Posted on 05/10/2010 3:17:06 PM PDT by Davy Buck
"If Lee was a traitor (and I don't believe he was), he would be the only traitor for which a ship in the United States Navy was ever named. He would be the only traitor in Statuary Hall at the U.S. Capitol. He would be the only traitor whose image was used in a positive way to recruit military personnel to fight and win WWII. Quite an accomplishment for a "traitor", wouldn't you say. . ."
(Excerpt) Read more at oldvirginiablog.blogspot.com ...
Yet Lee was an honorable man of impeccable character. In Lee's perspective, after secession, he was loyal to his home state of Virginia -- even though disloyal to the continuing government of the United States. This conflict of loyalties was inherent in the American system of government of that era.
Moreover, when the war was lost, instead of transitioning to guerrilla warfare, Lee surrendered at Appomattox and spared the country a continued and even more bitter conflict. Similarly, in civilian life after the war, Lee's good conduct and support for reconciliation with the North did much to ease sectional and racial tensions and helped knit the country together.
Lee disapproved of violence against Blacks and was a leader of a successful effort to establish a system of schools in Virginia for Blacks. Lee also applied for a federal pardon and restoration of his citizenship.
Wisely, to promote reconciliation, the victorious North chose not to prosecute Lee and recognized him as the honorable adversary that he had been. Over the next generation, Lee was gradually embraced as a national hero.
This longstanding consensus is now rejected by many Black opinion makers on the basis that because of slavery, all things Confederate are evil -- and elite opinion has sided with this view. Hence, Lee sometimes gets condemned now as a "traitor," often by people whose concept of loyalty to the United States is unusually loose.
Agree...
I as you state like what I like.... Not what others tell me I should or shouldn’t ..
Stay Safe Sir....
To which you replied:
"Watch out for the miniballs"
Let me be the first! They were Minié balls; named after co-developer, Claude Etienne Minié, inventor of the Minié rifle
Stepping back into the tree line--fire at will!
I just hope the South doesn’t change more than it already has.
And that’s from a Yankee y’all.
LOL...coming from you that is rich...very rich....you absolutely live for south bashing and white race baiting X....please.
let's don't be a hypocrite
And sadly, we all witnessed it again at the Duke LaCrosse incident....
Show the world you folks have grown up, and it will support your highest aspirations.!
And don’t forget George Washington WAS a redcoat, as a young man!
Gerald Ford signed the document that made R. E. Lee a citizen again. Since Lee fought for the south he lost his rights as a citizen of the USA. He did sign an oath after the war but it was lost and he never regained it until Ford signed it by an act of congress.
Lee had everything to lose by following his State of Virginia into the Confederacy, and nothing to gain personally. He had been offered the supreme command of the Union forces and turned it down because he correctly concluded that States were sovereign, and under Jeffersonian principles, people and their States had the right to fight against a govt. which exceeded Constitutional authority. Don’t kid yourselves. The Republican Party was the big-govt. party in those days, which wanted Federal public works and protective tariffs. The Republicans didn’t even bother campaigning in the South; they were a sectional party. The North used its vast industrial power, its complete naval dominance, and hordes of immigrant recruits to crush States’ rights by force. In the process, we all lost. If you really hold the obscene view that Lee, one of the finest leaders this country ever produced, was a traitor, then you must think the Tea Party movement consists of traitors. Shame on anyone who believes that.
LMAO !!
Ya’ll dry out yet ?
For a description of the Yankee behavior throughout the “Civil” War, please read “The South Was Right” by James Ronald Kennedy and Walter Donald Kennedy, Chapter 4.
Then talk to me about Andersonville. BTW, Captain Wirz was convicted on perjured testimony of a deserter. And Lincoln’s Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton, (hardly a Southern sympathizer, noted that a higher percentage of Southern POWs died in Northern captivity than did Yankee POWs in Confederate hands.
Can anyone deny the George Washington was a traitor to the British throne? Of course he was! Robert E’ Lee led a war against the USA but he wasn’t a traitor? Impossible!
“Though they were wrong about slavery,...”
As was the whole country. There was slavery in the north war was not fought to free slaves. The north has no moral high ground when it comes to slavery.
Uhhh, ya you’re right, all those Yankees committed suicide.
Southern men at arms are forever stained ... sorry - facts are facts.
“And sadly, we all witnessed it again at the Duke LaCrosse incident....”
Uh...you really have no idea what you are talking about. Yankee students at a Yankee run school are falsely accused by a black stripper and an immoral lawyer doing his best imitation of a Philadelphia lawyer prosecutes because he wants to maintain standing within the black community that is Durham, NC. No which correlates to the old South or Confederacy at all.
“Show the world you folks have grown up, and it will support your highest aspirations.!”
LOL! Let the world show us that they still care about the Republic that once was the U.S. and the South tried to preserve and it may have some standing. Until then, you are not worthy to judge us or even hold my jock.
Easley? You’re not very familiar with NC are you?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.