Skip to comments.FBI Arrests Houston Officers in Fall-out of Harding Street Raid, Deprivation of Rights
Posted on 11/26/2019 2:56:36 AM PST by marktwain
The Federal investigation into the no-knock raid on 7815 Harding Street in Houston Texas, on January 28th, 2019, where the married couple, Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas were killed in their home, has resulted in indictments and arrests for three people. Those three are former officers Gerald M. Goines, 55, Seven M. Bryant, 46, and neighbor Patricia Ann Garcia, 53.
There were many suspicious facts about the raid that raised red flags from the start. Initially, the Houston Police Department, Police Chief Acevedo, and the Houstion Police Union circled the wagons and insisted the raid was legitimate.
In August, the Harris County Prosecutor Charged Goines and Bryant with crimes. They were arrested and released on bond. Now, both have been charged and arrested on the federal charges, and the neighbor across the street, Patricia Ann Garcia, has been arrested on federal charges. From justice.gov:
A federal grand jury returned the nine count indictment Nov. 14 against Gerald M. Goines, 55, and Steven M. Bryant, 46, both former Houston Police Department (HPD) officers. Also charged is Patricia Ann Garcia, 53. All are residents of Houston. The indictment was unsealed this morning as authorities took all three into custody. They are expected to make their initial appearances before U.S. Magistrate Judge Dena H. Palermo at 2 p.m. central time.
Former officer Goines is charged with two counts of depriving victims of their Constitutional rights against unreasonable searches. According to HPD Chief Alcevdo, the charges are under Title 18 U.S.C. 242, deprivation of rights under color of authority.
Both Goines and former officer Bryant are also charged with obstructing justice by falsifying records; Goines for false statements in his offense report and tactical plan connected with the search warrant, and Bryant for false statements in a supplemental report, after the raid was conducted. There are three more obstruction charges against Goines for statements after the raid. Goines faces sentences of 20 years to life. Bryant faces up to 20 years on the falsification of records charge.
Images from Houston Police Department, source nbcnews.com, 23 August, 2019, combined, cropped and scaled by Dean Weingarten.
Garcia is charged with conveying false information. Cheif Alcevedo says she was the neighbor across the street from 7815 Harding Street.
The charges against Garcia allege she conveyed false information by making several fake 911 calls. Specifically, on Jan. 8, she allegedly made several calls claiming her daughter was inside the Harding Street location. According to the indictment, Garcia added that the residents of the home were addicts and drug dealers and that they had guns including machine guns inside the home. The charges allege none of Garcias claims were true.
In Cheif Acevedo's statement, he says Garcia was charged with Title 18 U.S.C. § 1018, but I find the maximum sentence for that section is one year in prison. The press release from the DOJ, Southern District of Texas, says she faces a five year maximum sentence. The charge may be Conveying False Information with Malicious Conduct, which has a maximum sentence of five years in prison, under 18 U.S.C. § 2292.
The arrest warrants were issued in the Southern District of Texas on 14 November, 2019, according the Chief Acevedo. Goines and Garcia were arrested in Harris County, Texas. Former Officer Bryant was arrested in Fort Bend County, Texas. Garcia was arrested at 7812 Harding Street, according to Chief Alcevedo.
Alcevedo mentioned all three arrestees were transported to the FBI field office in Houston.
Police Chief Alcevedo held a press conference shortly after the arrests were announced. His spin was considerably different from previous press conferences. In this press conference, he claims the investigation by HPD into Goines, Bryant, and Garcia all started mere days after the incident. But the HPD did not initiate charges or arrests of these individuals. In fact, it appears the HPD disapproved of the charges and arrests by the Harris County prosecutor earlier this year. Now Chief Acevedo is attempting to take credit for the FBI charges and arrests.
Chief Acevedo now says "...today is another step in that journey towards justice and the journey to justice for the deceased individuals, Ms Regina and Mr. Tuttle."
Later, he says:
"Our number one responsibility is to the Tuttle's, the Tuttle family, Regina and her family, and the officers who went to execute what they believed to be a lawfully obtained search warrant based on factual information provided by the case agent, ."
This is a considerable difference in attitude from Chief Acevedo's comments a few months ago. In May, according to Reason, Acevedo was still blaming the Tuttles for the raid.
Although Police Chief Art Acevedo has said the affidavit for the search warrant was falsified, he continues to defend the investigation that led to the raid, citing a January 8 call from an unnamed woman who reported that her daughter was using drugs at the house and described Tuttle and Nicholas as armed and dangerous drug dealers. Acevedo also said neighbors had thanked police for raiding the couple's home, which he said was locally notorious as a "drug house" and a "problem location."
