Posted on 06/12/2011 6:31:37 PM PDT by nickcarraway
She prayed for peace that day.
But the sage that Robin Brown carried on a bird-watching outing in Weston landed her in jail on felony charges of marijuana possession.
Now she is suing over the wrongful arrest.
"I'm not out for revenge," said Brown, 49, a soft-spoken woman from Montana who moved to Hollywood in 2007. "I'm trying to bring information to light so that it doesn't happen to anyone else."
Sheriff's Deputy Dominic Raimondi, 51, mistook Brown's sage for marijuana, then searched her car and found more. His field kit said the sage — purchased at an airport gift shop in Albuquerque, N.M. — tested positive for marijuana.
He did not arrest her that day in March 2009, but sent the 50 grams of "contraband" to the crime lab for a more definitive test.
Assistant State Attorney Mark Horn ordered Brown's arrest without having the sage tested, court records show.
Three months later, Raimondi showed up at the Massage Envy in Weston where Brown works and took her away in handcuffs.
"They arrested me in front of my customers, my boss, my co-workers," Brown said. She later was subjected to a body cavity search, a strip search and an overnight stay in jail.
A month later, Brown's attorney discovered that the sage had never been tested at the Broward Sheriff's Office crime lab.
"When I found out they didn't do a lab test, I was outraged," said her Miami attorney, Bill Ullman. "I raised hell about that."
On July 23, 2009, Ullman demanded that the sage be tested.
The lab test concluded that the dried sage was not marijuana at all.
The criminal charges were dropped.
Ullman said one apologetic prosecutor called him to say it was "scary" someone could be arrested under such circumstances.
"Our policy is to make sure the evidence is tested at the very least before trial," said Ron Ishoy, spokesman for the Broward State Attorney's Office. "Looking back now at this specific police report, it would have been the better practice to test the evidence before filing a formal charge."
Field tests are unreliable and can give a false positive, said John Kelly, a forensic drug test expert based in Washington, D.C.
Brown filed a civil lawsuit claiming public humiliation, mental pain and suffering. The suit accuses the Broward State Attorney's Office of negligence and malicious prosecution.
Circuit Judge John Bowman dismissed the case in January, saying prosecutors are given immunity from lawsuits in the course of doing their jobs.
Brown is appealing to 4 District Court of Appeal in hopes she will be granted the right to a jury trial.
"We just want a chance to go to trial and let a jury decide if the prosecution should have immunity," she said. "We are appealing to a higher court so my case can be heard."
Ullman argues that, in this case, the prosecutor should not have immunity.
"They said if we allow people to sue prosecutors for mistakes they would be afraid to do their jobs," Ullman said. "In this case, the prosecutor should be sued because he filed a false statement swearing she had marijuana. And she didn't."
Brown was birdwatching that day in the woods off U.S. Highway 27.
An avid bird-watcher, Brown brought her sage along for smudging, a purification ritual popular among Native American tribes and spiritual groups. Brown believes the smoke from the sage helps clear negative energy and also helps take your prayers to heaven.
Before heading back to her car, Brown burned the sage in a clay pot to give thanks for the wildlife she had seen that day.
"Smudging is a way for me to give thanks and express my gratitude," she said. "That day, I was using it to carry my prayers to heaven."
When Brown returned to her car, a deputy and officer with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission were waiting. They asked what she was doing there.
Bird-watching, she told them. When they continued to question her, she opened her backpack to show them her binoculars and bird book.
That's when the deputy spotted her sage and the smudging bowl with burned ashes.
Three months later, she found herself in jail.
"I tried to look tough, but inside I was quaking," she said. "I didn't know how long I would be there. All I knew was that something had gone terribly wrong. A few months had gone by. I thought I was in the clear."
After her fiance posted $1,000 bail, she was released at 4 a.m. in Pompano Beach.
Brown says she has learned her lesson. She leaves the sage at home these days.
Well, we haven’t had a raucous WOD thread in quite some time.
There are many herbs that appear to be drugs — and the lady should NOT have to stop carrying sage if she finds it enhances her bird-watching activities.
Wrong lesson to learn in a free country....
I’m siding with the bird-watcher on this one.
Or maybe they would be more careful in how they do their jobs.
Two ozs is a felony, wow.
Wow, I didn’t realize that sage will trip up field kits.
Ya think?
No I think she should bring the sage with her. Excuse my ignorance, but how does Sage resemble marijuana?
Sage doesn’t smell or look like pot, those are some dumb old boys in that department. I think even Barney Fife would of figured that one out or at least Andy.
Sage doesn’t smell or look like pot, those are some dumb old boys in that department. I think even Barney Fife would of figured that one out or at least Andy.
How couldn’t you? What did she do wrong?
How the F%$#! is this different from any other job? We should not only NOT hold public officers to a higher standard -- we should have absolutely ZERO standard, ZERO accountability, and UNLIMITED ability to do whatever the F%$# they want to whoever they want for any reason they want!! In the case of a prosecutor making a mistake, the life of the falsely accused/ prosecuted/ convicted is inevitably royally screwed up. And that's aside from the fact that allowing prosecutors free rein to make "mistakes" without any repercussion makes a mockery of the concept of "innocent until proven guilty".
This idiot should be dancing at the end of a rope right now instead of making lame excuses like this.
She should sue the Major County Sheriffs Association Inc,
http://www.mcsheriffs.com/officers.shtml
That’s the only way to fix this.
I paid a lot of money for sage back in my early college days...but that’s another story.
I was wondering the same thing - especially when it comes in a store-bought plastic sleeve labeled “Smudge stick” (in the video at link).
The cops involved here must not have ever seen someone actually smoking dope. If they had, they’d probably know most people generally don’t bundle it with incense and then burn it outdoors in a giant woven bowl. /sarc
She did nothing wrong, obviously. I just didn’t feel like making a longer post (bit tired tonight).
Even if it had been marijuana there was NO NEED to arrest her, no need to handcuff her, no need for the jailing and the body cavity search. Why? It's not a big crime. Not a violent crime. Serve her to appear in court. This is presumptive criminal process, totally beyond anything the Founders would have tolerated.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.