Posted on 04/18/2023 3:07:19 PM PDT by nickcarraway
Dr. Zahi Hawass, one of the most famous Egyptologists and the former Egyptian Minister of State for Antiquities Affairs, has criticized Netflix for its controversial decision to cast Cleopatra with a black actress in an upcoming docuseries.
The new Netflix series, dubbed “Queen Cleopatra”, which is produced and narrated by the American actress Jada Pinkett Smith, has sparked fierce debate over the misrepresentation of history and representation in TV and media.
Hawass, who is Egypt’s most recognizable archaeologist, decried the decision by Netflix to portray Cleopatra as being of black descent, pointing out that the historical figure “was Greek”.
Zahi Hawass criticizes portrayal of Cleopatra by Netflix
“I announced these days to the media that Cleopatra was not black,” Zahi posted on his Facebook account in response to the controversy surrounding the new Netflix series.
“The film that is coming on Netflix is not accurate and gives wrong information on ancient Egypt,” the famous Egyptologist continued.
Grecian Delight supports Greece
“Cleopatra was Greek and she was similar to the queens and princesses of Macedonia,” wrote Zahi, alluding to the fact that Cleopatra was a member of the Ptolemaic Dynasty who ruled over Egypt between 305 BC and 30 BC.
The Ptolemaic Dynasty was founded by Ptolemy I Soter, a Macedonian Greek who served Alexander the Great as a general, bodyguard, and historian. When Alexander died and his empire was split between his squabbling generals, Ptolemy established his own kingdom in Egypt.
Misrepresentation of Egyptian history
The Netflix series appears to have angered many Egyptians, as well as Greeks and people with a general interest in history who expressed their disappointment online.
A petition started by two Egyptians calling on Netflix to cancel their upcoming Cleopatra documentary garnered well over 60,000 signatures until it was removed by Change.org for “violating community guidelines”.
In his Facebook Zahi further discussed the historicity of the Netflix documentary vis-a-vis ancient Egypt even beyond the period of Ptolemaic rule.
“If we look at the scenes on the Egyptian temples, we can see that the pharaohs are depicted and in front of them were Nubian, Libyan, and Asian captives; the king is always completely different from all of them,” he wrote.
“During the 25th dynasty, the Kingdom of Kush ruled Egypt and those were Kushite pharaohs but they had nothing to do with ancient Egyptian civilization,” he continued.
The Kingdom of Kush was an ancient Nubian civilization of the Nile Valley. Its territory spanned what is today northern Sudan and southern Egypt. At various points throughout their history, the Kushites were both ruled by and ruled over the ancient Egyptians.
Like the Macedonian Greek Ptolemaic Dynasty, they were a foreign people who once ruled over the ancient Egyptians after the foundation of the 25th Dynasty by the Kushite King Piye in the 8th century BC.
Zahi concluded the Facebook post by saying “I am not against black people at all but here I am just listing the evidence that Cleopatra was not black.”
As a postscript to my earlier post, in this case Dr. Hawass is correct. But it sounds like the Netflix series has set a very low bar for historical accuracy.
CC
Some have speculated that Cleopatra was pretty short, about 5 ft tall Also was rather plump if not obese
“If they do a biopic of Martin Luther King, I think they should spare no expense and get the best actor they possibly can. Maybe Leonardo DiCaprio. Or Robert DeNiro.”
Since Macedonia is now northern Greece, she probably looked Greek— like Irene Pappas eg.
Thought the One Eyed One Horned Giant Purple People Eater was her direct descendant.
When Alexander the Greek conquered Egypt, he set one of his general, Ptolemy, as Pharaoh. The siblings married, so they were pure Macedonian Greek, i.e.white/CAUCASIAN. Cleopatra was the last of the line, which had ruled Egypt for almost 300 years.
Once upon a time, when schools taught factual history, we all knew this.
Coin depictions of her do not portray her as fat and neither do they make her look like a beauty.
Good old Zahi, still alive and collecting his salary.
Zahi had better watch it, or Jada will have Will Smith punch him in the face.
A petition started by two Egyptians calling on Netflix to cancel their upcoming Cleopatra documentary garnered well over 60,000 signatures until it was removed by Change.org for "violating community guidelines".
Change.org is just as much a piece of garbage as is Netflix.
Robert Downey Jr.
LOL, how about Dylan Mulvaney?
She probably did not have the figure of a teenager by the time she died but as she was a mother several times over that would not be unexpected. As for fat, probably not.
Oooooo..... a show worth watching!
So... probably not going to air on Netflex.
From the ancient coins I've seen, she wasn't a raving beauty, but she wasn't ugly either and supposedly she was extremely intelligent, well read, charming, and yes, charismatic.
Though older when Antony fell mightily for her, as well as a mother, she must have had enough allure, charm, and whit to have enticed him so thoroughly.
Cleopatra was black. Get used to it.........
“Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And the process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right.”
― George Orwell, 1984
DiNero is tooo old.
Plus he’s an a$$hole.......................
The characters in Dickens’ “Great Expectations” weren’t black either..................
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
