Posted on 03/29/2025 7:37:23 PM PDT by Red Badger
In my younger years, I always preferred cars and trucks with manual transmissions. I learned to drive on a manual transmission, and always liked them; in a car, such as the '65 Mustang I had for a while, there was nothing more fun that opening up the four-barrel on that 289, smoking off a line, and slamming through the gears. In a 4x4 truck, I always preferred a manual when off-roading, as it made it easier to ensure your motor was in its best power-band, keeping the RPMs right where you wanted them while climbing up a steep trail or fording a creek.
Manual transmissions have pretty much disappeared from American cars nowadays. But, in an interesting move, Ford Motors - my brand of choice - is bringing them back.
Sort of.
Ford has just filed a patent to bring back a classic driving experience - but only 18 percent of Americans would know how to use it.
The automaker has submitted paperwork to bring stick shifts to electric vehicles.
Manual transmissions have all but vanished from the American new car market. Last year, less than 1 percent of new vehicles sold in the U.S. had manual gearboxes.
In 1990, that figure sat between 25 and 30 percent.
The patent application, published on March 20, outlines a system designed to replicate the tactile experience of shifting through gears – even though there are no actual gears to shift.
The setup includes a traditional-looking shift lever mounted in a raised console, similar to the ones found in gas-powered sports cars.
But instead of mechanical linkages, the system uses electronic signals to adjust the EV's driving feedback based on how the driver moves the stick.
I'm inclined to ask, "What's the point?" I mean, at the end of the day, what is Ford trying to accomplish here?
'Electric vehicles lack operator to vehicle physical feedback that is advantageous in conventional motor vehicles,' the company wrote in the patent.
The filing arrives at a time when fewer drivers in the US know how to operate a stick shift at all.
That much is certain; one of the best theft deterrents you can have in a car now is a manual transmission.
I'll agree that driving a car, especially a high-performance car, is a lot of fun with a manual transmission, and yes, you're more engaged with the vehicle. In everyday driving, you get so used to shifting gears that you don't even think about it; it becomes reflex. You are, essentially, the automatic transmission. But for an EV? I just don't quite see the point.
But, then, as my grandfather was fond of saying, "Every cat its own rat." Maybe Ford will sell some of these. Maybe they'll catch on. I'm inclined to think that they'll be a bust, but who knows? I could be wrong - I mean, it's bound to happen eventually.
Many years ago, I had a great truck - a 1974 Bronco, the original small, tough Bronco, all steel outside, all steel and vinyl inside. It had manual everything; you even had to get out and turn the hubs to "LOCK" by hand. It would go up and down trees, or very nearly, and at the end of elk season, I could take it into the car wash, open the doors, and just hose out the interior. One summer day in 1995 or so, My Dad and I were crawling up a jeep trail in that electric-green Bronco - we called it the Green Machine. Dad commented that if Ford would make that exact truck then, all metal, no frills, manual everything, and sell it for $10-15k, he reckoned they wouldn't be able to build them fast enough. I know I'd buy one.
But that's not the technological world we live in now. Ford is bringing back a semblance of the famous old stick-shift, but not really. And that, while interesting, is kind of sad.
DEI Advertising.......................
Bench seats and necking knobs!
I learned to drive on a standard. Owned a few cars with standard transmission. Also owned an old Duster that had three on the column. I’m old now and my legs and knees wouldn’t be able to deal with working a clutch. Any car I drive needs to have power seats as I have a bad left shoulder (told I need a full shoulder replacement). I’m left handed...can’t pump a seat up anymore with that hand. I’m kind of wishing they’d bring back the automated seatbelts because with the car I drive now, I have trouble reaching back to grab the belt and pull it forward across my body to lock it in. It sucks to get old.
The reason bench seats are no longer standard is there would have to be a center airbag for a passenger and it would take up too much room in the dash.............
If a car could be transgender, this would be it. No thanks.
I question your judgement in letting a valet get behind the wheel of that.
Yes, but the girl would be sitting so close to the driver with his arm around her that his airbag would protect them both. Maybe you’re not old enough to remember that.
I’m 70. The driver’s airbag would be insufficient to protect two bodies. They have to be precisely calculated or they won’t be reliable...................
Thanks for the post.
I was totally unaware of the vehicle.
With AWD, it would have been awesome.
About the equivalent of exhaust pipe speakers on an electric car.
I would buy a real stick over a CVT, but the only cars with the real thing now are $$ luxury sports cars. Out of my budget.
My 04 & 07 Sonatas have decent 4 speed trannies with a 5th overdrive. At 73 I’m hoping to keep them both going until I’m dead. No more cars.
At least I can put the miles on my Indian Scout. Honda has sold a lot of Rebel 1100 DCT. I’m guessing to new riders based on the number of used ones for sale - the bike is too fast for a beginner. No way would I ride a bike with an auto. Just ain’t right. No fun and poor low speed control without a clutch to feather.
This is ridiculous. It’s not enough Ford has Hundreds of millions on EV’s. Now we have this stupdity
You are probably right, but the valet that drives it, fell in love with it. He parks it in the best spot and watches it like a hawk. Ya can’t leave it in a parking lot unattended.
For far to many, driving with a clutch is like reading something written in cursive.
My wife’s subaru has a “10 speed” CVT. There are shift points programmed into the CVT that simulates the transmission “shifting”. You can even put the stick in manual and use the paddle shifters...on a CVT.
It seemed silly when we bought it but it works well and the car is awesome.
The bad part of manual transmissions are the parts that wear out. I saved a lot of money replacing those parts myself but it is not an easy job . The amazing part was seeing the inside of the manual transmission itself. How anybody could design such complex gears much less make them always impressed me.
A fake standard? GAY !!
That recorded exhaust note is cringeworthy, but everything coming from greenies is cringeworthy.
The sales numbers are dismal for the Dodge Charger EV and some are saying that Stellantis is going to be putting Hemi’s in them next year.
I’m not exactly sure what the point is for doing this. It adds nothing to the performance, it’s just pretending.................
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.