Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Iraq and 9/11: What the Judge Said
NewsMax.com ^ | May 28, 2004 | Carl Limbacher

Posted on 05/28/2004 11:47:03 AM PDT by Carl/NewsMax

In light of Thursday's Wall Street Journal report detailing new evidence tying Iraq to the 9/11 attacks, it's worth noting that the only time the question of an Iraq-9/11 connection has been legally tested, the verdict was affirmative.

In a woefully underreported decision on May 8, 2003, Manhattan U.S. District Court Judge Harold Baer ruled in favor of two 9/11 victim families who had sued Iraq and others claiming they were culpable in the attacks. The court awarded plaintiffs $104 million based on the Baer's findings.

The ruling by Judge Baer - a Carter appointee, by the way - was quite detailed. In fact, we suspect that the reason for the media's near-blackout on the case is because most Americans would consider his findings to be very persuasive.

Here, in part, is what Judge Baer had to say about the Iraq-9/11 connection:

"The opinion testimony of the plaintiffs' experts is sufficient to meet plaintiffs' burden that Iraq collaborated in or supported bin Laden/al Qaeda's terrorist acts of September 11. . .

"Their opinions, coupled with their qualifications as experts on this issue, provide a sufficient basis for a reasonable jury to draw inferences which could lead to the conclusion that Iraq provided material support to al Qaeda and that it did so with knowledge and intent to further al Qaeda's criminal acts."

Judge Baer continued:

"[Former CIA] Director [James] Woolsey reviewed several facts that tended in his view to show Iraq's involvement in acts of terrorism against the United States in general and likely in the events of September 11 specifically.

"First, Director Woolsey described the existence of a highly secure military facility in Iraq where non-Iraqi fundamentalists [e.g., Egyptians and Saudis] are trained in airplane hijacking and other forms of terrorism. Through satellite imagery and the testimony of three Iraqi defectors, [he] demonstrated the existence of this facility, called Salman Pak, which has an airplane but no runway.

"The defectors also stated that these fundamentalists were taught methods of hijacking using utensils or short knives. Plaintiffs contend it is farfetched to believe that Iraqi agents trained fundamentalists in a top-secret facility for any purpose other than to promote terrorism.

"Second, Director Woolsey mentioned a meeting that allegedly occurred in Prague in April 2001 between Mohammad Atta, the apparent leader of the hijackings, and a high-level Iraqi intelligence agent. According to James Woolsey, the evidence indicates that this was an 'operational meeting' because Atta flew to the Czech Republic and then returned to the United States shortly afterwards. The Minister of Interior of the Czech Republic, Stanislav Gross, stated on October 26, 2001:

"'In this moment we can confirm, that during the next stay of Muhammad Atta in the Czech republic there was the contact with the official of the Iraqi Intelligence, Mr. Al Ani, Ahmed Khalin Ibrahim Samir, who was on 22nd April 2001 expelled from the Czech Republic on the basis of activities which were not compatible with the diplomatic status . . . '

"Third, Director Woolsey noted that his conclusion was also based on 'contacts,' which refer to interactions between Hussein/Iraq and bin Laden/al Qaeda that are described in a letter from George Tenet, the Director of Central Intelligence, to Senator Bob Graham on October 7, 2002. Director Tenet's carefully worded letter included in substance the same allegations, but with less detail, that Secretary of State Colin Powell made before the U.N. Security Counsel on Feb. 5, 2003, in his remarks about 'the potentially much more sinister nexus between Iraq and the al-Qaida terrorist network. . . .'

"Both Director Tenet and Secretary Powell mentioned 'senior level contacts' between Iraq and al Qaeda going back to the early 1990s [although both acknowledged that part of the interactions in the early to mid-1990s pertained to achieving a mutual non-aggression understanding]; both mentioned that al Qaeda sought to acquire poison gas and training in its use from Iraq; both mentioned that al Qaeda members have been in Iraq, including Baghdad, after September 2001. . . .

"Finally, plaintiffs also place considerable weight on an article that appeared in a regional Iraqi newspaper in July 2001, two months before the disaster of September 11. This article, a paean to bin Laden, mentions that bin Laden 1] 'will try to bomb the Pentagon after he destroys the White House,' 2] 'is insisting very convincingly that he will strike America on the arm that is already hurting,' and 3] 'will curse the memory of Frank Sinatra every time he hears his songs.' See Exs. 16-18, Naeem Abd Muhalhal, America, An Obsession Called Osama Bin Ladin, Al-Nasiriya, July 21, 2001 [original, translation, and certificate of accuracy of translation].

