Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Mueller orders review of bombing investigation 2004-02-27 -- OKC Bombing
Breaking News The Oklahoman ^ | Feb 27, 2004 | John Solomon, AP

Posted on 02/27/2004 4:49:24 PM PST by PhiKapMom

Mueller orders review of bombing investigation

2004-02-27

By JOHN SOLOMON
.c The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) - The FBI on Friday ordered a formal review of some aspects of the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing investigation, reopening the question of whether Timothy McVeigh may have had more accomplices in the worst domestic terrorist attack in U.S. history, The Associated Press has learned.

Reacting to an AP story earlier this week, the FBI ordered agents to determine why some documents did not properly reach the bureau's Oklahoma City task force during the original investigation or get turned over to McVeigh's lawyers before he was executed in 2001, officials said.

The review of evidence and documents will also try to determine whether FBI agents in a separate investigation of white supremacist bank robbers may have failed to alert the Oklahoma City investigation of a possible link between the robbers and McVeigh, and allowed some of that evidence to be destroyed.

AP reported Wednesday that documents never introduced at McVeigh's trial showed FBI agents destroyed evidence and failed to share other information that raised the possibility that a gang of white supremacist bank robbers may have assisted McVeigh.

The evidence includes documents showing the Aryan Republican Army bank robbers possessed explosive blasting caps similar to those McVeigh stole and a driver's license with the name of a central player who was robbed in the Oklahoma City plot.

The documents don't prove additional accomplices were involved - blasting caps are plentiful and the gang was expert in document fraud. But the FBI agent who ran the investigation, Dan Defenbaugh, said his team never got the chance to investigate the evidence and he called for the probe to be reopened.

The April 19, 1995, bombing killed more than 160 people and McVeigh was put to death for it in 2001. His co-defendant, Terry Nichols, will stand trial in Oklahoma next week on state charges that could carry the death penalty.

Nichols' attorneys asked Thursday for the trial to be delayed in light of the AP story, but the judge refused.

FBI officials and Nichols' attorneys declined comment Friday night, citing a gag order in the case.

Government officials, who spoke only on condition of anonymity, said the review will be handled by the FBI's inspection division, a unit of senior agents that routinely conducts reviews to ensure the bureau follows its own rules and conducts investigations properly.

The officials said the review was ordered ``out of an abundance of caution'' to ensure that any questions about additional conspirators be put to rest.

It is not the first time issues in the McVeigh case have had to be reopened. In 2001, the Justice Department was forced to conduct an internal investigation to determine why 4,000 pages of documents from the case were belatedly turned over to defense lawyers just days before McVeigh was supposed to be executed. The revelation prompted a one-month delay in the investigation.

Peter Langan, one member of the ARA robbery gang, told AP he plans to testify at Nichols' trial that federal prosecutors several years ago offered and then withdrew a plea deal for information he had about the Oklahoma City bombing.

Langan said he plans to testify that at least three fellow gang members were in Oklahoma around the time of the bombing and one later told him that they had become involved.

Agents who worked both the McVeigh bombing and the bank robbery spree - two of the FBI's highest priority cases of the 1990s - said they suspected a link between the two because of physical evidence as well as statements made by the robbers and a girlfriend.

The agents said they ruled out a connection when the bank robbers denied their involvement and provided an alibi showing they left Oklahoma three days before McVeigh's bomb detonated outside the Alfred P. Murrah federal building on April 19, 1995.

That alibi, however, was contradicted by information Langan offered prosecutors and by car sales records that showed the bank robbers were still in the Oklahoma area after they claimed to have left, FBI documents show.

McVeigh in 1994 stole from a quarry hundreds of construction blasting caps, some which he used to explode the Oklahoma City bomb. The FBI spent months unsuccessfully trying to locate many of the other stolen caps.

Agents collected witness testimony that McVeigh had placed some of the extra caps in two boxes wrapped in Christmas paper in the back of his car along with mercury switches and duffel bags.

One electric and five non-electric blasting caps were found in the Aryan Republican Army robbers' Ohio hideout in January 1996, along with mercury switches, a duffel bag and two items described as a ``Christmas package,'' FBI records show. The FBI allowed firefighters to destroy the caps at the scene, and they were never compared to the Oklahoma case.

