American Idol 2009--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^

[silent_jonny]

American Idol 2009

For Ladyinred

[AxelPaulsenJr]

Actually, I always liked the melody, a good forceful driving tune. But, LOL, the lyrics, were just insane, making no sense.

[Jrabbit]

Good! Those were my top 3.

[ken5050]

IMHO, Tohn’s outfit was straight out of a HS production of Grease

[ken5050]

Mayberry’s “Pigeon sisters!!”

[ken5050]

Question..I remember this only because my two daughters loved her back in the 80’s..but does Alexis remind anyone of Cyndi Lauper?..the look..the hair, the voice?

[Netizen]

I think the Pigeon sisters were on the Odd Couple.

Jean Carson and Joyce Jameson played Daphne and Skippy. Not sure if their characters were given last names or if they were related.

[Lucky9teen]

8:15 and we’ve heard one, ONE performer!
______________________________________

This and all the stupid filler, drama....is why I DVR the show and watch later. I LOVE the fast forward button. ;)

[Yaelle]

Anticipation? LOL. I think that’s Carly Simon. Frankly, I think the ketchup commercial killed that song dead.

[Yaelle]

Only Alexis and the first girl (with all the stage presence and “interesting” voice) were any good, to me, of the girls. I liked Danny and Anoop for the guys. The country guys are both cute but neither stood out — I think I didn’t like their song choices and they both looked a mite nervous or unsure.

[Palladin]

Jackie Tohn looks like tough bartender down in the Village.

[Lucky9teen]

Since most of the singers from last night actually sucked...these are the top 3 for me:

First up: Alexis

I think Simon is correct, she is the dark horse...who I think looks a little like Molly Ringwald (sans red hair)
 
 

Then to the Drama Queen (and what would Idol be without Drama?): Tatiana

She may be annoying and too dramatic, but she can sing....and she looks like Gloria Estefan, IMO

Then: Danny

I don't think I'm alone when I say he looks like Robert Downey Jr.

[Palladin]

shhhhhh...don’t tell anyone, but I voted 3 times for Tatiana...

[Clint N. Suhks]

You nailed 1, 2 and three.

Try finding a pic a Katharine McPhee, Tatiana looks more like her than Gloria IMHO.

[Fawn]

I voted for #4—the country singer about 10 times. THe line wasn’t busy once....so I have a feeling he didn’t make it.

[Lucky9teen]

Try finding a pic a Katharine McPhee, Tatiana looks more like her than Gloria IMHO.

________________________________
I disagree....

[Clint N. Suhks]

I definitely see the resemblance.

[Wolfstar]

Try finding a pic a Katharine McPhee

Speaking of Kat McPhee, she's been cast in a new romatic commedy movie called 'Wedlocked.' The male lead is Dave Annable. Here's a link to the announcement.

If anything, Kat is more McBeautiful than ever:

[TexasNative2000]

McArthur Park

The song bites, but the instrumental version by Maynard Ferguson is solid.

[Wolfstar]

Obviously in my post #5,917 above, commedy should be comedy. To make up for my typo, here's another recent pic of the McLovely McPhee. :)

BTW, the two pics of Kat in her black-and-white print top are from when she attended the The Mercedes-Benz Fashion Week 2-15-09. They are totally UNRETOUCHED photos. She has the most amazingly McFlawless skin I have ever seen.

[sweet_diane]

Actually, its the new judge Kara that looks most like Katherine McPhee!