Posted on 06/04/2005 5:06:35 AM PDT by Happy2BMe
We don't need tent cities or detainees, we need to STOP them from CROSSING the border, otherwise they have all the rights of a citizen - just ask the aclu.
Soldiers with weapons and some additional training can do the grunt work of spotting and rounding up the vast majority of border crashers.
1000 average everyday citizens, many seniors, were able to spot and report with no training at all. Don't make this harder than it is. Line the troops up on the border, WITH WEAPONS. That will stop them from CROSSING.
Why does it have to be the military? Just give enough manpower to the Border Patrol and someone with the gonads to effectively run it.
The combat units in the NG are being regularly federalized and have been in the rotational hopper for IRAQ along with the Active Army.
With regard to your anecdote regarding the 3d AD and the 10th Light, you are only addressing climate and terrain. You totally ignore the nature of the mission.
I really do not give a crap if you sit on the border with a night scope and increase your body count each day.[Get out from behind your keyboard and do something]. But, you are not going to screw up the combat effectiveness of our Army.
Condor51 has been given that assignment. ;-)
Sorry to stray from current topic, there is a site that rates Senators/Congressmen etc on their immigration policies. I am so far pretty impressed with Missouri's Jim Talent and Gov Roy Blunt, I wanted to check that site but didn't bookmark. Do you/or anyone know it?
You are absolutely correct, Frank. That's a Border Patrol mission.
CommandoFrank has it right.
Correction Missouri Gov Matt Blunt (we have Congressman Roy Blunt too). I love Gov Matt Blunt from what I've seen.
I have preached this issue for 45 years at my 5 year high school reunions. The first couple of reunions, I was treated like I was crazy. Now all the words I said years ago are coming back around.
The natural openness of Mid-westerners is going to bite them in the butt. These are not just individuals in poverty (by American standards- THE KEY TO WHOLE ISSUE). They are often criminals and worse.
Keep your powder dry and your ammo topped off.
Is this the one you're looking for:
Im making a list of names to take with me when i go and vote..............
Then why is an Army unit from Hunter Army Airfield, Savannah GA, currently training on the New Mexico border with JTF-North?
In preparation for rotation to Iraq?
Do you think the Army is stupid enough to send a unit out to dull its tactical skills before sending them into combat?
I certainly don't. I saw us do some dumb things during the 20 years I was in, but this isn't one of them.
It already has...
That's it! Thank you very much.
Yeah, Mexican troops are already on the border....
sw
"The problem right now is we arent seriously trying to stop this illegal entry and Mexico and their people know it."
Only part of the problem, sgtbono2002. Another really hairy part of the problem is that some Mexicans are shooting at our guys.
You're welcome.
So are ours.
We're running training rotations of Regular, and Reserve troops in conjunction with anti-drug/anti-terror forces on our side.
And they're catching illegals.
Excellent point. The drug runners are at war with us, and we haven't acknowledged that yet.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.