FBI agents in the robbery case also determined that the bank robbers had an Arkansas driver's license in the name of Robert Miller, the alias name used by Arkansas gun dealer Roger Moore.

The government contended at McVeigh's trial that Moore was robbed at his Hot Springs, Ark., home in November 1994, and the proceeds were used to fund the Oklahoma City bombing.

One of the bank robbers, Mark Thomas, claimed in a newspaper in 1997 that one of his gang was involved in the Oklahoma bombing. And Thomas' ex-girlfriend told FBI agents her boyfriend stated shortly before he traveled to an Oklahoma white supremacist compound in spring 1995 that a federal building was about to be bombed.

02/27/04 19:33 EST


TOPICS: Breaking News; Crime/Corruption; Government; News/Current Events; US: Oklahoma
KEYWORDS: aryanrepublicanarmy; bojinka; coverup; defenbaugh; fbi; fredthompson; mcveigh; murrah; nichols; okc; okcbombing; thomas
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-80 ... 141-151 next last
To: PhiKapMom
There are serious, well documented stories connecting muslim terrorists to OKC. Do a search of David Schippers McVeigh and see how many pop up. Schippers was the lead democrat investigating Clinton during the impeachment proceedings. Schippers says when first told of possible mideast connections, he wrote it off to another conspiracy nutcase. But read his interviews and what he has written. This is just one of many links to this.

http://www.dccsa.com/greatjoy/Illumine.htm
41 posted on 02/27/2004 6:27:31 PM PST by treeclimber
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Peach
Will do. I had my suspicions about this from the beginning but they really peaked after visiting the Bombing Memorial and then the Museum. Since then I have become totally convinced there was a cover-up.

There are some pictures of the bombing that I had never really looked at before recently. They don't make much more sense then this whole deal. Looks at this picture -- the debris is in front of the building but why weren't the traffic lights blown down from the truck bomb? If the truck was parked in front of the building -- why is the debris all in front instead of being blown out the back? The second photo is the back and side of the Murrah Building. I could be totally wrong but something about these pictures make me think something is not right.

http://photos.newsok.com/bombing/ There are a lot more photos archived at The Oklahoman on this page. The one of the Clintons at the Memorial Service is not the one the mural is made from. In that one they are both there with that cat that swallowed canary look.

42 posted on 02/27/2004 6:31:42 PM PST by PhiKapMom (AOII Mom -- Support Bush-Cheney '04 -- Losing is not an Option!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 33 | View Replies]

To: treeclimber
Something else -- there are articles about a particular motel that was used by some Middle Eastern folks with McVeigh and just so happens Atta and Zacarias Mousawi were at that same motel and it was turned over to the authorities after 9/11 and they did act on the tip about Mousawi/Atta. Mousawi was the former Norman resident who wanted to fly large aircraft at our flight school and stayed with two other Middle Eastern types here in Norman and suspected of being the 20th hijacker. I know they followed up on Mousawi -- in fact, they interviewed people all around Norman about the guy and his two roommates ended up in prison.

The FBI did not follow up on the McVeigh/Middle Eastern deal is my understanding, but I have read and heard so many rumors I am not sure.
43 posted on 02/27/2004 6:38:16 PM PST by PhiKapMom (AOII Mom -- Support Bush-Cheney '04 -- Losing is not an Option!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 41 | View Replies]

To: Mr. Jeeves
Nichols is not in federal custody -- he is in State custody and the OK County DA is a straight shooter and not a grandstander like Macy. There had to be a reason that the OK County DA turned down a no-contest plea by Nichols in exchange for life in prison. He said no -- it was after that the witnesses started coming forward and the Judge ruled the testimony was admissable. I think Nichols will spill the beans if it means he can get life in prison and not the death penalty.