"Because, according to Director Woolsey, 'all publications in Iraq really appear at the sufferance of and with a full vetting by the Iraqi regime,' see Tr. 158, and because of the coincidences and the fact that '[t]here is a certain propensity, I think, on bin Laden's part and on Saddam's part ... to try to communicate in somewhat vague terms,' Director Woolsey concluded that there is a probability of a vague foreknowledge of what was contemplated. See Tr. 159." [End of Excerpt]

Judge Baer also found the testimony of terrorism expert Dr. Laurie Mylroie persuasive, writing:

"Dr. Mylroie described Iraq's covert involvement in acts of terrorism against the United States in the past, including the bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993. Dr. Mylroie testified to at least four events that served as the basis for her conclusion that Iraq played a role in the September 11 tragedy:

"First, she claimed that Iraq provided and continues to provide support to two of the main perpetrators of the bombing of the World Trade Center in 1993. Specifically, Abdul Rahman Yasin returned to Baghdad after the bombing and Iraq has provided him safe haven ever since. See Tr. 175-76. Also, Ramsey Yusef arrived in the United States on an Iraqi passport in his own name but left on false documentation - a passport of a Pakistani who was living in Kuwait and whom the Kuwaiti government kept a file on at the time that Iraq invaded Kuwait. See Tr. 174.

"Second, she noted bin Laden's fatwah against the United States, which was motivated by the presence of U.S. forces in Saudi Arabia to fight the Gulf War against Iraq. See Tr. 177.

"Third, she noted that threats by bin Laden in late 1997 and early 1998 which led up to the bombing of the U.S. embassies [on August 7, 1998] were 'in lockstep' with Hussein's threats about ousting the U.N. weapons inspectors, which he eventually did on August 5, 1998. See Tr. 178-79.

"Dr. Mylroie concluded that 'Iraq, I believe, did provide support and resources for the September 11 attacks. I agree with [Iraqi defector] Captain [Sabah] Khodada when he said that ... it took a state like Iraq to carry out an attack as really sophisticated, massive and deadly as what happened on September 11.' See Tr. 182." [End of Excerpt]

To be sure, Judge Baer also noted that the case for Iraq's involvement in 9/11 is far from a slam dunk, concluding, "Plaintiffs have shown, albeit barely, 'by evidence satisfactory to the court' that Iraq provided material support to bin Laden and al Qaeda."

Nevertheless, that's a far cry from media claims - not to mention President Bush's incredibly ill-advised statement last fall - that there's no evidence tying Iraq to 9/11.


TOPICS: Extended News; War on Terror
KEYWORDS: 911; alqaedaandiraq; judgebaer; mylroie; salmanpak; woolsey
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-4041-6061-67 next last

1 posted on 05/28/2004 11:47:05 AM PDT by Carl/NewsMax
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Carl/NewsMax

bump


2 posted on 05/28/2004 11:51:20 AM PDT by pgkdan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Carl/NewsMax
In a woefully underreported decision on May 8, 2003, Manhattan U.S. District Court Judge Harold Baer ruled in favor of two 9/11 victim families who had sued Iraq and others claiming they were culpable in the attacks. The court awarded plaintiffs $104 million based on the Baer's findings.

I find it odd that NewsMax would report this "woefully underreported decision," since a cursory review of Harold Baer's track record as a judge would reveal that the guy is pretty much a loony-tune who shouldn't be anywhere near a Federal bench.

3 posted on 05/28/2004 11:53:28 AM PDT by Alberta's Child ("Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium . . . sed ego sum homo indomitus")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Carl/NewsMax
'will curse the memory of Frank Sinatra every time he hears his songs I know the religion of peace has some strange and arbitrary preferences -- camels good/monkeys bad; babganoush good/shrimp cocktail bad. But what did Ol' Blue Eyes do to get on Allah's s***t list?
4 posted on 05/28/2004 11:56:55 AM PDT by Kiss Me Hardy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: pgkdan

Iyad Allawi -- the fellow just picked to be interim PM of Iraq -- was apparently the source of the info about Mohammad Atta's meeting with Iraqis.


5 posted on 05/28/2004 11:58:12 AM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Carl/NewsMax

Also, Iyad Allawi was the guy who told MI6 that Saddam could launch missiles in 45 minutes.

But I think the British think that the Atta-Iraq claims are legit.


6 posted on 05/28/2004 11:59:14 AM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: pgkdan

News that will not see the light of day. Massive denial setting in. Lie, Lie, Lie...right Ted?


7 posted on 05/28/2004 12:01:32 PM PDT by gathersnomoss
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: gathersnomoss

I think it WILL get some attention with the nomination of Allawi. Lauri Mylroie, who is quoted in the article, has a lot to say about him. He's apparently not a good guy, but he's the source for a lot of the stuff that the CIA has quashed. (why, I don't know.)


