Posted on 04/20/2006 6:54:31 AM PDT by mlc9852
If Reade's ID is bad--can she be credible on any other?
I wonder about him, we have not heard too much about his alibi.
I heard early on that Finnerty's attorney NEVER talks to the press about his cases or clients.
And I have heard that some of the defense attorneys are upset with some of what is being released.
Snark, look at this:
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0405061duke2.html
Notice the "description of crimes" at the bottom; see how many they were NOT charged with; do you think they've dropped them after seeing some medical evidence?
You're right, he could have been the photographer. I also wonder where the 6'6" McFayden was--we haven't heard about him in a while--He also has a million dollar home. Could he be #3?
I can see the difference in styles from the coverage.
IMHO, trying a case in the media is not usually a good idea, but since this DA has been doing it like crazy, I guess Seligman's attorney feels it appropriate.
With the racial tensions afoot, it might be useful, but I don't think it can counteract the race-baiters who have conducted rallies and taken a position on it.
Ugh...it's super late for us East Coasters--catch you later! Good night!
I'll bet no. 3 does not get named until the accuser's circle of advisors has figured out who exactly appears in the photos of the party. The defense lawyers need to be especially on guard for leaks out of their offices, as some of the race hustlers might pay top dollar for a look at the photos to make sure the no. 3 that is chosen is in there.
Also, the accuser's people may be trying to identify who made the "she's just a stripper" comment, and ID him. Perhaps they will approach the cabbie and threaten him or bribe him to pick that guy out of the lacrosse team picture. Then we will find that that guy is the lucky no.3 defendant.
I wonder if Kim was the one who threatened to call the police--since that's what she did. And maybe that threat was the reason for the rapid disbursement of the remaining partygoers.
Snark, look at this:
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0405061duke2.html
Notice the "description of crimes" at the bottom; see how many they were NOT charged with; do you think they've dropped them after seeing some medical evidence?
____________________________
Didn't they know the results of the SANE nurse's evaluation by the time they got this warrant?
I forgot, can you tell me what the charges were again for Reade and Collin?
My brain is not functioning properly tonight..lol
I agree with your opinion.
I assume the identification has already been made. The person just hasn't been charged due to lack of evidence (of course that hasn't stopped Nifong previously from making arrests). I'm not so cynical as to believe Nifong would allow her to ID someone NOW.
Good God! Conspiracy to commit murder? How in the hell did I miss that crime?
lol--I hope his standard for evidence has gone up a little!
That was added after the email.
Oh, I see. Thanks.
goodnight everybody.
It's 2am here and I work in the morning.
I will be back here tomorrow.
Keep the info coming.
;-)
Susan Filan--what a clown. Has to twist herself into a pretzel to explain things away and find "scenarios" under which the rape "could've" occured.
Lol, good one.
The leak was that she was 90% on the third person.
He allowed the other IDs to be made 4 weeks after the event, and after the identities and photographs of the lacrosse team had been highly publicized. Frankly, it's not any less prejudicial to let her make an ID now than it was 4 weeks after the event.
I wonder whether the accuser's circle of friends had access to the party photos somehow before she made her IDs. The picture of Reade is very clear and distinctive, and he has a face that is not easily confused for someone else. Perhaps the accuser's side paid off a paralegal or secretary in a defense lawyer's office, got certain that he was at the party from the photos, was from a wealthy family, he had scratch marks on his body, and decided to go with him.
The 2 IDs made to date were, according to news reports, made from a photo lineup consisting only of Duke lacrosse players.
So I think you are giving the police investigators and the DA too much credit, and underestimating the animus driving the race baiters surrounding the accuser. The stakes are high for them, they are playing for keeps, and I think it would be a mistake to put anything past them in this case.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.