Posted on 08/17/2012 11:47:30 AM PDT by Mountain Bike Vomit Carnage
Two Denver hikers are locked in a bitter battle over the fate of a German Shepard named Missy, who was abandoned by one and then rescued by another at 13,000 feet.
Scott Washburn found the dog bloodied and near-death atop Colorado's Mt Bierstadt and then organized a search and rescue party to save her.
He wants to keep the dog, alleging that Anthony Ortolani lacks the ability or compassion to care for the creature, which went without food and water for eight days.
But Mr Ortolani says he didn't abandon the animal, an oncoming storm forced him to choose between staying by her side and perishing, or going down the mountain without her.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2189640/Canine-custody-battle-Hiker-climbed-13-000ft-rescue-Missy-German-Shepherd-wants-owner-forced-leave-dog-mountain.html#ixzz23pYWurwx
(Excerpt) Read more at dailymail.co.uk ...
So you and your child and dog are stuck on a mountain. The dog is injured and a storm is coming. You can rescue yourself and child if you leave the dog behind. Or you stay and all three of you may die. You would deny your child a chance at a full life for a dog? Bull. And if you did you’re a crappy parent. I love my dog but my three sons are 1000x more important. Get some perspective man.
I think we should let Missy decide - I’m sure she’d make the right decision :-)
I would not leave my dog to die even if I was going to die. I would pray for divine intervention. The guy who left her is abominable.
you mean the moron in the underwear
>> I love my dog but my three sons are 1000x more important. Get some perspective man.< <
You are on a life raft. There is only food for 2 people for a few days. You have 2 kids both under 5 years old.
What do you do?
You have 2 kids and somehow have criminals grab you. They will shoot one of them. You name the one. What do you do?
I can play this all day.
I am saying my decision deals with me and me alone. The dog and I are a pair. Period (actually I am mentally substituting my beloved kitty who sadly passed a few years ago).
Many people with pets refuse to be rescued if their pets aren’t rescued as well. And rightly so.
That isn’t the situation here so false imperatives really aren’t in play.
This man behaved without thought or concern for this animal who trusted him, and the one who went back and saved her is a hero. Who loves this dog?
The man who went back to find her, without knowing whether she was even alive.
>>Legally, it is property. It is private property. Animal or not, this does not change.<<
The term you are searching for is “chattel.” And, thank God, courts are now applying different standards in evaluating pet cases. For example, my departed kitty was probably “worth” a buck or less.
But if someone harmed her, they would — in most jurisdictions — be on the hook for all the vet and care costs, even if that ran into the thousands.
It might be a bit less of an issue for animals raised as food. But I have to admit I don’t know how the laws apply to farm chattel.
There are animal welfare laws for good reason.
I’d say both taking her up there and walking her across sharp rocks until she could walk no more were abusive acts, and not making any effort to go and recover her thereafter—except for seeing if the government would do it for him—was pretty offensive too.
The knucklehead doesn’t deserve to have her back and she’d be better off without the knucklehead. But as someone pointed out earlier, the chances are probably pretty good that he will get her back.
I have two GSDs , brother and sister and they would have found all three of us there in this situation. My dogs wouldn’t abandon me and I wouldn’t abanson them.
I hate idiots like that. Give his dog to those granola hippies who saved it. The End.
He didn't even have the heart to go back for her - dead or alive.
Any decent person would want a decent burial for a beloved pet. This scum left Missy to die like a piece of trash!!
He shouldn't be allowed anywhere near her again.
My guess is the authorities are going to investigate to see of he is guilty of neglect, abuse and abandonment of the dog which would allow them to take the dog away from him to give to the rescuers. This guy may regret fighting for the dog because he might end up being prosecuted.
"An anti-Obama coward lured a stray cat with food and then impaled it and burned it alive."
I did an internet search and yes, there's a story out there about it and it is sickening. I guess it is being considered a threat directed at Obama.
The body of a burned cat and a message directed to President Barack Obama were found in Longfellow Park, city and federal officials said.Minneapolis police, the FBI, the U.S. Secret Service and other agencies responded to the message a parks employee found Monday near the Longfellow Park and Recreation Center, a voting location used in Tuesday's primary election.
Dawn Sommers, spokeswoman for the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board, said the cat's body was found with a political message attached to it at the south end of the park.
[Source is Twincities.com: Minneapolis: Reward offered after burned cat, anti-Obama message found in park]
I don't know what to say.
It sounds to me the guy (not man) was thinking more about his own interests and passions, and less about those under his care and protection.
A man puts the care and protection of those (human or animal) with whom he is entrusted BEFORE pursuit of his own interests and passions.
There is a road almost to the summit of Mt. Evans. Someone could have driven up there to go down tothe dog and then picked the dog and rescuers up slightly lower.
The dog was at ~13,000ft elevation. The climbers didn't start at zer0 ft, so they had to climb many fewer thousand feet than the title implies. It could have been a lot less if they took the road.
I’m glad the dog survived this ordeal.
(Oh, and German Shepherd ping! )
My guess is the owner will be charged criminally with animal cruelty and abandonment, then be offered a plea deal if he agreed to surrender the dog, pay for vet fees, and agree not to have another dog.
The first owner abandoned the dog to death and it should be dead in his life. The second owner gave the dog his life and deserves to keep it.
Its pretty obvious to me and I wouldn’t abandon my dog even if I had to carry down on my back.
By the way, what kind of idiot takes a dog into such a place in the first place?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.