8 posted on 05/28/2004 12:04:17 PM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: ScaniaBoy; Cooter; eyespysomething; B4Ranch; Alamo-Girl; Triple; MJY1288; potlatch; Shermy; ...
OKC-911 CONNECTION ALERT. Please let me know by freepmail if you want to be taken off this list. Thanks.

Peripheral to the OKC bombing, but more compelling info nonetheless.

9 posted on 05/28/2004 12:05:54 PM PDT by ovrtaxt (Stop the war. ********** NUKE EM NOW !)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: ovrtaxt

Put me on this list please. I am fascinated with the choice of Allawi today and I'm wondering what difference this will make to the 9/11-Iraq connection data.


10 posted on 05/28/2004 12:07:24 PM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Alberta's Child

That "fact" should assure wide coverage by the RATmedia. Isn't that its favorite kind of judge.

Or has the RATmedia all of a sudden become circumspect wrt Judicial opinions.


11 posted on 05/28/2004 12:07:43 PM PDT by justshutupandtakeit (America's Enemies: foreign and domestic RATmedia agree Bush must be destroyed.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: Carl/NewsMax

http://www.reuters.com/printerFriendlyPopup.jhtml?type=topNews&storyID=5290246


12 posted on 05/28/2004 12:09:21 PM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Carl/NewsMax

Carl -
Can you please tell me your opinion why the President isn't using this information to silence his critics?


13 posted on 05/28/2004 12:11:36 PM PDT by M. Peach (eschew obfuscation)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: justshutupandtakeit

As soon as I read about this case last year and the judge's decision, my immediate reaction was that it sounded identical to the decision that was handed down in that idiotic civil suit by Martin Luther King's family a couple of years ago.


14 posted on 05/28/2004 12:16:31 PM PDT by Alberta's Child ("Ego numquam pronunciare mendacium . . . sed ego sum homo indomitus")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: M. Peach

The information will silence them, in time.


15 posted on 05/28/2004 12:20:26 PM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: ovrtaxt

Yes peripheral - connected looks that way!


16 posted on 05/28/2004 12:27:28 PM PDT by TrueBeliever9 (Life is uncertain. Ride your best horse first. Unknown)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: devolve
bump!

17 posted on 05/28/2004 12:32:51 PM PDT by MeekOneGOP (There is ONLY ONE good Democrat: one that has just been voted OUT of POWER ! Straight ticket GOP!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: PolitBase
Iyad Allawi -- the fellow just picked to be interim PM of Iraq -- was apparently the source of the info about Mohammad Atta's meeting with Iraqis.

Actually, that info came from Czech intelligence, who eyewitnessed Atta in Prague during the time when our government completely lost track of his whereabouts. They originally believed that the meeting had to do with a plot to blow up the headquarters of Radio Free Europe.

Several media outlets including the New York Times have put forth an abundance of false information on this topic, such as stating that Czech intelligence later retracted the claim (when they never did), and stating that the CIA denies that the meeting took place, when in fact the CIA's official position is that they can't confirm or deny it.

18 posted on 05/28/2004 12:32:59 PM PDT by jpl ("You can go to a restaurant in New York City and meet a foreign leader."- John Kerry)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: jpl

http://www.indianexpress.com/full_story.php?content_id=37272

LONDON, DECEMBER 14: The mastermind of the September 2001 attacks in the US, Mohammad Atta, was trained in Baghdad by a Palestinian terrorist at the instance of deposed Iraqi President Saddam Hussein, a media report said today.

Atta, who was trained by Palestinian terrorist Abu Nidal, visited Baghdad just weeks before the terror attack, The Sunday Telegraph reported. The details of Atta’s visit are contained in a secret memo, written to Hussein by the former head of Iraqi intelligence service Tahir Jalil Habbush Al-Tikriti, it said.



The handwritten memo, a copy of which has been obtained by the daily is dated July 1, 2001 and provides a short resume of a three-day ‘‘work programme’’ Atta had undertaken at Nidal’s base in Baghdad. In the memo, Habbush reports that Atta ‘‘displayed extraordinary effort’’ and demonstrated his ability to lead the team that would be ‘‘responsible for attacking the targets that we have agreed to destroy.’’

Although Iraqi officials refused to disclose how and where they had obtained the document, Ayad Allawi, a member of Iraq’s ruling seven-man presidential committee, said the document was genuine.

‘‘We are uncovering evidence all the time of Saddam’s involvement with Al Qaeda,’’ Allawi said. ‘‘But this is the most compelling piece of evidence that we have found so far. It shows that not only did Saddam have contacts with Al Qaeda, he had contact with those responsible for the September 11 attacks.’’


19 posted on 05/28/2004 12:36:14 PM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

To: jpl

Or do you consider this disinformation?


20 posted on 05/28/2004 12:37:19 PM PDT by PolitBase
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-4041-6061-67 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson