SSGT. FRANK WUTERICH, OUR SON, OUR HERO

Our son is Staff Sergeant Frank Wuterich the squad leader at Haditha. Most of you know the circumstances of Haditha, the ambush, the IED explosion, the loss of a comrade, the ensuing firefight, the aftermath of the engagement and then the media frenzy condemning our son and his squad. We would now like you to know a little bit about our son.

As a young boy in elementary and middle school, Frank always wanted to be challenged to do his best and accomplish as much as possible. He had been in the gifted and talented program, the Target program, the Odyssey program, the College Science program, played the trumpet in the school band, participated in baseball and soccer. High school was no different, except that there were numerous other activities, Drama Club, drum major, jazz band, tennis, soccer, wrestling, to name a few.

Frank had been considering a military career for a couple of years. He enlisted in the Marine Corps under the Delayed Entry Program on July 1, 1997, just a few months before he began his senior year in high school. Although he had planned to play in the Marine Corps band, things didn't work out and he enlisted in the infantry. We were always amazed at how he was able to juggle the Maine Corps, school, sports, a part-time job and a social life but he did so with determination.

A few days after high school graduation Frank was sent off to basic training at Parris Island, S.C. How proudly we stood and watched as he graduated from boot camp. Our son had accomplished his goals. He had become a dedicated, well-discipined Marine, a man. All he could be. He is now stationed at Camp Pendleton, CA.

Haditha was Frank's first combat tour of duty. He wasn't afraid to go although he would certainly miss his family. He was anxious, willing and ready to serve his country, confident that he and his fellow Marines had the best training possible and were well prepared. He wrote to us as often as he could, always telling us "not to worry." "We are all doing our jobs extremely well here and making it extremely hard for the insurgents to operate." We prayed every day, every night, every minute he was in Iraq, that he and his fellow Marines would come home safely.

On November 12, 2005, Haditha happened. Word came that he was okay but had lost one of his fellow Marines, two were injured, the rest were safe. In January 2006 he was recommended for the "Navy Achievement Medal with combat distinguishing device" by his platoon leader Lt. William T. Kallop for his leadership at Haditha. This recommendation has since fallen through the cracks and the medal has not been awarded.

Frank returned to the states in April 2006. He and his family were planning on relocating closer to the east coast when he was discharged in June 2006. He hoped to pursue a career in music production. That never happened! In May of 2006 the allegations began. We were deluged with media at our doorstep and phone calls from every news source in the U.S. and beyond. We continue to be called upon whenever any new headlines emerge. We know our son is innocent, we know he has done nothing wrong, we know he was following the "Rules of Engagement." He is a Marine who was doing the job he was trained to do. To Time magazine, John Murtha and Alan Colmes we say: "How dare you? How dare you condemn our Marines for doing their job? There have been NO Article 32 hearings, NO convictions, NO confessions! Yet you deem it necessary to tarnish their reputations without any facts." The misinformation, the "leaks", the media "sensationalism" makes our blood boil and our hearts break.

There isn't a day that goes by that we don't shed tears. There isn't a day that goes by that we don't say prayers. There isn't a day that goes by that we don't think of Frank and his squad. To those of you who have expressed your support for Frank and his felllow Marines via mail, phone calls, the internet, etc., we can only say that we will be eternally grateful! You make it a little easier to get through each day.

We have continuously talked to various news media, been on local and national television defending our son. Dave and our daughter-in-law have appeared on Hannity & Colmes. Our family and friends will continue to support our son. We hope and pray that you will too. We truly believe in his innocence.

Through all of this adversity Frank has maintained his innocence with dignity and held his head up high. He is a great Marine, a loving son, father, husband and brother. He is kind, has great character, and loves his country. He is OUR SON, OUR HERO!

The following is an email sent to 60 Minutes:

I have serious misgivings about whether or not anyone will take the time to even read this email, much less take any sort of action.

I am writing in response to Scott Pelley's recent report on the actions of US Marines in Haditha. I have watched 60 minutes almost religiously for decades now. I have often times defended 60 minutes against accusations of sensationalizing news for the benefit of ratings. Apparently you have changed your honest, non-sensationalized, rational and balanced approach to reporting news.

Scott Pelley's report on the young Marine, SSGT Wuterich, and the actions of his squad in Haditha were completely and utterly biased. There is an old saying, a Persian proverb, that states that everyone knows how to save the ship once it has sunk. Pelley has obviously never heard of, nor gleaned the logic behind that proverb.