Speculation: Might this be related to the Federal indictments, the families independent investigation, and the lawsuit by the family?
Link to Acevedo Press Conference Video
In the latest press conference, Chief Avecedo admits that most (more than half) homes in Texas are likely to have guns.
"..most houses, I would say a greater number, you would find firearms than not."
This undercuts the idea the mere presence of firearms is sufficient to justify a no-knock raid. It also emphasizes a loose end in the investigation former officer Goines. From khou.com:
Goines swore in search warrant affidavits that knocking and announcing would be dangerous, futile, because he claimed a confidential informant had seen a gun inside. Those claims led judges to grant no-knock warrants, which accounted for 96 percent of all the search warrants he filed in the last seven years, a KHOU 11 Investigation has found.
But in every one of the more than 100 drug cases based off those warrants, theres no record of Goines ever seizing a gun after executing a no-knock search warrant.
HPD deserves some credit. They interviewed and taped then officer Goines in the hospital. The interview video and written replies were critical in unraveling the lies which were used to build the case for the warrant.
I suspect there are ongoing federal and Harris county investigations about what happened to the guns that were found in the 100 drug cases based on Goines' no-knock warrants. The idea that *no* guns were found is absurd.
There were numerous rumors floated over the past 10 months that it was Regina's mother who called the police. This was predicated on the caller complaining that her "daughter" was doing drugs at 7815 Harding Street.
The caller was no relation to the Tuttles. She only lived across the street. The "daughter" in the house never existed, except as a fabrication. As there was no other woman in the house, people concluded Regina was the non-existant daughter.
It is now understood 7815 Harding Street was the targeted address for the raid. Early speculation of a mix-up with another address (7815 Hardy Street) was not correct. The police did not mix up the addresses. Chief Acevedo did not help when he mixed up "Hardy" and "Harding" in early reports.
There is an unresolved ambiguity about how the .357 revolver was not included in the initial inventory at the scene, then showed up later.
One advantage of our litigious society, is pressure can be exerted in cases such as this.
The deaths innocents and wounding of officers could have been entirely prevented, if the warrant had been presented in a reasonable manner. No-knock warrants are controlled much more tightly now, according to Chief Acevedo. No-knock warrants should be exceedingly rare in the United States.
A question for readers to consider: Houston is a heavily Democrat city. Would the federal investigation of the Harding Street no-knock raid have occurred if Hillary Clinton were President?
©2019 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice and link are included.
The federal investigation has resulted in three arrests, two of them former police officers.
They were always justified for special circumstances.
They have become common with the "war on drugs".
the charges are under Title 18 U.S.C. 242, deprivation of rights under color of authority.
The death penalty is an option under this statute.
After 100 no-knock warrants?
I'd have gotten suspicious of Goines after he executed a half dozen such warrants without turning up any firearms.
What was the name of that lady across the street in the old TV Series Bewitched. That is the name they should use for Red Flag laws.
FBI: “WE can do that. YOU can’t.”
May they end up in general population if found guilty
Alice Kravitz (sp?)
Im of the opinion that any government personnel who enacts or enforces gun control laws should be charged with Title 18 Sec 242.
Wow! Great report.
> I honestly think that no-knock raids are unconstitutional.
Too dangerous for everybody involved, including the police.
In this particular raid, every living thing in the dwelling was killed: the humans and their dog. In fact, the shooting started with the killing of the dog by the police.
I recall one poster on freerepublic who denigrated Ammoland after reading my first article on the subject.
Ammoland has been ahead of the curve on this event, all the way.
Why did it take the FIB years to look into it? Looks like it didn't take near as long for the nazis to go krystalnacht.
Good job on this, bro.
The police chief is Acevedo,not Alcevedo.
I think it was Gladys Kravitz.
The raid occurred on January 28th of this year, 2019.
The FBI was investigating by February, if I recall properly.
Yes, there are plenty of bad no-knock raids out there.
I gets harder to cover them up with the ubiquitous possession of digital recording devices.
The Houston PD tried in this raid. They confiscated that neighbor’s security camera recording, and were careful not to wear body cameras during this raid.
But private investigators, hired by the Tuttle family, found cell phone recoding of the raid.
Simply by the luck of the bullet, the chief fabricator and lead officer was hit in the neck. He could not talk, making it difficult for him to coordinate coverup efforts, in my humble opinion.
Heroin was found in his car, but not at the house raided.
Want to bet it would have been found in the house, if he had not been wounded?
Finally some justice and at the hands of the FBI no less!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.