Skip to comments.Does God condone polygamy? Bible scholar says 'no,' Old Testament shows it only creates turmoil
Posted on 12/16/2019 8:08:32 AM PST by SeekAndFind
The Bible talks about polygamy but that doesn't mean God endorsed it, said Peter Gentry, a professor of Old Testament interpretation who stressed the importance of understanding historical narratives in Scripture.
In a video posted on The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary's YouTube channel on Monday, Gentry said readers must distinguish between what God commands versus how He treated His people and how His people, who were not faithful, treated Him.
"God is the one that designs marriage. God is the one who invents marriage. Marriage is not something invented by humans. God is the one who gives the first woman to the first man. God is the one who presides over that marriage ceremony," he explained.
Thus, in Genesis 2:24 when Moses writes of a man leaving his mother and father and clinging to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh, that is God's original standard, he said. Much of the Old Testament, however, is the documented history of God's covenantal relationship with his people.
"A covenant is like a marriage, where two parties make a commitment to be devoted to each other, to be loyal, to be faithful," he said, noting the Old Testament contains a series of these covenants.
Such covenants are where God makes new starts with people like Noah, with Abraham and his family, and with Israel. But history shows that the human partners in the covenants are the unfaithful, disloyal, and rebellious ones, a history where a constant violation of the original standard occurred, he said.
An example of this is how Abraham did not trust God or wait for His promise of a son, and then has a relationship with Hagar, yielding Ishmael. Another is Jacob's relationship with two wives, which was not a wonderful arrangement as the Bible shows how it brought about all kinds of trouble, he said. The book of Judges also recounts how the judges had multiple wives because they were aspiring to be king.
"Most people in the ancient near East had only one wife. Only kings could afford to have many wives," Gentry added.
"When you read the Bible, the Bible is not promoting polygamy. It's showing us that only royal figures had many wives. It's also showing us that this is not ideal, that this caused all kinds of difficulty and hardship and trouble and the fighting among the wives. And it's not a satisfactory relationship."
Another example of how God did not endorse the practice of many wives is when King David was confronted by the prophet Nathan in 2 Samuel 12. Nathan told the king a parable about a man who had many sheep and a poor man who had only one sheep. The man with many sheep stole and slaughtered the sheep of the poor man for himself when he had to show hospitality to a guest.
The prophet's message of rebuke to David was, essentially, "You have many wives and still you're not satisfied, and you have to go an steal the one woman that this one person has," Gentry said, underscoring the recurring theme that polygamy yields turmoil.
Further still, he continued, "Solomon was a tragic figure because he did not practice what he preached."
Although Solomon produced volumes of wisdom in his writings, it was not displayed in how he lived, he said.
"He disregarded his own wise principles, he multiplied wives, which is expressly forbidden for kings in Deuteronomy 17," he said.
"Because who is the king going to marry? He's going to marry a princess from another country and it is going to create a political alliance and they're going to trust in that alliance and they are not going to trust in the Lord."
The biblical history shows that these men might have had faith in God, but that does not mean they were men of morality or that all their actions were moral, he said.
"If you look at the New Testament and you look at what Jesus says in the New Testament and look at what the apostles say, they never hold up anyone from the Old Testament as a moral example. They hold them up as examples of faith, but not as examples of morality," Gentry emphasized.
"There is a very clear difference between what God commands and instructs us to do in marriage and how His people actually behaved in the history that is recorded for us. Just because these things happened in the Old Testament, we have to listen to what the narrator is saying. The narrator is not saying this is good thing. He's showing that this is a bad thing ... because it is abandoning the Creation standard."
You can make a better case for polygamy in the Bible than you can divorce.
And yes there is one specific situation in the OT where polygamy IS condoned. When a man dies, his brother had the duty to take his brother’s wife into his household and if the brother was childless, raise up children for the brother.
You can look it up.
All that said. The guy in the article is essentially right
Anyone who thinks he wants more than one wife probably hasn’t been with just one for very long.
Good God! What sane man would have more than one wife??!! Oh the humanity! Oh the horror!
You’d think logical people would figure that out...then there are the Muzzies....
RE: What sane man would have more than one wife??!!
Kings David and Solomon ( especially the latter ) were bonkers then.
RE: When a man dies, his brother had the duty to take his brothers wife into his household and if the brother was childless, raise up children for the brother.
Hmmm... does that mean that Hunter Biden was only following the Bible?
Polygamy being of God, is not specified in the Bible, but it is mentioned as “abominable before me saith the Lord” in the Book of Mormon.
“Behold, David and Solomon truly had many wives, and concubines, which thing was abominable before me, saith the Lord.” - Jacob 2:33
“Wherefore, my brethren, hear me, and hearken to the word of the Lord: For there shall not any man among you have save it be one wife; and concubines he shall have none: For I, the Lord God, delighteth in the chastity of women.” - Jacob 2:36
“For they have not forgotten the commandments of the Lord, which were given unto our fathers, that they should have, save it were one wife: and concubines they should have none; and there should not be whoredoms committed among them.” - Jacob 2:55
There were no government social services at that time and widows would have been beggers otherwise. The corollary today would be to help the widowed sister-in-law to make a mortgage payment or other financial support
I’m not a Mormon, and tend to disregard their dogma out of hand.
Where does it say that brother is already married? Couldn't he have been single?
RE: Behold, David and Solomon truly had many wives, and concubines, which thing was abominable before me, saith the Lord. - Jacob 2:33
SO, why did Joseph Smith and Brigham Young have many wives?
Old Testament shows it only creates turmoil
I once worked with a Pakistani Muslim fellow. He told us that yes, under his religion he is allowed to have up to four wives.
“But..” he said, rolling his eyes, “a fellow would have to be pretty much insane to actually try it!”
RE: a fellow would have to be pretty much insane to actually try it!
What is the corollary to this when it comes to his prophet, Mohammad?
RE: Isaiah 4:1
What does it say about these women in the PREVIOUS verses?
Any of us men that have a really good wife would laugh heartily at the concept of ever having some other woman around - never mind two or three other ones !!!!
I cant even imagine the conflict, jealousy envy and other nonsense that would be around that kind a house!
RE: I cant even imagine the conflict, jealousy envy and other nonsense that would be around that kind a house!
That’s precisely what this article is saying.
Abraham’s house did not have peace the moment he took Hagar as is his common-law-wife, resulting in conflict between Sarah and this woman ( never mind that it was Sarah’s idea in the first place ).
David’s house was in turmoil as his children from various wives plotted against one another with one of his children, Absalom actually rebelling against him. Up to the time he died, his wive’s and children were plotting to see who would take over his throne.
Solomon’s pagan wives turned his heart away from the Lord.
Just three examples.
24 Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh.
25 And they were both naked, the man and his wife, and were not ashamed.
Adam, the first man in the flesh, left his father and mother in heaven to cleave to his wife.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.