"Frag and clear" is a house clearing method that has been used since World War II. It has been in use these many decades because it works. You pop the pin on a grenade, let the spoon fly, give a four count and toss it through the door. After the grenade explodes Marines then fan out into the affected space and "clear" the area. In this sense "clear" is a word which is a result of political correctness. In reality "clear" means kill anything that moves. The after effect (dirt and debris in the air) of the grenade explosion makes it near impossible to distinguish a combatant and a non-combatant.

There is, as of this moment, no definitive means of determining whether or not there are people inside a house, much less what their intentions might be. As such, frag and clear remains the best option for clearing a house. Therefore you cannot fault the Marines for their actions in clearing the houses. From what I have heard, they followed standard protocol.

A Marine's job is to follow orders. No Marine wants to kill civilians. The Marine is a warrior, but he is also a human. He has a conscience. He has a heart. He has the intelligence to realize that for every non-combatant he kills, he creates a combatant in the personage of the non-combatant's brother, father, friend or cousin. Regardless of whether you agree one thing remains constant: if you are wrong in your assessment of a person's combatant status, you may die. Let that sink in for a moment, Mr. Pelley.

In this instance it is regrettable that civilians died. In fact, it is an atrocity. However, the blame cannot be placed on the shoulders of a Staff Sergeant. Wuterich was trained to clear a house by the United States Marine Corps in a fashion which tends to kill more bad guys than Marines. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but this is the objective of any military. I also hate to be the bearer of bad news when I remind you that Marines are trained to be warriors, not police officers. Iraq is a war zone, not the United States. Let us please face the fact that Iraqi civilians are being killed every day. This is not SSGT. Wuterich's fault.

It is easy to sit at your desk back here in the States and pass judgment on the men and women on the ground in Iraq. Mr. Pelley spoke down to a man (who by the way is considered innocent until proven guilty) who had faced the IEDs and bullets and uncertainty in Iraq while Mr. Pelley sat here in the States safe, warm and happy. What was Pelley's biggest decision that day? Which tie should I wear? What should I have for lunch? Am I furthering my career today?

I have a few questions for Mr. Pelley: Are you an urban combat expert? Have you ever been involved as a combatant in battle? Have you ever been trained by the Marine Corps? Have you ever spontaneously acquired the ability to see through walls? If so, was your x-ray vision accompanied by a means with which to determine the person's intentions? Have you ever had to make life and death decisions on the fly while people were trying to kill you? If any of these questions are answered "no", then I suggest that you make a formal apology to SSGT Wuterich.

Pelley has no right to shade his questions and treat SSGT Wuterich as a common criminal. Even if Wuterich is convicted, which is probable due to the inflammation of this story by the media, he was only doing what he has been trained to do: kill more bad guys than Marines. His decisions, right or wrong, were based on the Marine Corps ethos: Unit, Corps, Country, God. Marines are indoctrinated into a warrior society which lives and dies by this creed. I agree that it is regrettable, but without such training they would simply not go where there is danger. They would run away from conflict rather than face the danger and take the actions necessary to eliminate the threat. This training usurps every self-survival instinct. Once again, it is sad, but entirely necessary. After all, how much sense does it make to you (whoever is reading this) to advance into an area where people are shooting at you? Answer: none. This is why these young men are trained to ignore the danger, to discard the normal instincts of civilized people and advance in the face of danger.

Mr. Pelley's facial expressions and tonality made him appear as if he were passing judgment on SSGT Wuterich. 60 Minutes has a track record of unbiased and fair reporting over a span of many years. It is sad that you would allow your emotions to cloud your judgment and blemish that record. Ironically this is the same crime you accuse SSGT Wuterich of committing.

On a separate note, it was deplorable that Mr. Pelley solicited a graphic description of the Marine who was dismembered in the IED attack. It was even more deplorable that the editors and producers did not edit that portion to spare the Marine's family. It was obvious that you did so only to further your biased position that the actions taken by the Marines that day were in reaction to the well liked Marine's death. You owe a public apology to his family.

I will no longer watch 60 Minutes so long as you continue to employ Scott Pelley. No one in my house will watch 60 Minutes so long as you employ Scott Pelley. His actions and lack of sensitivity to the family of the fallen Marine are/is reprehensible. I admit that this may be an irrational decision based on emotion, but hey, emotional and irrational are the catch words of the day.

Jeremy W
Jumpnghosophat@yahoo.com
York, PA

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.