Skip to comments.Remembering 9/11 (Stephen Miller Discusses How Duke U's 9/11 Memorial Resistance Was Broken Alert)
Posted on 09/26/2006 2:28:39 AM PDT by goldstategop
A September 11th memorial poses peculiar problems for the modern American university.
In the typical college of today, the intellectual vogues are anti-Americanism and sympathy for Americas enemies. By contrast, patriotism and support for our national defense are embraced about as strongly on college campuses as are capitalism and Dick Cheney. Anything that portrays America as under attack by Islamic terrorists, as even the most purely apolitical 9/11 memorial inevitably will, challenges the university dogma.
And so it is often left to students properly to mourn and remember that tragic day when its anniversary arrives. But what if students wanted to organize a memorial on a scale that exceeded their limited capacity to fund it? What if this memorial was not going to be a politically correct homage to "understanding" and non-violence, but traditional and patriotic? Could they somehow compel your typical leftist university to support it and would students embrace the opportunity to participate? Can 9/11 be properly remembered in a place that wants to pretend it never happened?
The 9/11 memorial at Duke University provides an answer to these questions, and that answer to each is a resounding, "yes."
About one month before school began, I decided I was going to organize a 9/11 memorial at my school to mark the fifth anniversary of the terror attacks. It didnt even occur to me when the idea developed that the school might already be organizing a proper slate of events. I knew that whatever they were planning would be insufficient and this assumption was of course shortly confirmed.
The first order of business was soliciting all of the major university departments for funding. These requests are sent to the department chairs. The memorial began as a Duke Conservative Union endeavor, but the goal from the beginning was that it should be a community memorial, an event for the whole student body, as well as Durham residents. As I set out in my initial funding request: The project I write to you about today transcends ideological and political boundaries--it is an event behind which the whole school can unite.
Apparently not. The departments I solicited offered not a cent of funding. Perhaps my desire to have a 2,997 flag display to memorialize everyone whose life was taken that day, and the purchasing of flag pins which we will encourage people to wear so that we as a campus can come together to show our support for our nation which suffered so much pain and loss in that attack 5 years ago, clashed too strongly with their worldviews.
Consider part of the response I received from the new head of the political science department: I personally do not think that your approach is appropriate because it depersonalizes the tragedy by converting it into an American issue.
Tell that to the firefighters raising the flag on ground zero, or the soldiers draping the flag over the pentagon. How is the worst terrorist attack on our soil in American history, from an enemy seeking to destroy us, not an "American issue"? How is showing unity and support for our nation as we remember when it was attacked inappropriate? I guess I havent been paying enough attention in my classes.
The same apparent concerns about the patriotic components of the memorial were echoed by the chair of the sociology department:
9-11 moved us into the human family in a new way, brought terror into white, urban, upper-class lives. Dont we want to acknowledge the horror of terrorism more broadly? Specifically, the type of event you propose suggests that all the pain of 9/11 has been borne only by the US and US citizens. That's untrue--thousands of lives across multiple nations, both on 9/11 and in the subsequent months, have been lost.
Keep in mind, all of this concern is fueled by the simple fact that the purchasing and display of American flags is involved in the memorial budget, which would indicate the leaders of the sociology and political science department would take objection to the great majority of 9/11 memorials occurring all across the nationoutside, naturally, of college campuses. Maybe the FNDY should remove the American flag from its honor guard and replace it with the UNs? God forbid we should come together as Americans in the wake of the terror attacksthat sort of behavior might inadvertently breed the will to fight terrorism.
Requests sent to the Duke graduate schools produced the same results. But the administration provided a much more interesting response: They promised to consider my proposal. They would talk it over, they said, and get back to me. So I waited. And waited. I sent a few more e-mails and waited some more. Nothing.
Duke had a problem. The school knew there was no way to justify not supporting a community 9/11 memorial, especially when they didnt have a similar one of their own, but they also didnt like the idea of conservatives being in charge, even if those conservatives were designing a non-partisan memorial. How could a 9/11 memorial at Duke University be run by anyone other than politically correct leftists? Could conservatives be trusted to run such an event? Who would make the pleas for non-violence and understanding? With no left-wing students clamoring to design a major community memorial, the administrations options were limited. They were entering uncharted waters and I just needed to find a way to nudge them in the right direction.
