Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Hard-Line Bishop to Succeed Flynn
Twin ^ | 4/24/07 | David Hanners

Posted on 04/25/2007 6:16:33 AM PDT by marshmallow

A lauded liturgist, administrator, New Ulm conservative also is known for controversy

Roman Catholic Bishop John Nienstedt of New Ulm, Minn., a theological conservative who has taken on Hollywood, stem-cell research and people who make too much noise in church, was named Tuesday to succeed Archbishop Harry Flynn.

The announcement by the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis that Nienstedt, 60, had been named "coadjutor archbishop" ended months of speculation over who would succeed Flynn, who will step down when he turns 75 next year.

Flynn, who has been archbishop since 1996, introduced Nienstedt at the archdiocese's chancery in St. Paul. He called Nienstedt "such a capable bishop" and said he had "broad experience that will serve him well."

But Nienstedt's time as bishop of the Diocese of New Ulm has not been without controversy. While Flynn and others lauded him as an able administrator and liturgist, some of his actions have rankled his own priests and parishioners in the diocese he has led since August 2001.

Soon after being named bishop in New Ulm, he condemned some of the theological views of the man who had held the post before him for 25 years, Bishop Raymond Lucker, a noted progressive clergyman who died in 2001. Denouncing his predecessor's views was an "extraordinary step," the National Catholic Reporter noted in an article on the incident.

As bishop in New Ulm, Nienstedt prohibited cohabitating couples from being married in Catholic churches. He barred female pastoral administrators from leading prayers at a semiannual leadership event. He once disciplined a priest for holding joint ecumenical services with a Lutheran congregation after the Catholic church had been destroyed by a tornado.

Kenneth Irrgang, a retired priest who clashed with Nienstedt when he was bishop in New Ulm, predicted that Nienstedt will meet resistance among the 654 active priests in the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis.

"I expect disaster there. I don't think those priests are going to accept him," said Irrgang, who now lives in St. Cloud. "He's a micromanager. He has to control everything. He hews the line from the Vatican without any question whatsoever. He's not a very good people person."

But the Rev. Philip M. Schotzko of the Church of St. Peter in St. Peter, Minn., praised Nienstedt's abilities.

"Bishop Nienstedt is a consummate man of the church," said Schotzko. "He thinks with, prays with and loves the church with everything he's got. He just follows very carefully the teachings and all aspects of church theology and moral teachings. You'll get a very committed man in that way."

He said Nienstedt is "gifted in many ways as a liturgist" and considers him "a good organizer and planner and administrator."

According to his church biography, Nienstedt was born in Detroit, the second of six children. He completed his theological education at Sacred Heart Major Seminary in Detroit and the Pontifical Gregorian University in Rome, and was ordained into the priesthood in July 1974.

Nienstedt has held a variety of positions in the church throughout his career. He's been an associate pastor, priest-secretary to a cardinal, vicar general of the Archdiocese of Detroit and served in the Vatican Secretariat of State.

He was ordained a bishop in June 1996.

After Flynn introduced him Tuesday, Nienstedt spoke of his life in the church.

"When I was yet a boy, I fell in love with a beautiful woman who was the bride of Christ," Nienstedt said. "For me, the church has never been just an institution, just a hierarchical structure, just a doer of good works for the poor, the sick and the stranger, but she was and is a concrete manifestation of God's great love, for whom Jesus gave his very life."

A coadjutor archbishop is akin to an archbishop-in-training. Nienstedt will assume some of Flynn's duties, and aid him with others.

Nienstedt is moving from a diocese that has 42 active priests and 68,000 parishioners to an archdiocese with 454 priests and 646,000 parishioners. He noted the difference in his remarks.

"And while we, in the Diocese of New Ulm, have our share in life's joys and sorrows, I somehow think that both will proportionally increase with this new assignment," he said.

As bishop in New Ulm, Nienstedt wrote a regular column, "And Miles to Go," for the diocese's newsletter and Web site. In the first column, written in September 2001, he complained about President Bush's decision to fund stem-cell research into possible cures for disease.

Nienstedt called on government and people to "curb the scientist's thirst for novelty" by ending the research. In a later column on the subject, he called legislation allowing stem-cell research "a very misguided, political attack on human life," and said, "there have been no medical cures resulting from the use of embryonic stem cells."

He also used his column to air his views on homosexuality, saying people became gay or lesbian as a "result of psychological trauma" when a child is between the ages of 18 months and 3. Homosexuality, he wrote, "must be understood in the context of other human disorders: envy, malice, greed, etc."

Nienstedt also advised parishioners to avoid the movies "Brokeback Mountain" - "a story of lust gone bad," he wrote - and "The Da Vinci Code." He said Dan Brown's best-selling novel, later turned into a movie starring Tom Hanks, was "pure Evil in its intent" and "seeks to confuse the young, whose faith may be weak, and lead them astray."