Think the trial is going to get more interesting since the Judge seems to be a straight shooter as well.
44 posted on 02/27/2004 6:43:12 PM PST by PhiKapMom (AOII Mom -- Support Bush-Cheney '04 -- Losing is not an Option!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 40 | View Replies]

To: PhiKapMom
Good questions.

http://www.aim.org/publications/weekly_column/2001/11/21.html

OKLAHOMA BOMBING LINKED TO BIN LADEN

Reed Irvine
Chairman, Accuracy in Media

November 21, 2001

"...there is a lot of evidence that an ANFO bomb alone could not have caused all the damage done to the Murrah Building and that smaller powerful bombs inside the building caused much, if not most, of it. Since the ANFO that the FBI says was in the Ryder truck failed to demolish a low concrete wall between it and the building, or knock down a nearby lamp post, it could not have destroyed the more distant reinforced concrete building."


45 posted on 02/27/2004 6:45:49 PM PST by FairOpinion ("America will never seek a permission slip to defend the security of our country." --- G. W. Bush)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies]

To: PhiKapMom
"Something else -- there are articles about a particular motel that was used by some Middle Eastern folks with McVeigh and just so happens Atta and Zacarias Mousawi were at that same motel "

==

It's one heck of a conincidence, isn't it?
46 posted on 02/27/2004 6:46:56 PM PST by FairOpinion ("America will never seek a permission slip to defend the security of our country." --- G. W. Bush)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 43 | View Replies]

To: Nita Nupress
How about a stroll down Memory Lane just so we won't forget?

How about an introduction to reality, too?

BET you've NEVER seen this -

- excerpted from ... a published work ...

According to McVeigh, Jones began acting as though he was convinced his client was "delusional." Again and again Jones would send different members of the defense team to El Reno to hear McVeigh recount every detail of the story, only to hear McVeigh give the same version of events each time. Jones even hired an Oklahoma City psychiatrist, Dr. John R. Smith, to evaluate McVeigh and help determine whether McVeigh was delusional or competent to stand trial.

Smith, sixty-three at the time, had examined nearly one hundred accused killers as a court-appointed psychiatrist. But he'd never met anyone accused of killing 168 people. Nor had he ever been assigned to a case that hit so close to home. His own home, about a mile from the Murrah Building, had had a front window blown out by the blast. A piece of debris from the bomb had come crashing through a window in an office where Smith's daughter worked, fortunately injuring no one. He was already treating several of the bomb victims, who were traumatized by their experiences. Smith himself had driven past the Murrah Building less than half an hour before the explosion. When Jones's team approached him, they told Smith that they wanted him to judge the mind of "a man who drove off the interstate, set fire to a five-minute fuse, and then set fire to a two-minute fuse."

Smith talked with McVeigh for twenty-five hours, mostly over a five-week period in the spring and summer of 1995. Five years later, McVeigh gave Smith a written release to discuss their interviews with the authors of this book.

Smith found McVeigh very intelligent, with a 126 IQ, and very open to discussing his crime with a psychiatrist. By the second visit, Smith said, McVeigh was openly discussing the bombing, step by step, in chilling detail.

The psychiatrist saw no signs of remorse as McVeigh calmly explained how he designed, built, and delivered his bomb. He talks about this crime like it's some kind of successful science project, Smith thought angrily after one session.

And yet even in this confessed mass murderer Smith found things he liked, and reasons for sympathy. While others saw McVeigh as outgoing and happy-go-lucky, Smith found McVeigh deeply troubled by his parents' divorce and his war experiences. He pictured McVeigh in adolescence, trying to lose himself in the fantasy world of comic books late at night while his parents argued so furiously in the next room that McVeigh actually feared they might kill each other.

Others saw McVeigh as tremendously proud of his accomplishments in the military, but Smith saw a young man who was horrified by the killing of Arab soldiers. He listened closely to McVeigh's nightmarish descriptions of the killing he had done. To Smith, it was tragic that McVeigh never received counseling when he returned to the United States after the war. McVeigh told him he had looked into the possibility of getting treatment at a Veterans Administration hospital in Florida, but backed out when he was told he could not be treated under an assumed name. McVeigh was worried that receiving such counseling would be held against him when he applied for jobs.

Mcveigh told Smith he bad briefly experimented with methamphetamines after leaving the Army, but Smith saw no indications that McVeigh had ever been a heavy user of drugs.

While McVeigh proudly called himself a warrior, Smith could only picture McVeigh killing others from afar - while peering through the sights of a Bradley, or delivering a bomb and leaving the scene, but never face-to-face.

