Posted on 10/30/2008 11:43:40 AM PDT by Domandred
Democratic candidate Walt Minnick leads Republican U.S. Rep. Bill Sali by a seven-to-five margin in one of the most telling polls of Idaho's 1st Congressional District race: a tally of the two rivals' personal firearms.
Minnick owns seven guns: three pistols, a .22-caliber rifle, two Remington shotguns and a pellet gun he's used to teach his children to shoot. Sali, who in 2006 helped fight off an Army National Guard effort to restrict shooting in a Snake River raptor preserve, owns two shotguns and three rifles.
Now Minnick and Sali are dueling over who would best stick up for 2nd Amendment rights. Sali won an "A+" rating from the National Rifle Association on a questionnaire; Minnick got a "D+".
Meanwhile, Minnick, a 66-year-old former business executive who tied for the highest score in his 1970 U.S. Army class's marksmanship test, was endorsed by a rival group, Maryland-based American Hunters and Shooters Association, which says the National Rifle Association backs candidates for partisan reasons.
"I think guns are part of our American culture," Minnick said earlier this month. "There is no one more opposed to gun control than I am."
Sali, a 54-year-old lawyer from Kuna, retorted, "He believes it's OK to go out and shoot a deer, but not a criminal intruder in your own home."
For a glimpse of how deeply guns resonate in Idaho, take Greenleaf, a town of fewer than 1,000 souls founded by Quakers in the sugarbeet and mint fields above the Snake River. In 2006, it passed a law asking residents who didn't object on religious grounds to keep a gun at home.
The hamlet's mayor, Brad Holton, who owns 25 rifles, estimates that as many as 40 percent of eligible voters in Greenleaf see gun rights as a decisive ballot issue. While few think Minnick aims to ban guns, Holton said some fear the Democrat would be more likely to back legislation limiting acceptable weapons.
"The peace-driving people, they're saying, 'We've got to get Walt in there because he's going to reduce the variety of guns,' " Holton said. "But there are other people who have Uzis. To me, they are gun pursuers that love the right of firearms. They pursue it as far as that will go. I personally don't have them, but I understand that people enjoy them."
At the center of this debate is the 27-question National Rifle Association survey Minnick completed earlier this year.
The survey included this question: "The NRA opposes gun bans as a violation of both the Second Amendment and common sense. (However, fully automatic firearms, short-barreled shotguns, and certain "destructive devices" are currently very strictly regulated.) Which of the following statements best describes your opinion about banning firearms?"
Minnick, an NRA member, wrote "firearms with no legitimate sporting or recreational use" should be banned.
Andrew Arulanandam, an NRA spokesman in Virginia and a former Idaho GOP state director, said that answer won Minnick the poor rating.
"It's reasonable to conclude, based on Walt's response ... that he believes that a woman with a restraining order against a violent ex-, or the parole officer who has a conceal-carry permit to defend himself and his family from some of the people he deals with in his line of work, that these people don't deserve to own a firearm," Arulanandam said.
Minnick aides counter that the question referred to unconventional automatic weapons, short-barreled shotguns and "destructive devices." His response was never meant to be interpreted as opposition to handguns used for self defense, said John Foster, Minnick's spokesman in Boise.
"From Walt's perspective, there's no reason for someone to have a howitzer in their backyard or a .50-caliber machine gun in their garage," Foster said. "It's about protecting the rights of lawful gun owners by making sure they stay out of the hands of felons and criminals."
Minnick's answers did conform with the NRA's stance opposing registration, federal licensing and waiting periods -- and backing the U.S. Supreme Court's June 2008 decision to overturn a Washington, D.C., handgun ban.
Sali aides said Minnick isn't sincere.
"He's not a friend of the 2nd Amendment," said Wayne Hoffman, Sali's campaign spokesman. "He just doesn't like the fact that the NRA is calling him on it."
American Hunters and Shooters Association touts itself as "a gun owners association that doesn't have a radical agenda" and accuses the National Rifle Association of hijacking mainstream gun owners' heritage with an anti-conservation message. Its directors say Minnick's stance on guns -- and membership on boards including the Idaho Conservation League -- made the choice easy.
"We believe Minnick is going to protect our guns and the places where we learned to hunt and fish," said John Robinson, its chief of staff. "With Sali, we see a future where our wild lands have been sold off to the highest bidder to be harvested, logged, mined and carved up with roads."
Sali. Game over.
Actually, the way the district boundary is drawn up, most if not all of the Boise city limits are in the 2nd district, not the 1st. Anything to the east of Cole Road is considered in the 2nd district.
Minnick is running as a quasi-conservative Dim for a reason. That's the only way he has a realistic chance of besting Sali.
What is this guy talking about? I would think that with the weather in Idaho most people would want to garage their howitzers most of the year and everyone knows .50s go in the gun safe except when mounted up on the ring mount of the SUV.
That office is currently vacant by the way.
Heck yeah. You could be my assistant with that many guns ......;o)
Gotta love Idaho.
Sounds like you missed a perfect, ultimate, FReeping oportunity by not not filing to run against him.
Hell, my life would be complete to be your assistant. Bringing you bourbons by the pool and eyeing the fine collection of lady folk oiling ya’ up.
But you have to discuss quantity versus quality. Of course you get bonus points for the ASP.
Great movie and great line from the movie. After uttering that, I have to believe that Alan Ladd was a conservative. No Hollywood lib would be caught dead uttering those lines!
You have no idea how funny that is. DeFazio is bulletproof in this district, unless, as the saying goes, he gets caught in bed with a dead girl or a live boy. He beat a guy with utterly impeccable, fighter pilot, FBI war on terror, Eagle Scout credentials. I wrote in a local hard-core Conservative Democrat talk show host named Jim Bice. He's gonna be broadcasting returns from the Courthouse on Tuesday. He might get a laugh out of it. Or he might hunt me down and kick my ass. :)
Thanks; I wasn’t sure what it was, though I knew that it isn’t a church. I love that style.
DeFazio, eh? Any relation to Oregons Peter DeFazio?
Is this the start of another multi-state dynasty, a-la Rockerfeller, Udal & Kennedy?
The very same. He’s got the libs in Eugene and he holds onto the more conservative Dems with his positions on guns and vet’s issues. He’s in until he makes a Senate run.
Kin to the fabled Colonel Rex?
NO. Just moved our name for our last place in the Little Applegate Valley, between Medford & Grants Pass, to here. Seemed appropriate, since this place was origially homesteaded as a ‘fruit farm’. Still has a few of the original apple trees...and a lot of ‘wild’ descendants.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.