Posted on 09/13/2019 1:59:52 PM PDT by Red Badger
A Dutch court acquitted a doctor on Wednesday of all charges for the euthanasia of an elderly woman who suffered from dementia but may not have wanted to end her life when her life was taken.
The landmark case received widespread media attention because prosecutors claim the doctor, who remains unnamed, did not properly consult her patient before injecting her with a lethal dose of drugs. The unnamed 74-year-old patient was given a sedative in her coffee and had to be restrained by her husband and daughter as the doctor injected her with the deadly drugs.
"We conclude that all requirements of the euthanasia legislation had been met. Therefore the suspect is acquitted of all charges," Judge Mariette Renckens said at the court in The Hague.
The case tested the interpretation and scope of the Netherlands' euthanasia laws after the country became the first nation to legalize medical euthanasia in 2002.
This is the first case of a doctor being accused of wrongfully causing her patient's death, but Wednesday's ruling determined that the doctor correctly followed her patient's instruction to end her life despite her having to be restrained at the time of her death in 2016.
Judge Renckens based her decision on a declaration the patient wrote four years before her death saying that she would rather be euthanized than placed in a nursing home with other patients who suffered from dementia.
According to the Dutch Euthanasia Review Committee, which reviews every euthanasia case, the woman wrote: "I want to be able to decide (when to die) while still in my senses and when I think the time is right."
Shortly after being taken into the care of her doctor, the doctor determined that she qualified for euthanasia. Dutch law requires that a patient must be subject to "unbearable and endless suffering" and have requested to die "earnestly and with full conviction" to qualify for euthanasia.
The Journal.ie reports that two independent doctors also concluded she qualified for euthanasia but when it came time to receive a lethal injection, the woman stood up while the drug was being administered before being held down by her family.
The woman's daughter said in a statement in court that she supported the doctor's actions and said she "freed my mother from the mental prison which she ended up in."
"A crucial question to this case is how long a doctor should continue consulting a patient with dementia, if the patient in an earlier stage already requested euthanasia," Sanna van der Harg, a spokesperson for the prosecutors, told the BBC. The prosecutors said they did not doubt the doctor's intentions, but believed the patient should have been more involved in her death.
However, Judge Renckens ruled that the doctor "did not need to verify the current desire for euthanasia" because the patient's desires to be euthanized were clearly stated in her living will, Reuters reported.
The now-retired doctor was not at court Wednesday but her lawyer Robert-Jan van Eenennaam told reporters "she will be delighted with the verdict."
"The judges were very clear in their verdict that she acted in the correct manner. But my client still feels that a criminal case was not the correct way to deal with the issue. She has been through a lot these past few months."
Prosecution spokesperson Sanne van der Harg said that "clearly the judges thought about it differently than we did."
"We will now carefully study the verdict and decide at a later stage whether we will lodge an appeal," the spokesperson added.
This is going on here in this country.
Interesting that you didn't mention that her husband didn't participate. It's usually the husband. Remember Terry Sciavo.
can anyone say NAZI Eugenics program? Because that is what this is.
I guess I should have used the word “adult” instead of “individual” to make my point about “forced suicide”.
White Rose Ping, in honor of Terri Schiavo
Stolen kidney! oh my gosh.
To my fellow Baby Boomers; you had better be paying attention.
Its not ethnic, its cultural. If you are going to insulting at least try to get the correct insult.
Napoleon could care less if they were ethnic or cultural British. He hated the British all the same and sent the memo to his propaganda ministers. Effacement was necessary, beginning with small words and then a steady uptick on the volume.
More stories like that on this side of the pond and more to come. This is because class identification is necessary for power advancement in a democratic age.
I'm glad you're awake now.
AKA...
SLIPPERY SLOPE.
Well i dont hate the dutch personally but i detest some of their radical
culture but i will share that most europeans do hate the dutch.
Americans better vote wisely. This kind of thing has already happened to Terri and others, and probably many we don’t know about.
2 of them did....................
Logan’s Run comes to mind..........................
Exactly. This is murder.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.