Enter the City Council. At the same time I sent requests to all the major facets of Duke University, I also tried to get in touch with the Durham City Council. Two City Councilmen, Mike Woodard and Thomas Stith, along with City Manager Patrick Baker, offered their full weight and support to the memorial project. I am indebted to them.
Additionally, I had sent out a request to the Durham Fire Department asking for their aid and involvement, and I was immediately put in touch with one Captain Towner. He and the department provided phenomenal assistance and support in bringing this memorial to our community. With two city councilmen, the City Manager, and the Fire Department behind the memorial (support which I strongly feel was vital to its success) the school had powerful reason to support it and a most difficult situation if they did not.
But the task was far from over. The school was hoping the decision could be taken off their hands if someone else would come forward and fund the effort. In a phone conversation with one of our university Vice-Presidents I was told that they would prefer to fill in the holes in an existing budget rather than supply a budget themselves. Given that at the time of this conversation 9/11 was only two weeks away, I was naturally very concerned about whether the project would be able to happen at all.
I had a third parallel process going forward from the beginning, which had already netted the generous $1,000-dollar donation from the VFW, and this was the search for outside funding. I had solicited donations from local business, national business, foundations, private individuals, you name it. However, the overriding sentiment from these different sources was that it was not their place to support one particular memorial at one particular university. There are many programs in place to fund speakers to which student organizers can apply. I dont blame the organizations that didnt donate to the memorialthere simply arent the existing bylaws or guidelines in place to make such a contribution possible, however much the individuals making the decision personally supported the project. Im also confident that with more time, arrangement could have been made. Nonetheless, I hope that in the future, these bylaws and guidelines will expand, but as a number of these people pointed out, the school itself should bear much of the responsibility for using some of its vast budget to support a 9/11 memorial.
Having made it clear to the administration that I had extensively and vigorously pursued outside funding and that the future of the memorial was in their hands, my suspicion was that the knowledge the memorial rested on their decision combined with the support of the Fire Department and key community leaders, who spoke with the administration, meant that they would in fact make a contributionenough money to say they helped out and prevent the possibility of criticism, but not enough to enable a program that would cost approximately 5,000 dollars. (To give you a sense of what that budget means to the university consider that they spent 45,000 dollars on MLK day commemoration last year, which featured Harry Belafonte as the keynote speaker).
However, there is also another factor in play which empowers non-leftwing college students in a way they never have been before. University administrators can no longer act with impunity. Students for Academic Freedom not only fights for student rights (and succeeds), but also serves as a vital watchdog group. Thanks to SAF, administrators are much more hesitant to engage in the sorts of partisan discrimination that characterizes so much of what goes on in our college campuses.
Obviously, there is a lot of battle left to fight, but as an SAF chapter President at Duke, I have personally witnessed the effect SAF has had on academia and am very confident that the new pressure brought to bear on university administrators, and their great need to be able to deflect criticism, has vastly increased the chances of success for non-left, non-PC projects, like this 9/11 memorialprojects that are usually the victims of partisan-motivated under-fundingof receiving proper university support.
To illustrate just the sort of mentality were dealing with, consider the one aspect of the memorial which the administration, later on, quashed. Any use of firearms on campus requires administrative and university police department clearance. The Durham Police Department wanted to honor and mourn the heroes from NYPD killed on 9/11 with a 21 gun salute (blanks of course) and I immediately set about trying to obtain said clearance. The administration, however, forbade any such salute. Here was the reason: Having a 21-gun salute, and thus involving guns in the memorial, would jeopardize its non-partisan nature and possibly offend students who werent conservative. You cant make this stuff up.