Smith had met many murderers who seemed to enjoy killing. McVeigh was different. His outlook on the bombing was cold and calculating, but Smith could see that McVeigh took no pleasure from the killings at the Murrah Building. McVeigh viewed the bombing as a mission that it was his duty to carry out, and he was convinced the bombing would change government in America.

"I expect to be convicted for the bombing, and I expect to receive the death penalty," McVeigh told the psychiatrist.

McVeigh also told Smith that, in scouting locations for his bombing, he had looked for a target he could bring down without killing a lot of people in surrounding, nongovernment buildings.

Smith concluded that McVeigh's life had been thrown into turmoil by a series of disturbing events: his parents' breakup, the killing he had done in the war, even the tragic death of Terry Nichols's stepson. But the Waco incident, Smith believed, was the flash point for MeVeigh's anger.

As a boy, Smith said, McVeigh had been so upset by his parents' breakup that he created a fantasy world for himself. "He created this superhero role for himself," Smith said. "He fantasized all these monsters, which he fought."

As an adult, McVeigh came to see the U.S. government as the ultimate monster - especially after the Waco incident.

"Waco was not the sole reason for the bombing," Smith said. "But if there had been no Waco, I don'tt believe Tim would have bombed the Murrah Building."

Smith once tried to confront McVeigh about the pain his bomb had caused others. Smith had noted how much McVeigh seemed to enjoy talking to people, and now he tried to use this quality to provoke a reaction from him. "Instead of the death penalty, Tim, they should put you in a tiny little cell, Smith said. "You wouldi't be allowed to talk to anyone, ever again."

McVeigh looked surprised. He stood straight up from his chair. "You'd put me in a little cell like that?" he said.

"Tim, that's what you did to your victims and their families," Smith said. "They'll never be able to communicate with each other again."

The two quickly moved on to other topics. "Tim, have you ever loved anyone?" Smith asked.

"My father and my grandfather," McVeigh quickly answered.

"I noticed you didn't mention your mother or your sisters," Smith remarked.

"Yes," McVeigh said. "I was just noticing that myself."

Smith could see that McVeigh was awkward with women, but he knew that McVeigh had cared deeply about a couple of women in his life. McVeigh once asked Smith if he could take some of his sperm out of the prison and give it to a woman, so she could become pregnant. Smith agreed to look into the legal requirements for such a venture.

Smith said McVeigh also told him of the brief affair he allegedly had with Marife Nichols, the wife of Terry Nichols. Though he was horrified by McVeigh's crime and his cold attitude, Smith did not see him as an evil man. Clinically, he saw him as an essentially decent person who had allowed rage to build up inside him to the point that he had lashed out in one terrible, violent act. "I've seen it many times," Smith maintains. "Nice people do really terrible things."

The psychiatrist reported back to Jones that his client was not delusional - that be knew exactly what he did, and exactly what be was doing now.

As for McVeigh, he considered himself as sane as anyone. In the months after his arrest, he continued his voracious reading of all things antigoverment, and he enjoyed watching TV shows that questioned the government's actions. One night on cable, McVeigh enjoyed a viewing of Brazil, Terry Gilliam's surreal 1985 film about a futuristic society where citizens are dehumanized. One of the characters in the film is Harry Tuttle, a terrorist bomber played by Robert DeNiro. Some people later theorized that McVeigh had chosen the alias Tim Tuttle in honor of DeNiro's character, but the first time he saw the film was inside prison walls.


47 posted on 02/27/2004 6:47:09 PM PST by _Jim ( <--- Ann C. and Rush L. speak on gutless Liberals (RealAudio files))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 38 | View Replies]

To: DoughtyOne
I forgot about Hubbell the guy the Clintons paid to keep quiet. A lot of strings in this one.
48 posted on 02/27/2004 6:47:14 PM PST by PhiKapMom (AOII Mom -- Support Bush-Cheney '04 -- Losing is not an Option!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 25 | View Replies]

To: dalebert
And the Nichols trial is in McAlester in Southeastern OK -- wonder if they can manage to get deposition admitted this time. The judge except for ruling the trial starts Monday had been given the defense a lot of leeway.
49 posted on 02/27/2004 6:49:11 PM PST by PhiKapMom (AOII Mom -- Support Bush-Cheney '04 -- Losing is not an Option!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 27 | View Replies]

To: All
"White supremacists" do not exclude radical Islam.

