Posted on 12/28/2021 9:54:21 AM PST by Red Badger
Brighton, N.Y. (WHAM) - It's arguably one of the most popular holiday songs in the world, however, it will no longer be sung at Council Rock Elementary in Brighton.
First reported by the online publication, the Rochester Beacon, the school has decided to remove 'Jingle Bells' from it's repertoire due to the song's 'questionable past'.
The Rochester Beacon says principal Matt Tappon confirmed the song, and several others, have been replaced with different songs that don't have the "potential to be controversial or offensive."
The article says a factor in the decision was research published in 2017 by Boston University professor Kyna Hamill.
In her research, the song's first public performance may have occurred in a minstrel show nearly 150 years ago, where white actors performed in blackface.
The district assistant superintendent for Brighton also told the Rochester Beacon that some suggest the use of collars on slaves with bells may be connected to the origin of the song and that even though they are not taking a stance of whether or not that is true, that line of thinking is not in agreement with "district beliefs."
Some people in the community believe banning the song altogether goes too far.
"You hear Jingle Bells and it's just the spirit of Christmas time," says Mary Santiago from Rochester. "Christmas without Jingle Bells isn't Christmas. I feel it's ridiculous," she said.
Ruth Ferguson, whose children were once students at Brighton, believes other schools should follow the same lead.
"It is taking away a Christmas tradition. That's a tradition, like so many traditions, that we need to lose if it's tied to slavery or racism. It's just that simple," Ferguson said.
While speaking with the Rochester Beacon, Hamill says she was surprised a school would ban the song and told the publication she believes it should still be sung and enjoyed by children.
13 WHAM reached out to the Brighton Central School District and Hamill for comment for this story.
On Tuesday, Superintendent Kevin McGowan responded:
Several weeks ago, a resident of the community asked for more information regarding an item that he had noticed on the District’s website regarding work being done to review curriculum with a diversity/equity lens. Specifically, he was curious about the District’s decision to use different songs in the elementary music curriculum based on work being done to be more culturally responsive. Several staff members provided feedback, explaining various reasons why the song “Jingle Bells” was no longer being used. This resident decided to write a piece on the subject and it was published last week by the Rochester Beacon. This article has been distributed by the author and picked up by a variety of media outlets.
First, we couldn’t be more proud of our staff and the work they continue to do to reflect on what they teach and how they teach in an ongoing effort to be more culturally responsive, thoughtful, and inclusive. Let me be very clear, their work has been and continues to be smart, thoughtful, and well intentioned in every way. We stand behind their work without hesitation or question. They are doing work that they have been asked to do and they are doing it exceptionally well K-12 in every discipline.
Second, it may seem silly to some, but the fact that “Jingle Bells” was first performed in minstrel shows where white actors performed in blackface does actually matter when it comes to questions of what we use as material in school. I’m glad that our staff paused when learning of this, reflected, and decided to use different material to accomplish the same objective in class. It is also important to note that a song so closely related to a religious holiday that is not celebrated by everyone in our community was not likely a song that we would have wanted as part of the school curriculum in the first place. Our staff found that their simple objective could be accomplished by singing any one of many songs in class and therefore they chose to simply choose other songs.
Third, choosing songs other than “Jingle Bells” wasn’t a major policy initiative, a “banning” of the song or some significant change to a concert repertoire done in response to a complaint. This wasn’t “liberalism gone amok” or “cancel culture at its finest” as some have suggested. Nobody has said you shouldn’t sing “Jingle Bells” or ever in any way suggested that to your children. I can assure you that this situation is not an attempt to push an agenda. We were not and are not even discussing the song and its origins, whatever they may be. This was very simply a thoughtful shift made by thoughtful staff members who thought they could accomplish their instructional objective using different material. The change in material is also not something being forced on children or propaganda being spread. The teachers have never taught about the song in any way when it was being used then or in the midst of deciding not to use it.
In other words, suggestions that this situation is somehow being used as a way to indoctrinate children just doesn’t make sense either. It is as simple as this, we are using different songs, and we are not teaching about their history at this level. Nobody is discussing politics about the song or anything regarding its history with students. This is not a political situation, it was a simple, thoughtful curricular decision.
Finally, if there is ever a question as to whether or not something might be experienced differently by someone else, shouldn’t we be respectful of that? Is singing the song "Jingle Bells" so important that it outweighs the question about its past or its potential to not be inclusive in a variety of ways. If many, many songs are available to accomplish the same objective, then why wouldn’t we use those songs? I think our teachers answered that question very thoughtfully and I’m proud of their work.
What? They're Not? Well this is the first I'm hearing this :)
Did they ban rap that demeans women, uses the forbidden “N” word, and promotes drugs and violence?
NO IT DOES NOT!
This is where the idiocy starts and where it must be ENDED! Note this quote with my highlight; "In her research, the song's first public performance may have occurred in a minstrel show nearly 150 years ago, where white actors performed in blackface." We are talking about 1867 or there-a-bouts, when record keeping of such pop-culture was iffy at best!
So this Educrat then says "... the fact that “Jingle Bells” was first performed in minstrel shows ..." is a blatant LIE! Next the decision is based upon this research by a single academic. With all due consideration, it is not wise to base decisions on songs with a single attribution of a 'questionable past'! This is the road to perdition that is paved with the good intentions!
The School District Administration needs weeding ... BADLY!
“... first performed in minstrel shows where white actors performed in blackface ... “
So once again the ‘sins’ of our fathers from many generations ago are brought forth to punish our way of life today. IMHO the fidiots that came up with this faux concern should be put in the stocks!
Of course not! It’s ART!...................
Say wut? The bells are on a bob tailed bay. It’s a horse! Says so right in the lyrics for crying out loud.
Evidently, they’ve received some feed back because that email is now blocked.
Now we know where the lunatics went when Reagan emptied the mental hospitals. Public Schools.
Every week I read something and I say to myself that we’ve hit rock bottom. It can’t get any stupider. Every week I am wrong.
The ingenuity of idiots knows no bounds.
I think Gov Northam sang that in blackface.
Aaah yes, liberals doing what they do best; sucking the joy from everything they touch.
He mentions that the song is connected to a religious holiday not everyone celebrates, so I wonder what the kids are allowed to sing during “the holiday season.”. That would expose the real agenda.
When I was in school in ancient times we used to sing Stephen Foster songs. I’ll bet that isn’t done anymore.
Guess we’ll have to ban pianos, horns, percussion, vocals, guitars, clothes, stages, curtains, makeup, lighting, oxygen, water....etc. etc. etc.....anything that MIGHT HAVE BEEN USED IN MINSTREL SHOWS BEFORE THE DAWN OF TIME.
What idiocy.
Hope that education doofus gets voted out or replaced very soon.
Jingle Bells was also written for Thanksgiving, but that issue apparently didn’t come up.
In other news: All works of art, history and other cultural reverences are going to be banished because the first ancestor of man has been reported as having sinned.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.