For Francis and his allies, one of the greatest surprises of the 'consultation of the laity' conducted as part of the Synod on Synodality must have been the consistent and vocal support for the Traditional Latin Mass and opposition to restrictions. This 'din' in favor of the Latin Mass was so widespread in American synodal listening sessions- including those that we attended- that support for Latin Mass and opposition to restrictions was
mentioned in the USCCB's National Synthesis Report. As Joseph Shaw
has documented, the United States was far from being isolated in this respect, as reports from England, Ireland, Scotland, Australia, Canada, and France note a desire for celebration of the Traditional Latin Mass. One Scottish diocese noted perceptively a generation gap: "The sheer difference of what the young think the Church is, the generation for whom to be Christian at all is to be effectively an everyday martyr. What the world looks like to young students is so different from what it looked like to my parent’s generation where Christianity was normal." Thus, "the consensus seemed to be that there should be a place for a variety of forms of worship, both traditional and contemporary, and in particular that both the Traditional Latin Mass (extraordinary form) and the Novus Ordo should be reverently celebrated and warmly embraced."
At World Youth Day, the Vatican asked for handwritten prayer intentions "for the synod and the Church." The results posted by the official Vatican Synod account show
overwhelmingly that the Catholic youth- of all cultures- want a return to traditional Catholicism. A sample (
courtesy of Matthew Hazell):
- "do not forbid the Tridentine Mass"
- "a return to orthodoxy and tradition"
- "priests dedicated to their vocation"
- "that Catholics who find spiritual fulfilment in the TLM may be accepted and allowed to attend the Mass of their choice"
That an official Vatican Twitter account would post such messages in favor of orthodoxy is itself something of a shock. But,
according to an observer who was at World Youth Day, the Vatican had little choice: "90% of the post-it notes in São Domingos had this sort of message on it."
The youth growing up in a secularized, post-Christian world yearn for the distinctive reverence of the Traditional Latin Mass- the Mass of the Ages. They want a bold contrast with the modern world- not a Church that blends in with it. In this, they are taking the lead of Christ himself, who proclaimed: "if the world hates you, know that it hated me before you." The God of Surprises has much in store for the Church, indeed.
This is where Pope Benedict XVI — surprisingly — got it all wrong. When you read his directive from around 2007 that allowed the widespread adoption of the TLM, you get the impression that he saw this as something of a temporary situation that would end when the last of the pre-Vatican II generation that still holds a sentimental attachment to the Latin Mass passes on.
Apparently he had no idea how popular the Latin Mass is among younger Catholics.