"US extremists conflicted over war on terror," by Brad Knickerbocker, Staff writer of The Christian Science Monitor, June 18, 2002

"Experts tracking antigovernment radicals also note their shared interest with Muslim extremists in opposing what they see as this country's pro-Israel foreign policy. This is often voiced as opposition to, as the most militant call it, "ZOG" -- the "Zionist-Occupied Government" of the US."

Cooperation with foreign terrorists would help to precipitate "the kind of race war envisioned in 'The Turner Diaries,' the anti-Semitic, racist, and apocalyptic novel many on the extreme right see as prophetic." [end excerpt]

It took years to get serious looks at Ruby Ridge and Waco. OKC is no different except it connects directly to the Clintons' Oval Office.

Americans who would not let Ruby Ridge and Waco go were ridiculed and threatened. Jayna Davis, Mr. Key and others have suffered the same treatment.

Remember this? "When the full stories of these two incidents (1993 WTC Center bombing and 1995 Oklahoma City bombing) are finally told, those who permitted the investigations to stop short will owe big explanations to these two brave women (Middle East expert Laurie Mylroie and journalist Jayna Davis). And the nation will owe them a debt of gratitude." -- Former CIA Director James Woolsey, "The Iraq Connection", Wall Street Journal, September 5, 2002

50 posted on 02/27/2004 6:50:23 PM PST by WilliamofCarmichael (Benedict Arnold was a hero for both sides in the same war, too!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: FairOpinion; DonQ
"...there is a lot of evidence that an ANFO bomb alone could not have caused all the damage done to the Murrah Building and that smaller powerful bombs inside the building caused much, if not most, of it. Since the ANFO that the FBI says was in the Ryder truck failed to demolish a low concrete wall between it and the building, or knock down a nearby lamp post, it could not have destroyed the more distant reinforced concrete building."

Mind numbing idiocy ...

THIS is the SHAM theory that michael redvero 'pushed' for so long ...

There is absolutely no evidence of any internal explosions in the Murrah Bldg.

An internal explosion would leave scorch marks, melt the carpeting, form spiderwebbing cracks, and generally create an epicenter of damage.

NO such damage was found anywhere inside the building. One of the witnesses to this fact was a local fire marshal who participated in the rescue effort.

The notion of internal explosions was contrived by a very retired USAF Brig.Gen, Ben Partin, whose "expertise", it turns out, was precision aerial bomb dropping on third world huts (he had retired during the Vietnam War), not the physics and chemistry of homemade explosives at ground level on modern office buildings.

Partin didn't even come to OKC to view the damage himself. Based on some (wrong) assumptions Partin convinced himself that, mathematically, a truck bomb couldn't have done the damage and he postulated four bombs inside the third floor. Except the third floor was the Federal Employee's Credit Union, which was actually a non-civil service establishment and more heavily locked and protected than most of the rest of the building.

Morever, there were some survivors from the third floor who testified and made it Very Clear that the explosion (just one) came from outside the building.

Partin postulated the internal bombs only to solve one problem -- his own calculation about the blast power at the distance from the truck -- but his postulation created even more problems; if bombs had been on the third (or fourth or any other) floor, then the floors below and the floors above would have been pushed in different directions and there would be unmistakable signs of that, also there would have been a LOT more damage to the far side of the building. And, again, a different epicenter.

Partin had calculated on the assumption that McV used common diesel fuel, when in fact he used racing fuel which would have quadrupled the blast power.

The simple fact is that the truck bomb not only wrecked the Murrah Bldg, it also wrecked at least two buildings at least as far away in the opposite direction - the Water Board Bldg and the Athenian Bldg - and killed four people inside those other buildings! To me, this is very clear proof that Partin's calculations are just plain wrong.

