Posted on 11/26/2025 8:10:19 AM PST by Red Badger
Two Charlotte County men face felony charges after allegedly trespassing onto a DeSoto County farm and shooting a cow in the head while they were on their way to school.
The DeSoto County Sheriff’s Office arrested Matthew Robert Wright and Gavin Hunter McMillan on charges of armed trespass and aggravated animal cruelty, the press release stated.
Thomas Butler discovered the men on his family’s cattle farm northwest of Arcadia on Friday. One man stood in the pasture holding the dead heifer’s head, telling Butler “someone shot this cow,” according to Fox 4, which cited an arrest report.
When Butler asked where they were going, the men said they were headed to school and needed to leave. “Butler advised they were going nowhere and contacted the Sheriff’s Office to report the incident,” the report stated.
DeSoto County Sheriff's Office 5d · Yesterday, Deputy Beasley and Corporal Santana responded to a property located in the area of NW County Road 661 in reference to a trespass. The complainant reported two unknown males trespassed on their property and killed one of their Heifer cows. The unknown males were identified as Charlotte County residents, Matthew Robert Wright and Gavin Hunter McMillan, and were located next to the deceased cow. The cow had an obvious gunshot wound to its head. Wright admitted to shooting the cow, which suffered briefly before he had to shoot it again to kill it. Wright said he did not plan to do anything with the cow. Both Wright and McMillan were arrested and charged with: • Armed Trespass F.S.S. 810.08(2)(c) - FELONY • Aggravated Animal Cruelty F.S.S. 828.12(2) - FELONY • Knowingly propelling a potentially lethal projectile over or across private land without authorization F.S.S. 810.09(g) – FELONY • Possession of Marijuana less than 20gms F.S.S. 893.13(6)(b) • Possession of Drug Paraphernalia pursuant to F.S.S. 893.147(1) Cattle operations are an important livelihood for many families here in DeSoto County and across our state. Sheriff Potter is thankful for the concerned citizens and the Deputies who investigated this senseless crime. Remember to report suspicious activity, if you see something say something. Report Animal Cruelty to us at (863) 993-4700.
=====================================================================
Carl Pickle, who owns the land where Butler raises cattle, told deputies the men jumped a barbed wire fence to access the property.
Wright initially changed his story multiple times before admitting he shot the cow with his rifle, deputies said. When asked what he planned to do with the animal, Wright said he intended to do nothing with it.
Deputies removed a concealed 9mm Glock handgun from Wright’s pants during questioning. A search of McMillan’s vehicle turned up several grams of marijuana and a grinder.
“It was cruel, what they did,” said Rylee Butler, Thomas’s daughter. “And I don’t think it’s whatsoever right.”
The family estimates the heifer was worth around $45,000.
“You weren’t going to take it for the meat, you know? What was the purpose of it?” Rylee said. “It was just like a vindictive kind of act.”
Sheriff James Potter thanked concerned citizens and deputies for investigating what his office called “this senseless crime.”
Maybe they thought it was a deer?
(s)
Some dumb A$$ shot a friends horse the first week of deer season here in NH.
FYI, I am NOT anti hunting. I shot a 9 pt white tail buck a couple weeks ago.
Not even close. Ever been to a livestock auction?
Ever shopped for a quality line heifer?
Know what a quality blood line heifer is worth?
I’m guessing not.
Shoot them in the head, before they start killing people.
What if it were a young milk-producing cow? Healthy and strong to produce calves…?
headline should read “Punks on the way to school.....”
DEPENDING ON HOW MANY YEARS THAT HEIFER PRODUCES CALVES & MILK-—MIGHT BE CORRECT...
EXACTLY
Cows are often the most docile creatures, there would be not sport in this only a sick enjoyment of killing. Those two budding serial killers need to be monitored for the rest of their lives.
You prove that heifer will drop 20 calves and maybe it is worth it.
Terrible. But how is a heifer worth $45,000?
Taylor Swift is worth a Billion dollars.................
The things you think are precious, I can’t understand.
Not a good sign for these two in later life.
These guys chase the thrill of killing, this probably wasn't their first kill - maybe thrill killing of stray dogs or cats. Next, something bigger, livestock.
Humans would be the next logical kill.
It will be interesting to see what the courts do to these two.
Good normal ‘replacement’ heifer might be $4500, so there may be a typo, BUT a high-value genetic line might be twice the $45k mentioned and be certainly insured somewhat. Tax and insurance people will decide if necessary.
Make them skin, butcher, and then eat it.
Raw.
L
-45000? For one Heifer? I call….BS.-
If you want to negotiate for the price of a cow, do it before you shoot the cow.
Not one person has questioned the comment the these men were on thir way to school. What school were they attending? Not covered in the article.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.