Live Replay of SCOTUS Oral Arguments in DC v. Heller (2A case)

C-SPAN ^ | March 18, 2007 | C-SPAN

[NinoFan]

http://www.cspan.org/watch/cs_cspan_wm.asp?Cat=TV&Code=CS

[July 4th]

There's a lot of history that's coming to a head here. Just think, we're in a country that's so politically and legally stable that we're having an honest argument about what the English Bill of Rights of 1689 meant.

[mvpel]

“Dangerous weapons” - getting into the Dredd Scott reasoning, begging the question.

[Mr. Brightside]

Anyone here still want Obama or Hillary to nominate the next few Supreme Court Justices?

[Domandred]

I love Roberts: “What IS reasonable about a complete ban on possession?”

[mvpel]

“Shoot a lot of people at once” - what a jackass Dellenger is.

[beltfed308]

I think Roberts’s question cuts to the heart of the matter:

It sure does! Most of the justices from their questions I think aren't buying the DC argument at all.

[Virginia Ridgerunner]

CJ John Roberts is THE man!

[BCR #226]

I’m getting the impression that Ginsburg is giving Dellinger every opportunity to convince her but he hasn’t done it yet. Opinion?

Mike

[mvpel]

“Common use” - the M-16 assault rifle is in “common use” by the US Military.

[Mr. Brightside]

The 2nd Amendment will be a MAJOR issue in this fall’s election.

Clinton and Obama will not be able to hide as soon as this decision is handed down.

[Smogger]

Anyone here still want Obama or Hillary to nominate the next few Supreme Court Justices?

Yeah. They do. Something about teaching someone a lesson.

[BCR #226]

Dellinger just tried to get out of the crosshairs... the Justices kept him squarely in their sights... this is BEAUTIFUL!!!

Mike

[cgk]

Great site. I check it regularly. They are Live Blogging this one.

http://www.scotusblog.com/wp/

[Pistolshot]

Yep. She is asking the questions to support her pre-disposed anti-gun stance, but he hasn’t yet. Ginsberg is looking for ANY excuse to support the ban.

[mvpel]

I’ve been saying that it would be for months, nice to be vindicated by the facts.

[Mr. Brightside]

Something about teaching someone a lesson.

Kind of like wishing one of your children would get hit crossing the street in order to teach the rest of your kids the lesson to look both ways first.

[BCR #226]

I’m finding that I have to hold my glee. I want to see how the Justices grill Heller’s side.

The Solicitor General should be shaking in his boots right now. He’s watching what he will go through in a few minutes.

I’ve never seen an attorney stutter like Dellinger is.

Mike

[ibbryn]

I don’t know anything about the US Sup Court, but in my (biased) view this argument sounded really bad for the anti-RKBA POV.
Maybe I’m just hearing what I want to....?

[BCR #226]

I agree, the anti’s didn’t get their point across.

Mike

[Pistolshot]

Clement is up next