Partin tried to get on the defense witness lists for the McV & Nichols trials but the defense lawyers refused to use him because they knew he'd be torn apart by real experts in the field of demolition and arson investigation. He did testify before the OKC Grand Jury, which was clearly not persuaded by his theories.

Aerial photos of the scene made within an hour or two after the blast, before the streets were cleared off, makes it Very Obvious that the epicenter of the damage is the spot (a deep crater) where the truck used to be.

All the debris radiates from that point. If there had been bombs inside the building, you see multiple epicenters, which didn't happen. Also, a couple of blocks away there were thin straight lines of debris in the streets -- not stuff blown all the way from the Murrah Bldg but dust and old paint and the like jarred loosed from the nearby buildings as a result of the blast, which creates an odd sort of chalk outline on the streets. If there had been multiple blasts, that line would have been seriously blurred.

There is no evidence that ATF personnel lied. One ATF person reported being trapped for several minutes in the elevator stalled at the time of the blast, and the building engineer denied that anything like that could possibly have happened with HIS elevators .... but I could tell you stories of my own about how govt building engineers have lied about their elevators. A contradiction but no solid proof.

I have not heard the stories about ATF people being bandaged, certainly a couple of them were actually taken to the hospital with bona fide injuries altho they were, generally, less seriously hurt than most others because of the location of the ATF office. A few people - none of them an expert on explosives - thought they saw "bombs" lying around (if this were true then the conspirators were very lousy bomb-makers, certainly not up to CIA standards) but these turned out to be such stuff as desk clocks and other innocuous items blown around to odd places by the explosion.

59 Posted on 09/28/2000 11:57:27 PDT by DonQ
[ Reply | Private Reply | To 56 | Top | Last ]

From:
http://www.FreeRepublic.com/forum/a39d1506d5f16.htm#59


51 posted on 02/27/2004 6:50:24 PM PST by _Jim ( <--- Ann C. and Rush L. speak on gutless Liberals (RealAudio files))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 45 | View Replies]

To: PhiKapMom
I can hardly say their name without being sick. The damage they have done to this country is incalculable.

VERY interesting about the debris. This is going to be interesting in the next few weeks to see what comes out...
52 posted on 02/27/2004 6:56:59 PM PST by Peach (The Clintons have pardoned more terrorists than they ever captured or killed.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies]

Competant resources for analysis of the OKC bomb blast - not this conspriacy-based crap (some of these links may or may not be current at this time):

Click here for info on book

"This book serves as documentation of the incident from a structural standpoint. It provides detailed discussion of the construction of the building, the structural damage witnessed, the hazard mitigation measures taken during the rescue/recovery process. It also provides a discussion of the weak points in the design and construction which may have contributed to exacerbating the damage and measures that structural engineers can take to limit damage due to this severe loading condition."

Click here for report from American Society of Civil Engineers, outlining inferior construction quality of Murrah Building

"It is important to understand that the bomb blast to the Murrah building was not devastating by itself -- it just so happened that it was located at a critical point which undermined the whole structure of the building. What we discovered as a result of our investigation was that most of the damage and a vast majority of the fatalities were caused by the progressive collapse of the building."

Click here for Court TV report

Click here for Oklahoma Department of Civil Emergency Management report

"A minimum of two subsequent "bomb scares" forced the evacuation of these personnel. The evacuation of the structure allowed officials to create a controlled perimeter around the dangerous site. Rescue workers were not allowed to re-enter the site until confirmation was given that no additional explosive devices were located."

Click here for second Court TV report

Click here for OKC book

"Draws on more than three hundred interviews--with survivors, victims' families, investigators, and convicted bomber Timothy McVeigh--to examine the full story of the Oklahoma City bombing."

Click here for Disaster Recovery Journal

Click here for 911 Magazine report

Click here for Popular Mechanics report

Cl ick here for CNN report

Click here for FEMA report

Click here for Weidlinger Associates report

Click here for City of Oklahoma City Final Report

Click here for AP report on Grand Jury

53 posted on 02/27/2004 6:57:26 PM PST by _Jim ( <--- Ann C. and Rush L. speak on gutless Liberals (RealAudio files))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 51 | View Replies]

To: FairOpinion
Of further note - excerpted from:

http://www.wai.com/AppliedScience/Blast/blast-okcity.html

BY JOHN PRENDERGAST

(Reprinted by permission from Civil Engineering, October 1995)

Can lessons learned from the tragic bombing in Oklahoma City help engineers outwit future terrorists? A key issue in the emerging debate is whether to require that government buildings be designed to protect against progressive collapse.

