Posted on 05/26/2004 5:05:16 PM PDT by Howlin
Last night!!!
Yes. Fantasia has great range but relies on vocal tricks. Diana has great range also but she can hit the note without searching for it.
Just unloaded groceries....I see Jazz is , (a'hem) singing!
George is on? He was the one I was rooting for until he was cut.
Everyone keeps talking about what a polished entertainer Fantasia is, but the way she was flopping around the stage during her last song was very distracting to me.
Seriously, Jasmine just eliminated any remaining doubts about whether or not she belonged up there tonight. I've heard better at elementary school talent shows!
over here
the back up singers were better than her.
Vocal tricks? Two different styles...Fantasia has more talent in her little finger. However, Diana is perfect to be the American Idol because who really goes to those tour concerts? 10 - 15 year old girls. Not exactly the Aretha Franklin crowd. However, in all fairness, I must say that the final song was HORRIBLE. Just the most HORRIBLE song I've ever heard. At least Kelly's A MOMENT LIKE THIS was really a song. My prediction is that Fantasia will have a better music career and Diana will end up doing tours, teen movies and stage work.
My husband said the same thing!
My husband said the same thing!
I knew I forgot to ping somebody!
He was my favorite too. I don't know if he'll be on again or not. I'm taping the rest of the show in case he sings again. My sister got to meet him and I'm so jealous. He showed up in her class room in New Orleans a couple weeks ago and sang for the kids. He gave her a hug and autograph. She said she and the other teachers acted like teenagers when they saw him. She said he is very nice.
One of the ex-contestants wrote that song, Tamara?
Dreadful.
Go Fantasia!
Thanks for the ping Howlin. How did we go from cheap to sleazy? LOL
I am watching : )
GO DIANA
I remembered, but I think she is teaching a class tonight....
Familiarity!
I'm stickin' with my theory--loser wins and winner loses. Diana #1, Fantasia #2. I hope I'm wrong, but the democratic process doesn't necessarily produce an optimal outcome.
GO DIANA
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.