Unusual Supreme Court vote rules illegal immigrant can avoid deportation on technicality ... The entire case centered on the word 'a'

https://www.foxnews.com ^ | APRIL 29, 2021 | By Ronn Blitzer

[Lurker]

There is no Law.

Stop pretending there is.

L

[Secret Agent Man]

weasel words

now the left has made the word “a” a weasel word

clinotn made “is” a weasel word

now we have this crap

[Yo-Yo]

OK, let's focus on one word in the Constitution: NOT.

As in "shall NOT be infringed."

[Red Badger]

They are articles of Impeachment....................

[Red Badger]

And ‘bear’ meaning ‘To Carry’....................

[Bloody Sam Roberts]

Yes..."a" bullet to the head will kill you. But generally...and I'm just spitballin' here...the first one will get the job done.

If ANY of these "multiple documents" were a directive to appear, then the clock stops. Semantics be damned. Let's try logic.

[Political Junkie Too]

How about all the times the word "shall" has been ignored?

-PJ

[Wuli]

Gorsuch flip flops between defending a purely statist interest and defending an individual on a technicality. It seems to Gorsuch the technicalities are only important when he thinks they are.

[Red Badger]

That’s what judges do.........................

[BohDaThone]

The sainted Justice Thomas was in the majority. Maybe he thinks he should actually read the law and apply judgments. Sometimes you agree with him and sometimes you don’t. Maybe that is called judgment?

[libertylover]

OK, let's focus on one word in the Constitution: NOT.

As in "shall NOT be infringed."

Great post!

[Red Badger]

The Congress wrote the law.

The Justices have before done similar things, basically kicking it back to them to fix................

[Ning_England]

If liberals had “a” logic, they wouldn’t be liberals.

[Hodar]

The fact that he is trespassing on US soil illegally, and has likely committed various felonies by falsely claiming Welfare to which he is not entitled, seems to have escaped our esteemed and highly educated judges

[TBP]

That can be fixed by statute.

[kaehurowing]

I finally read a Gorsuch opinion and the guy is out of control. I’ve never seen such bizarre legal writing in a court opinion. I actually can’t believe he was a federal judge, let alone that he got through the vetting process and got on the Supreme Court. And then I do a little googling and see all these people claiming what a brilliant writer he is.

[arkfreepdom]

Just what I was thinking. If Thomas voted with the majority it was probably the correct decision.

[Bigg Red]

This “journalist” needs a basic grammar lesson. Story is about a single individual — male, I assume — yet he uses the plural pronoun “they” instead of “he”.

[TakebackGOP]

But Texas had no standing.