Posted on 03/15/2011 6:25:31 PM PDT by Palter
National City, Calif.A San Diego-area boxing gym that serves at-risk kids is showing what it takes to fight for what is right and to win. A trial is scheduled to begin on Monday, March 14, 2011, to decide whether National City, Calif., may declare nearly 700 propertiesincluding the gymblighted, thus freeing the city to bulldoze these properties and make way for luxury condos among other private developments. The trial will be held before the Honorable Steven R. Denton, Superior Court of California, Hall of Justice, 330 W. Broadway in San Diego, Calif.
The Community Youth Athletic Center (CYAC) has had to endure a series of low blows by National Citys local government in a case that time and again demonstrated how difficult it is for California property owners to defend themselves against tax-hungry governments and land-hungry developers bent on eminent domain for private gain. Among other facts, the Institute for Justice, a public-interest law firm representing the gym, is prepared to demonstrate at trial that:
Weve spent more than three years getting here because National City has stonewalled at every turn and done everything possible to prevent this case from being heard on the merits, but the CYACs day in court is finally here, said IJ Senior Attorney Jeff Rowes. A trial is a search for truth, and this trial will prove that National City violated the CYACs constitutional rights and broke California law.
The law doesnt allow the government to take away your property so that someone wealthier can have it, said IJ Senior Attorney Dana Berliner. National Citys bogus blight designation is a deliberate strategy of using blight as a pretext for transferring property from owners of modest means, like the CYAC, to powerful developers for their private use.
This case is reminiscent of the California Supreme Court smackdown of National City in 1976, Rowes said. That landmark decision rejected the use of bogus blight designations for private economic development and National City has set itself up to be rightfully smacked down once again.
More recently, in January 2009 the California Court of Appeals unanimously reversed a lower court ruling that had for a short time derailed the gyms legal challenge seeking to prove how governments in California declare property blighted and pave the way for eminent domain abuse. The Court of Appeals decision sent the case back to the trial court with instructions to allow the nonprofit CYAC to make its case that National City violated the law when it declared roughly 700 properties blighted in 2007.
This will be the first case decided under the reforms passed by the Legislature in response to the infamous Kelo decision, and it will decide whether those reforms offer any protection for the CYAC and property owners throughout the state, Berliner said. National City ignored this new California law in ramming through a false blight declaration targeting humble property owners across the city. The CYAC is fighting this outrage not only for itself, but to establish precedent to protect all Californians.
The CYAC case has received nationwide media attention, including a feature by Rick Reilly in Sports Illustrated titled An Unfair Fight.
Video: EPIC EMINENT DOMAIN BATTLE: Inner-City Kids, Boxing Gym Fight Back
The whole place is essentially the extended development you'd find at any major urban terminal ~ except this is the main stop on the US/Mexico border ~ there's a vast 24/7 flow of commerce here.
It sounds very suspicious that the town wants to build highrise luxury condos ~ so what's this really for. Just doesn't make sense.
Remember the part of the Constitution that grants you rights to property unless somebody else will pay higher taxes than you? Neither do I
What purpose will the gym serve when they have gotten rid of all the kid’s homes? Thank you SCOTUS, for legalizing theft in the name of tax base.
This statement is 2/3 true. Do you know which 1/3 is false?
This statement is 2/3 true. Do you know which 1/3 is false?
"the Honorable" ... unfortunately!
STE=Q
IJ is great! It’s one of the few organizations that actually does something useful with the money it receives. I’m really tired of all the think tanks and other groups who just talk a lot, send out fundraising letters, and pay themselves handsome salaries.
Give 'm hell!
I think they are out of their minds imagining they can get people who can afford them to move into luxury highrise condos.
I just looked at the map to refresh my defective memory on where National City is. Yeah, that place is a real ____hole. It’s the kind of place I won’t go after dark because I would stand out there, speaking English.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.