The explosion that ripped through the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City shortly after 9 a.m. on April 19 killed 168 people, injured more than 500 and damaged more than 300 buildings. Also among the casualties of the blast was a lingering American faith that terrorism was something that happened somewhere else-in other countries, or at high-profile structures like the World Trade Center in New York.

......According to Rittenhouse, "The biggest structural engineering lesson learned from the Oklahoma City bombing was the need to improve the structure's ability to sustain significant local damage and remain standing." It has been estimated that at least 80% of the deaths at the Murrah Building were caused by the structure falling on occupants who might otherwise have survived the bomb attack, he says. "Therefore, the single most important improvement, aside from maintaining a substantial keep-out distance, would be to mitigate catastrophic failure or progressive collapse. This measure alone, regardless of improvements to the glazing and facade, will significantly reduce the number of fatalities." ............................................

Rittenhouse predicts there will be a "significant reduction" in transfer girders in future construction, especially in potentially dangerous locations. The Murrah Building had a transfer girder running across the face of the structure at the second floor, which transferred the weight of 10 building columns to five columns down to the ground. The failure of one column meant three failed; with the failure of two, six or seven failed, he says. "A certain number of people will be looking out a window or standing in the wrong place when a bomb goes off, but the remaining people get crushed," says Rittenhouse. "That's why this is an important issue. You'll have localized damage no matter what, but preventing progressive collapse will limit damage after that."


54 posted on 02/27/2004 7:02:21 PM PST by _Jim ( <--- Ann C. and Rush L. speak on gutless Liberals (RealAudio files))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 45 | View Replies]

To: rwfromkansas
The enemy of my enemy is also my friend.
55 posted on 02/27/2004 7:02:39 PM PST by Calpernia (http://members.cox.net/classicweb/Heroes/heroes.htm)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: PhiKapMom
That links up just fine if you follow Enron:

1992
Enron sent a group of officials to New Delhi to make arrangements to survey the land around Dabhol for the purpose of building a large power plant.
Enron and the government of the state of Maharashtra signed a non-binding memorandum of understanding to build the plant. This led to formation of the Dabhol Power Company (DPC), a joint venture of Enron and two other American corporations, General Electric and Bechtel.

1993
A formal agreement was signed for a plant that could generate about 2450 megawatts at an approximate cost of $3 billion.

Heinz Vergin, World Bank manager for India, rejects Enron's loan application, saying that the Dabhol plant is "not economically viable."

The Central Electricity Authority in New Delhi gave provisional clearance to the project. It was the largest single foreign investment in India.

1994
The Washington-based Export-Import Bank approved a $302 million loan toward a $3 billion Enron-controlled power plant in India. President Clinton took an interest in the deal, asking the U.S. ambassador to that country and his former chief of staff, Thomas F. "Mack" McLarty, then a presidential adviser, to monitor the proposal.

1995
Clinton administration's cabinet members, Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin and Energy Secretary Hazel O'Leary, personally urged India to accept Enron's proposed project.

Indian Prime Minister Rao and Iranian Foreign Minister Ali Akbar Velayati discussed a routing alternatives for a natural gas pipeline, including one which would run through Turkmenistan, Afghanistan, and Pakistan.

1996
"Mack" McLarty, who later became a paid Enron director, spoke with Ken Lay on several occasions about the plant. Four days before India granted approval for Enron's project, the Houston-based firm contributed $100,000 to the Democratic Party.

1996
Enron signed a contract giving it rights to explore 11 gas fields in Uzbekistan, a project costing $1.3 billion. The goal was to sell gas to the Russian markets, and link to Unocal's southern export pipeline crossing Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Afghanistan.

1996
Enron and the state government of Maharashtra reached a new agreement that would shift some of the construction costs and lower the electricity tariffs.

