American Idol 2009--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | 3-17-09

[silent_jonny]

.

For Ladyinred

[peggybac]

Can’t hear the song without thinking of Hannity.

[Jrabbit]

I’m not loving her....if fact, I am going to shun her.

[skateman]

Chorus is sounding better.

[freedumb2003]

>>Wow...she’s doing great.

L R?????

I think some of us don’t see it that way.

[CASchack]

I agree. She didn’t hold a candle to Martina.

[kjam22]

She got weaker when it higher and louder..... and she backed off of some of those really high notes Martina and Carie would have hit.

[Cudjo]

hi rabbit

don’t care for this gal at all

[maggief]

I disagree. I think it really stinks.

[Shortstop7]

Yeah, I thought she did pretty good. No, Martina...but there is only one Martina.

[Mark was here]

She was a great dancer.

[slugbug]

Agreed-the soft parts were bad but then when she got to the chorus and sang louder, it was much better.

[maica]

I agree with you.
The audience loved it - a Hannity or McBride audience?

[retrokitten]

It doesn’t take much to be better then Fantasia. But I don’t think they are comparable. Lil can actually sing. I just don’t enjoy her style of singing.

[nufsed]

I think she’s a good singer. However, this is one where I would say “wrong choice.”

[skateman]

Stop talking Lil, not helping your case.

[kjam22]

Judges didn’t like the song for her. Think she got it by listening to Hanity??? LOL

[retrokitten]

LOL!

[freedumb2003]

>>Can’t hear the song without thinking of Hannity.

True — L R is karaoke on this one.

Lets see if America can overcome the fix that is in.

[Fawn]

Why is Kara wearing a tinfoil dress?

[Shortstop7]

Lol...i dunno. Sure made me think of Hannity though.