Posted on 04/05/2003 6:16:19 AM PST by jordan8
RIO DE JANEIRO, April 4 — The Brazilian government, responding to demands to improve the lot of the black population, has begun imposing racial quotas for government jobs, contracts and university admissions. But that has unleashed an acrimonious debate in a country that traditionally prides itself on being a harmonious "racial democracy."
The initial battleground is a pair of public universities here, which have just accepted a freshman class that is 40 percent black. As in the United States, though, white students who were not admitted despite scoring higher on entrance examinations have challenged that action in courts. They contend that they are being denied the "equality of access to schooling" guaranteed by Brazil's 1988 Constitution.
Civil rights advocates in this nation of 175 million, which has the largest black population of any nation outside of Africa, predict that the debate is likely to intensify even further as a result of a sweeping Racial Equality Statute now before Congress. That bill, supported by the left-wing government that took power here on Jan. 1, would make racial quotas obligatory at all levels of government and require them even in casting television programs and commercials.
"This policy is absolutely correct in terms of philosophy and ethics," Justice Minister Márcio Thomaz Bastos said at a news conference with foreign reporters here this week. "I have no doubt of it. After all, this country has an enormous debt because of the iniquity that was slavery in Brazil."
As a byproduct of the debate, Brazilians are also being forced to define who is black, a process they find puzzling and alien. More than 300 terms are used to designate skin color — from the dark-skinned crioulo to the light-skinned brancarao — and racially mixed relationships are the norm rather than the exception. As a result, racial categories have never been defined as they were in more segregated countries.
College admission in Brazil is highly competitive, with many more applicants than places available, especially for prestigious public universities, and entrance examination scores count for everything. Of the 1.4 million students admitted to universities in Brazil each year, only 3 percent identify themselves as black, and only 18 percent come from the public schools, where most black Brazilians study.
Because of the university admissions dispute here, the Supreme Court has been asked to rule on the constitutionality of racial quotas, and has indicated that it will do so quite soon. Since the chief justice himself imposed a hiring quota for court employees last year, civil rights advocates are expecting a favorable decision, which they say could have an impact here comparable to that of Brown v. Board of Education in the United States.
"This is a historic moment, and the court has a historic opportunity to undo the terrible injustice that was committed in 1888," when slavery was legally abolished but no government support was provided to newly freed blacks, said Zulu Araújo, a director of the Palmares Foundation, a government agency that addresses the interests of black Brazilians. "I have no doubt that the justices will vote in favor of quotas and establish the new paradigm of racial equality that this country needs."
But critics of the measures say the government is merely making a difficult problem worse by turning to what they consider to be a solution imported from the United States, a country in which racial definitions and relations are very different.
"Do they want racial war in Brazil?" said a recent article in the daily O Estado de São Paulo, which also complained in an editorial that the government was "officializing racial discrimination."
Some opponents of racial quotas also argue that racism is not a feature of Brazilian society and that conditions for blacks will improve as poverty is gradually eliminated. But civil rights advocates point to statistics showing that white Brazilians earn more, live longer, receive more education and are less likely to be arrested than black citizens.
I'm suspicious of any statement coming from a 'Civil Rights Advocate', they usually have their own agenda, and use the 'little people' as a stepping stone for that agenda.
point to statistics showing that white Brazilians earn more, live longer, receive more education and are less likely to be arrested than black citizens.
I've been to Brazil on several occasions, and I've never seen a 'white' Brazilian, the only white faces I've seen are American and European tourists.
I read about a compound of 30,000 people that had 1,200 private guards and everyone who entered and left the compound were searched.
A Brazilian friend has said that crime continues to spiral out of control along with corruption. He believes it's just a matter of time before Lula's policies force the generals to take over again.
The day should come when people who support quotas are no longer given the title of "civil rights advocates."
WFTR
Bill
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.