1997
As an advisor for Unocal, Zalmay Khalilzad drew up a risk analysis of a proposed gas pipeline from the former Soviet republic of Turkmenistan across Afghanistan and Pakistan to the Indian Ocean. He participated in talks and social meetings between Unocal and Taliban officials in 1997.

1997
Police stormed the homes of several women in western India who had led a massive protest against Enron's new natural-gas plant near their fishing village. According to Amnesty International, the women were dragged from their homes and beaten by officers paid by Enron.

Enron International's CEO Rebecca Mark unveiled an energy plan that included a $300 million project to build a pipeline from Dabhol to Hazira and to the North to add 1200 km of complimentary pipeline system to the existing HBJ pipeline at a cost of $900 million.

Unocal invited a Taliban contingency to visit them in Houston, Texas, housed them in five-star hotels, dined them at the home of Unocal VP and medically treated the former foreign minister, Mullah Mohammed Ghaus before he returned home.

1998
Testimony of John J Maresca, vice-president, international relations, Unocal Corporation was heard by the House Committee on International Relations and the Subcommittee on Asia and the Pacific regarding "a proposed extension (of the proposed trans-Caspian pipeline) would link with the SUI pipeline system, moving gas to near New Delhi, where it would connect with the existing HBJ pipeline..."

In a speech to the "Collateral Damage Conference" of the Cato Institute, Cheney said, "the good Lord didn't see fit to put oil and gas only where there are democratically elected regimes friendly to the United States. Occasionally we have to operate in places where, all things considered, one would not normally choose to go.
But, we go where the business is."

The Department of State is pleased that Turkmen Minister of Oil and Gas Arazov announced Turkmenistan's selection of the U.S. company Enron to carry out a feasibility study funded by the Trade and Development Agency for a trans-Caspian gas pipeline.

U.S. Tomahawk cruise missiles target Kandahar Afghanistan and sites believed to be Osama bin Laden's training camps. Shortly after, the UN imposes sanctions on Afghanistan that isolate the nation.

1999
Human Rights Watch released a report that indicated human right violations had occurred as a result of opposition to the Dabhol Power project. Beginning in late 1996 and continuing throughout 1997, leading Indian environmental activists and representatives of villagers' organizations in the affected area organized to oppose the project and, as a direct result of their opposition, were subjected to beatings, repeated short-term detention and were not paid.
Joint agreement signed by Turkmenistan and two American companies, Bechtel and GE Capital Services to build a $2.5 billion trans-Caspian pipeline, after Enron conducted a feasibility study.

Enron purchased 5.1 percent of the company that operates the country's sole long-distance gas pipeline, which runs from the offshore gas fields in the Bombay High area to the country's capital, New Delhi.

2000
Maharashtra government allies demand scrapping the project because of the cost of the power it produces.
56 posted on 02/27/2004 7:08:17 PM PST by Calpernia (http://members.cox.net/classicweb/Heroes/heroes.htm)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: PhiKapMom
MY TAKE: This is a warning shot to Hillary: do not try to run for President in 2004 by bypassing the primaries.
57 posted on 02/27/2004 7:12:01 PM PST by ikka
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: _Jim
Not interested in anything you have to post. If you said the sky was blue, I would go check. You would serve the Federal LEO's better if you stayed off these threads instead of putting your propaganda all over them. You just lead people to suspect even more because you always show up when it is about any of the evil things associated with Clinton -- Waco, TWA, OKC Bombing!

This is my last post on here -- the thread is all yours to spin at will.

58 posted on 02/27/2004 7:13:13 PM PST by PhiKapMom (AOII Mom -- Support Bush-Cheney '04 -- Losing is not an Option!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 54 | View Replies]

To: Nita Nupress
Hello Nita! Haven't seen you much lately. God bless. :)
59 posted on 02/27/2004 7:16:36 PM PST by Zack Nguyen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: PhiKapMom
Let's all hope he has something to sing about. Cells operate by having operatives know next to nothing. I have a bad feeling if he knew anything....he would have been sentenced as fast as McVeigh.
60 posted on 02/27/2004 7:17:35 PM PST by Calpernia (http://members.cox.net/classicweb/Heroes/heroes.htm)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 21 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-4041-6061-80 ... 141-151 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson