Posted on 08/18/2022 7:11:55 AM PDT by ProfessorGoldiloxx
Idris Elba was Heimdall in the Marvel Thor movies.
I’m sure the Nordic people that never saw a black person worship a black god…
I understand what you are saying.. but like I said, your view is skewed by your environment, and what you consider “normal”.
If a Korean or Indian film maker where doing shakespere they would use Korean or Indian actors usually.
The same way Hollywood used white men in makeup to play Indians or Asians in old movies.
I have been watching a lot of Bollywood and Korean-made films recently and it what I am trying to explain suddenly accured to me.
I heard dat white wizard be doin’ magic and sheit…
Wolkien
Actually, in Tolkien’s work the female dwarfs do have beards. There was only one dwarf female, Dis, who was ever mentioned by name though.
GOT’s final season ended my interest in any other GOT prequels, sequels or any other “quels”!
It was so poorly done and an obvious rush job. It was clear the actors had had enough and were only interested in cashing their checks and moving on.
That's not to say I shun film versions of my favorite books. I will almost always be up for watching a film based on a book I've read. It's just very difficult for any film maker to top the written version.
I was on a business trip to Germany in the late 2000s. After dinner, I returned to my hotel room and turned on the TV. There was a Star Trek episode playing. The audio was dubbed with German speakers. The voices were VERY different from the original English speaking actors. Mostly voices that were much lower. It was amusing when observed from a background of having heard the original English speaking actors.
Almost no movie matches the book it it based on. The book is almost always better, and LotR is great literature that is virtually impossible to encapsulate in cinema. That said, I feel that Peter Jackson and his team did a fantastic job with the LotR movies.
Jackson clearly loved the source material and tried to distill it as faithfully as he could. He delivers on giving a feel of Tolkien’s world and the major outlines of the story. The movies were a technical achievement of their day; the stand well on their own and they did a great job of introducing millions to Tolkien’s work who never would have read it before.
My kids like to pull the DVDs out a couple times a year and we all end up watching the whole extended edition. They have also worn out a couple sets of the books.
The Hobbit movies were a big let down in comparison.
Bingo! The very reason I avoid most of what they produce. The reason my TV hasn't been powered up and displaying "broadcast" TV since 1999. I encounter it periodically on the TV screens at Applebee's. It just affirms my resolve to not waste power running the boob tube at home with that content source.
There are two volumes yet to be released, "The Winds Of Winter" and "A Dream Of Spring." I'm pretty sure that Martin will deviate quite a bit from how the TV series ended, especially after the audience reaction to it.
That is, if he ever gets those two books finished. George RR Martin is pushing into his mid-70s and doesn't look too healthy based on photos of him. In fact, he looks like he could play the role of one of the aging maesters on the TV show!
I hope he's able to push those final books out because as I said earlier, he's a very good writer.
Some stories are rooted in European white ethnicity. The legend of King Arthur. Norse myths. Much of Shakespeare. European history.
These woke films aren't even engaged in color blind casting in search of the "best actors." They're intentionally seeking to rewrite Europeans stories and histories. The hope is that future generations will think that Europe always had large numbers of Africans and Muslims, and that European achievements are African and Muslims achievements.
There was a recent movie about Anne Boleyn, in which she was portrayed by a very African looking African. Sorry, that's not history.
Kevin Hart is kind of funny. Plus, you're right. It's not new and wasn't political in the old days. You realize that none of the four main actors in the 1986 movies was Jewish either.
Hollywood is all about copying, and I don't think anybody had any serious trouble with "The New Odd Couple" (which nobody watched) being African-American. It's on par with remaking a French or Japanese movie with an American cast or vice versa.
There's a difference between recasting movies about contemporary life and "nontraditional casting" in historical dramas. Hollywood overdoes it now, but it wasn't always a terrible thing.
In kill bill, that Interaction between Hattori Hanzo and his assistant was great!
WTH? Anyone care to translate this?
I can’t make heads or tails of the article.
Tolkien's "privileged" race of men, the Numenoreans, sailed to other places in Middle Earth, initially as teachers, bringers of medicine, etc.. This included sailing to lands further south where there were people "of color".
But over time, many Numenoreans became corrupted and greedy, and began enslaving other people in Middle-Earth for their own benefit. Eventually, those other people in Middle-Earth rebelled against the Numenorians. The Faithful, those Numenoreans who stayed loyal to the Valar, oppose that slavery and exploitation.
So crap, you have this great potential storyline of oppressed people rebelling against those who would try to enslave them. Great roles for "actors of color" right there in the source material. That background is especially key because it explains why Sauron was later able to recruit the descendents of those people to his cause.
Instead, they go full woke. We now have black elves, black dwarves, and romantic/sexual relationships between elves and men, directly contradicting Tolkien's own statement that there were only three unions of elves and men prior to Aragorn and Arwen.
Utter crap.
Amazon Studios Sets Inclusion Policy And Playbook For Its Content And Productions"
So does Netflix: Netflix to Invest $100 Million to Improve Diversity in TV Shows, Films
So do the Oscars. Academy Establishes Representation And Inclusion Standards For Oscars® Eligibility
I agree that many times they are simply doing it for shock value or to push an agenda. And when they do it for that reason, the movie typically fails.
But, if they simply pick the best person for the role regardless of race, it can sometimes be surprisingly good.
honestly most amazon shows are garbage regardless of the color of the actors.
Netflix makes great content, but then inserts “wokeness” into them. Amazon just makes trash. They choose good stories, but the execution is horrible.
I don’t understand it, either, and I’m sorry I read it.
It’s nothing more than a profanity-filled blog post complaining that some of the actors are nonwhite in a new TV series based on LOTR.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.