigrant children – legal or otherwise – is a non-issue.
"Regardless of what the dollar figure is, these children have a right to an education," Jim Ferg-Cadima, legislative staff lawyer at the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund, told The Washington Times. "The issue was litigated all the way to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court decided on the issue."
In the high court's 1982 decision, Plyler v. Doe, justices said in a 5-4 decision the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment forbade public schools from prohibiting any children, regardless of citizenship status, an education.
Other supporters say the cost of educating illegals is minimal compared to the overall $700 billion annual cost of public education. And, they say it is the nation's best interests to educate illegal alien children rather than ignore them.
Still, the costs are continuing to rise and they come at a time when more Americans have become fed up with providing benefits to illegal immigrants.
An Aug. 30, 2001, Harris Interactive poll found 60 percent of Americans opposed a new plan to grant illegals amnesty.
"By decisive margins, the American public believes that illegal immigration is a net drain on public resources and that granting amnesty to illegal immigrants will encourage even more people to migrate illegally," the survey said.
A RoperASW poll in March found three in four Americans would reduce the number of immigrants allowed into the country annually. Fifty-eight percent would limit legal immigration to 300,000 a year, and 85 percent viewed illegal immigration as a "serious" problem.
"Illegal immigration is no free lunch," Dan Stein, executive director of FAIR, told the Times. "It's about shifting burdens – lowering labor costs at a tremendous cost not only to American taxpayers but to American kids."
Mark Krikorian, head of the Center for Immigration Studies, said U.S. and state governments could reduce costs by enforcing laws on the books.
"The solution is to start enforcing the law – not just at the border, which is politically easy, but also inside the country," he told WorldNetDaily.
Added FAIR spokesman David Ray: "If illegal immigration is not stopped at the border, its negative consequences, including bankrupt emergency rooms and overcrowded schools, quickly become everyone's financial burden."
California's Proposition 187 required proof of status for free public education. The left found a federal judge to block the law.
They consume services in far greater dollar amounts than the taxes they contribute. Don't play the damn percentage game either. If they make under $40,000 per year, they aren't paying any net income taxes. It is income taxes and property taxes that provide the general fund revenues from which education is funded.
BTW, while I was a California resident, I paid the max rate for state income tax AND 28% federal AND max rate for all social security and related taxes. My overall tax rate was far higher than any illegal alien and the total taxes confiscated are orders of magnitude more than they even earned in gross income.
Oh?
Last year, while campaigning for his Prop. 49 after-school programs initiative, Schwarzenegger...declared in answer to a question from the audience: "I would never stand in the way of any child going to school, whether he or she is here legally or illegally, it does not matter."http://www.sacbee.com/content/opinion/story/7287229p-8231859c.html
I might have missed your question on the first pass.
Virginians are just fine. They tend to leave other people alone. That is the way I think it should be. (Comments do not apply to northern VA.)
We have illegals here too. And, since you mentioned paramedics, I am starting EMT training in about three hours. That should be a good way to become better acquainted with everyone. All the better elements of the community.
One thing I am wondering about is whether they will allow me to take an Ithaca 16 gauge shotgun with me when I go on calls. I think probably so.
For a very long time, the crimes committed by hispanics were lumped under "white". That helped the lefties hide the impact. Now, we have separate categories for "non-hispanic, white" and "hispanic, white" to keep crime stats. Surprise! Guess where the criminal activity lies? It's not hidden anymore. My wife is charged with doing the data input for our city.
This has to be one of the most jaw-dropping, stupid statements EVER posted on this forum.
You don't know this. No one does.
No. Yours comes first.
Four shootings this weekend in Salinas. Gangs out of control...it was funny. On the TV news broadcast, all the people they interviewed were "hispanic"; one guy said in broken English "it's not safe here anymore". No Sh**, Sherlock. Now it's just like home in Mexico.
IT IS THE ADMINISTRATIONS AND THEIR FAT BENEFIT PACKAGES THAT ARE BUSTING THE SYSTEM.... REPEAT THE MANTRA.... THEY ARE THE EQUILVALENT OF THE BOUGOUSIE OF YESTER YEAR. THEY ARE MARXIST FINDING SOMEONE ELSE TO BLAME, MISDIRECTION... USE YOUR HEADS
Your understanding of economics and $3.50 will get you a cup of coffee at Starbucks. Any day.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.