Posted on 04/29/2009 8:27:54 AM PDT by GodGunsGuts
The Long Precambrian Fuse Gets Longer
April 28, 2009 Why did complex multicellular life explode on the scene some 550 million years ago? Thats mystery enough, but finding complex single-celled life a billion years earlier makes it worse. A new paper evaluated claims of Cambrian-like fossils from India dated 1.6 billion years old in the evolutionary timeline. It did not explain the Cambrian explosion, but it did require belief in a long, long fuse.
Bengtson et al evaluated rocks in India where claims of early Cambrian fossils had been reported in recent years. They reported in PNAS this week.1 What they found was not multicellular life, but a complex assortment of real fossils indicating bacterial mats, cyanobacteria, along with segmented tubes and evidences of eukaryotic life the more advanced form of unicellular life. The fact that some of these eukaryotes formed tube-like shapes raises the question: why would a billion years go by with no more complex assemblages? There were also embryo-like globules indistinguishable from those found in early Cambrian deposits, though the authors assumed the resemblance was superficial.
Prior reports of complex fossils so early in the timeline caused serious controversy. If these and earlier reports are correct, they have profound implications, they said; either the radiometric dating consistently reflects inherited dates not related to sedimentation, as suggested by Azmi and coworkers, or Cambrian-like fossils occur in rocks that are a billion years older than the Cambrian. They determined some imprints were due to gas bubbles in microbial mats. Though they could not rule out a few problematic forms, they concluded that the fossils were all from prokaryotes and a few colonial eukaryotes. Putting the happiest face possible on their findings, they said, the Vindhyan deposits offer important new insights into the nature and diversity of life, and in particular, the early evolution of multicellular eukaryotes.
Most important, the paper admitted that the Cambrian explosion had a long fuse. Heres how they put it:
In terms of the evolution of major taxa, the most significant information to come out of the Vindhyan phosphorites is the detailed 3-dimensional morphologic evidence for late Paleoproterozoic multicellular eukaryotes (filamentous algae). Previously accepted multicellular eukaryotes were only known from the late Mesoproterozoic or early Neoproterozoic (i.e., some 400600 million years later), although some older discoveries had at least suggested the possibility that they had a longer prehistory.The potential of the Vindhyan phosphorites to yield fresh information on the Paleoproterozoic biotas is thus considerable, and the shelly biota discovered by Azmi et al. gives new insight into the nature of the Paleoproterozoic biosphere. The discredited reports of Cambrian fossils [i.e., in the Vindhyan deposits dated 1.6 billion years old] turned out to be an important discovery.
How credible is it to think that eukaryotes could not come up with anything more than tube-like colonies for a billion years, then bang! trilobites, worms, crustaceans, jellyfish, and all the major animal body plans in a geological instant? Evolution is supposed to be this inexorable force for innovation that invented mammals, birds, flying insects and all the other wonders of nature in far, far less time than that. The real mystery here is how Darwinism survives wave after wave of falsification. The propensity of evolutionists to snow the public with their implausible, fictional, ad hoc, speculative, imaginative, self-contradictory plot lines to rescue their theory from the evidence deserves condemnation. Dont let them get away with their pretensions of scholarship when defending absurdities. The integrity of science is at stake.
ping!
Why, yes. Yes, it is.
Bush’s fault!
So life is a billion or more years old?
20 And God said, “Let the water teem with living creatures, and let birds fly above the earth across the expanse of the sky.”
21 So God created the great creatures of the sea and every living and moving thing with which the water teems, according to their kinds, and every winged bird according to its kind. And God saw that it was good.
22 God blessed them and said, “Be fruitful and increase in number and fill the water in the seas, and let the birds increase on the earth.”
23 And there was evening, and there was morningthe fifth day.
Thanks for the ping!
“kook thread”
Duh, how crediggle is it t’ dink dat eukotes cudd not come up wid anydigg more dan tube-like colonies f’ a billion years, duuhhhh, den bang! Huh huh! trilobites, duuhhhh, worms, duuhhhh, crustaceans, duuhhhh, dgellyfish, ‘n all de madgor animal body plans in a geological instant, duh...uh...? Ebolushun is supposid to be dis inexoraggle f’ce f’ innobashun dat inbentid mammals, duuhhhh, birds, duuhhhh, flyigg insecks ‘n all de odeh wondehs of nature in far, far less time dan dat. De real myssehy hehe is duh, how Darwinism surbibes wabe affeh wabe of falsificashun. De propensity of ebolushunists t’ snow de public wid deir iplaustiggle, ficshunal, ad hoc, speculatibe, uh uh uh, imaginatibe, uh uh uh, self-contradictory plot lines t’ rescue deir deory from the, uh, ebidess desehbes conbemnashun. Duh. Dont let dem get away wid deir pretenshuns of scholarship when defendigg absurdities. Um uh. De integrity of sciess is at stake. Lee me lone!
It's credible. What enabled complex multi-cellular organisms was new genetic mechanism to script gene expression over a number of generations. Interesting websites: www.palaeos.com, www.palaeos.org.
number of generations means *cell* generations.
It wasn't until you joined the thread. ;)
Amen!
If it exploded, how did it ever survive to propagate?
/oh, you didn’t mean it like that
That’s how old the Evo’s thought life would have to be in order to make darwood’s fanciful creation myth work via random mutation + natural selection. As it turns out, not even trillions of years would be enough time to account for the diversity of life, even if you grant darwood’s fairytale the miracle of the first self-replicating proto-cell.
It wasn’t a kook thread until you showed up.
:o)

I have no idea what you are talking about, so here is a kook with a rattlesnake on his head.
Beware of goats.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.