[EveningStar]

I originally posted this as an addendum to this thread, but it probably deserves a thread of its own.

[rightbrained]

Dylan’s a huge phony

[EveningStar]

ping

[Mr. Blonde]

Bob Dylan took this guy’s girlfriend ping!

[equalitybeforethelaw]

The article is blocked. I am at work. Love Joni and enjoyed Dylan. How much slicing did Joni do in this article?

[E. Pluribus Unum]

Dylan listened to lots of old 78s of rural groups to come up with his sound.

He admits it.

All honest musicians admit they borrow from what came before.

The dishonest ones pretend like their music was immaculately conceived.

[brooklyn dave]

His voice always got on my nerves. He can’t sing worth a $hit. “The answer my friend is blowing out your butt, the answer is blowing out your butt.” Great going Joanie!

[vladimir998]

One barely-there talent attacking another barely-there talent.

Whatever.

[subterfuge]

Dylan may be a “phony”, but Joni Mitchell is simply a drug addled hack herself.

[End Times Sentinel]

I didn’t read the article, but it says Bob Dylan is a homo, huh?

I’d be more surprised if I knew anything about him.

[dead]

If I wrote this article, I would have written it about Eric Clapton instead.

[EveningStar]

ping

[Mr. Mojo]

“Bob [Dylan] is not authentic at all."

He's certainly not an authentic "folky" ....which is a major compliment. Bob has a lot of fiscal (and even some social) conservative views that rile many in the folk crowd.

But Dylan's songwriting and lyric talents are of the highest caliber.

[Deb]

If recording company PR guys and the media could sell Bob Zimmerman as a genius, is it any wonder they could sell Barak Hussein Obama as a viable presidential candidate?

Although I was always curious who the first person was who told Dylan he was a singer.

[dmz]

LOL.

The mere mention of Bob Dylan’s name will cause haters to spring forth from the ground much like the waters of the great flood.

And Joni Mitchell accusing others of sleeping around? That’s the funniest thing of all. The phrase “go ahead and [sleep with]* her, I did” was coined for her. It’s a good thing Crosby Still Nash and Young were only 4 guys, and not a marching band.

*replace with 4 letter word

That being said, I still like her music (kind of - her latest cd has some pretty good stuff on it), but there are very few Dylan cds NOT on my iPod (thank God for 120 gig iPod classics).

[GSWarrior]

The real tragedy is that none of these very well-documented and nigh irrefutable plagiarism charges will ever emerge from the shadows

Spare me the histrionics!

[ETL]

"his name and voice are fake. "

Ha, I knew it! How could such an awful "voice" be for real!

[Oshkalaboomboom]

Must be a slow news day.

[allmendream]

So a bunch of songs that Dylan sings or has sung that nobody has ever really heard of might be too similar to other recorded music.

Whatever.

The guy is a great songwriter and a lousy performer.

And he hasn't written a decent song for decades.

You may as well go after Led Zeppelin as “phonies” because they covered or “re” arranged - “You Shook Me”, “You Need Love” (sung as “Whole Lotta Love”), “Killing Floor” (sung as “The Lemon Song”), “Bring it on Home”, “Shake em on Down (sung as “Hat's off to Roy Harper”), “I Can't Quit You Baby”, and “Traveling Riverside Blues” from Willie Dixon, Howlin Wolf and Robert Johnson.

Whatever.

[evets]

She looks pretty good for 70...

It's a Joni Mitchell concert, sans Joni (interview with Joni and a male Joni Mitchell impersonator)

[AngelesCrestHighway]

When old hippies go bad......