In a column from June with the headline "Silence," Nienstedt complained about people talking while he prepared for weekend liturgies, saying it was a "din of noise ... not unlike that of a sports arena."

"I have tried to overhear what is so important that people need to speak in church," he wrote. "Normally comments range from one's view of the weather, to a recent sports event, to how old Uncle Henry is looking. None of it is essential. None of it has to be spoken at that time."

David Hanners can be reached at or 651-228-5551.

TOPICS: Catholic; Current Events; Ministry/Outreach; Theology
KEYWORDS: altier; flynn; nienstedt
He hews the line from the Vatican without any question whatsoever. He's not a very good people person.

Imagine that. A Catholic bishop who's obedient to the Pope.


1 posted on 04/25/2007 6:16:35 AM PDT by marshmallow
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: marshmallow

Bump! Bishop Nienstedt sounds great! A lot of wailing and gnashing of teeth from retired dissident priests, National Cino Reporter, and the other usual suspects. God bless him and thank you Pope Benedict.

2 posted on 04/25/2007 6:24:37 AM PDT by Nihil Obstat (Kyrie Eleison)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marshmallow
Is Archbishop Flynn ill? Isn't co-adjutor generally reserved for when the current bishop is sick?

I remember there was a co-adjutor appointed in Dallas and it was considered a slap in the face for the current bishop. Is that the case here?

3 posted on 04/25/2007 6:27:46 AM PDT by old and tired
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: old and tired; NYer
The case here is that Flynn is a bad, bad, bad bishop. The Holy See can't wait for his retirement. Appointing this amazing bishop coadjutor right now is the Romanitas for telling Flynn "Don't let the doorknob hit you..."
4 posted on 04/25/2007 7:14:35 AM PDT by Siobhan (Agios o Theos, Agios Ischyros, Agios Athanatos, eleison imas.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: marshmallow

“He hews the line from the Vatican without any question whatsoever” — my post exactly! How’d this guy ever make it into the US Bishops??? WOW. Go God.

5 posted on 04/25/2007 7:20:54 AM PDT by bboop (Stealth Tutor)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Comment #6 Removed by Moderator

Comment #7 Removed by Moderator

To: marshmallow
Kenneth Irrgang, a retired priest who clashed with Nienstedt when he was bishop in New Ulm, predicted that Nienstedt will meet resistance among the 654 active priests in the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis.

"I expect disaster there. I don't think those priests are going to accept him," said Irrgang, who now lives in St. Cloud.

So, all 654 are 'do your own thing' kind of guys? I doubt it.

Hey, where's the 'fairness' the liberal press is so fond of mentioning? There's no corresponding comments from a retired priest who supports the bishop.

8 posted on 04/25/2007 8:41:20 AM PDT by siunevada (If we learn nothing from history, what's the point of having one? - Peggy Hill)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: marshmallow
Hmmmmm-Good news for Voice in the Desert and Father Altier who has wonderful homilies posted here and there.

Carmelite Coat of Arms Pray for

A Voice in the Desert

Catholic Medical Association
Condemns Bishop's Use of
Sex-Abuse Programs

 Your word, O Lord, for ever stands firm in the heavens; Your truth lasts from age to age.
              ~ Psalm 1

To receive updates, email us.

Sign the Petition sponsored by CRCOA
The Ongoing Saga Concerning Father Altier
The Homosexual Subculture in the Church Today
Where Heresy and Dissent Abound
"Safe Environment" Programs: Safe isn't Safe Anymore
There's More than Meets the Eye with VIRTUS

About Father Altier and Desert Voice
Father Altier's Monthly Schedule
Fidelity Green Light Award and Site Review 

See what happened to Father Altier
From the Twilight Zone to the Land of Oz 
      A commentary on McGrath's letter
Fr. Altier asks McGrath for retraction
Desert Meditations - a tribute to Fr. Altier
Letters from the Desert - your response
Shut Up, Good Priest - in defense of Fr. Altier Father Altier Assigned to Nursing Home
Statements about the silencing of Fr. Altier

In obedient compliance with the expressed written request of

Most Reverend Harry J. Flynn

Archbishop of the Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

Father Altier’s homilies and spiritual presentations
can no longer be published on

or broadcast on Relevant Radio.

This action of the Archbishop is not related to any scandal
or sexual misconduct on the part of Father Robert Altier.

We regret any inconvenience and humbly ask for your prayers.

All concerns should be directed in a spirit of charity to:

Archdiocese of Saint Paul and Minneapolis

 Most Reverend Harry J. Flynn
226 Summit Avenue
Saint Paul, MN, USA 55102
(651) 291-4400

9 posted on 04/25/2007 8:47:57 AM PDT by Salvation (" With God all things are possible. ")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson