American Idol 2011--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2011

[silent_jonny]

Pack Your Bags!

[Lil'freeper]

TaTa Strange enough that I didn't completely hate the whole idea. She was a little screechy in parts. On the fence about the poodle skirt.

NeemaAgain with "When Bolts of Fabric Attack". Now we find out that she does this to herself! Clearly she needs a different day job.

Kendra Singing was adequate. Costume unremarkable. Diction terrible. Wake me up when this is over.

Rachel reminds me soooo much of Rachel Berry on Glee. Tell me I'm wrong.

Karen más o menos

Lauren Note to self: tin foil bodices and garbage bag skirts are only cute on Project Runway. She sang well, the song was completely unremarkable.

Jonsey Bustiers and leggings are not clothes. They are underwear. Please put some clothes on next time. The singing reminds me of a cat out tomcatting. Mmmmrowwww-owww-owww-owwww.

E*Trade Commercial Hilarious! I love those talking babies. Creepy but oh so funny.

Julie Gorilla What the Hello is up with with the princess dresses?? Another Rachel Berry costume. And mumble mumble mumble, what's missing? Oh how about some Diction. And maybe something called breath control.

Haley Didn't hate it. Just hated the outfit. You're supposed to wear clothes over your Spanx.

Thetan Thought there was a wardrobe malfunction for just a second there, then I realized her dress was just skin colored -- to include the feather things. A great technical performance, though. Pretty impressive. But I wouldn't download it.

Lauren FInally! Something uptempo. Finally! Some clothes! Finally! Someone having a good time singing a song. This is a fun little performance. I liked it!

Pia Excellent. Mostly because of song selection. But as Simon always said, song selection is everything.

Glad that's over with. I think this might be the guys' year this year.

[freedumb2003]

So it looks like we are all kind of seeing the best as Pia, Lauren and Thia.

Thplaurian.

[Jrabbit]

I think she has tried out for AI like 7 times....her family is friends of Peaches

[silent_jonny]

Wow.... a yellow dress!

Quote from Lethal Weapon: "Put an APB out on Big Bird."

[VampireStateNY]

I agree! It’s like Randy inherited the role of Bad Cop from Simon. Or Bizarro Randy showed up this season.

[RummyChick]

your thinking of this girl

[silent_jonny]

I don’t think Jlo and Steven realize that the auditions are done and the competition has begun. They need to start critiquing. Then again since 7 won’t make it to next week, what’s point?

LOL, good point :)

[big'ol_freeper]

Brilliant!!

[Mark was here]

Thanks for the recap, you nailed it.

[retrokitten]

She kind of looks like this really annoying girl from America’s Next Top Model from a few season ago who started a rumor that this other annoying girl had flesh eating bacteria.

Unfortunately, I am not making this up.

[MagUSNRET]

I knew I recognized her...and I knew I remembered correctly that she has no talent...

[Netizen]

Is that Haley Scarnatto?

[Raebie]

Almost time for ‘Hoarders’...AKA, ‘Making you feel great about your horrendous housekeeping abilities and enabling you to justify your time online’.

Night all. xoxo

[silent_jonny]

what is that tattoo?

Couldn't make it out.

[retrokitten]

I’m not sure if I am going to be here tomorrow night or not. I’m supposed to go out with my friend, but that might get scrapped.

[RummyChick]

Rejected for a golden ticket in season nine,

http://ydtalk.com/chatter/?page_id=6118

[retrokitten]

My house is always SO CLEAN after a Hoarders marathon. It makes me want to hose my whole place down.

[silent_jonny]

She’s got a stance wide enough for a Minnesota airport bathroom.

LOL!!

[Netizen]

Its going to be on for two hours. you can go out and come back and the show will still be going on.... and on... and on....