Fortunately, this was the only feature of the memorial that required special clearance and, hence, that the university had any real control over. Nothing else was in any way affected. However, the clock was ticking and a decision was going to have to come soon. With the support I had and the pressure that had been placed on the university administration, I wasnt surprised when they starting giving signs that they would help fund the project. Nor was I surprised by their request that I bring other student groups, of diverse ideologies, into the fold, which would no doubt helped alleviate some of their concerns. Im sure they had many closed-door conversations debating my request and how best to proceed. They knew conservatives would still be in charge, but perhaps having some leftwing students involved would, the administration probably thought, enlighten things a little.
So I created what I called the Duke Student 9/11 Memorial Commission, serving as Chair, and appointed a student by the name of Adam Zell, who had shown an interest in helping out, Vice-Chair. Having such a commission only more easily enabled my desire to create a community memorial and was a natural development in the planning process. I had a strategy in my head which I knew would both satisfy the needs of the administration, aid in the success of the memorial project, and in no way alter or compromise the planned memorial. Given the options available to the administration, such as requiring changes in the planned memorial, sharing leadership, involving leftwing faculty, that they simply told me to get a diverse group of student organizations on board, and left the process and everything else to my discretion, was in my view a significant victory.
Was it necessary to have other student groups involved if the existed plan was already non-partisan? Not at all. Did it speak the administrations distrust of conservatives? Absolutely. But the all-important goal was a meaningful, successful memorial and now it was within reach. I got a couple of clubs on board right off, contacted the administrators in question, and then fantastic news followedthe school was going to support the memorial in the amount of 4,000 dollars. A major victory.
One problem, though: The decision was so long in coming that the fifth anniversary of 9/11 was only 10 days away. Most of the plan had been sketched out, the appropriate people contacted, the proper processes set into motion, but there was a great deal that couldnt be arranged, requested, planned or reserved until I knew whether or not the needed money would be there or, for that matter, could have access to it. We has also recieved $500 from the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, bringing our budget up to $5,500 dollars. Putting it all together in 10 days would be an enormous challenge.
Any thoughts I might have entertained that were simple logistical reasons for the administration's temporizing were quickly banished by the response I received from one key administrator when I suggested that the school, having made this wonderful decision, might want to consider issuing a press release, and also that, to help ensure the success of their investment, they might want to consider sending out an e-mail to the student body about the memorial. As Id made clear from the beginning, I wanted this to be a memorial for our whole community.
But the administrator, one of our Vice-Presidents, was greatly dismayed by these requests. He explained that he could not assist because we were receiving not institutional sponsorship from Duke, but merely financial sponsorship. We should be careful, he cautioned, not to imply the university official supported our event. The analogy he gave was the administrations financial support of the Palestine Solidarity Movement -- a group that as documented by FrontPageMag.com and as Ive personally witnessed at Duke, is in league with Islamic terrorists. This administrator was very eager to see that we were having progress in getting other groups involved. Clearly, he was afraid of having a community event run by conservatives. Of course, were leftists in charge, it would not be an issue, just standard operating procedure.
So Im sure he was pleased to discover that by the day of the memorial, 10 major student groups were on board. Given the conditions of being a member group of the Memorial Commission, this is in itself is something I consider to be one of the major successes of the memorial project. I knew that if I simply invited student groups, some of them quite leftist, to be part of the commission, and thought wed all sit down and hammer out plans for a memoria,l that wed end up with either chaos or a memorial rife with their political agendas. Instead, I proposed to them the existing plan that I had, and the request was either sign on to this or sign on to nothing.
So, for instance, when the Asian Student Association said they were concerned the memorial didnt deal enough with Asians assaulted who were mistaken for being Muslim, we explained that our memorials design was already created and budgeted but they were free to independently pursue such programming. If we somehow accommodated every request of sponsoring student groups, a memorial for those murdered on 9/11 would have become grossly distracted, to say the least.
My feeling is that some of the student groups who typically arent involved in activities like ours, which honored the military and their sacrifices, were put in a similar place as the administration. The administration knew key people in the city were behind it, were worried about conservatives running it, but no one else had come to them with such an offer, and saying no would be an extremely hard decision to defend. Similarly, the far-left student groups knew key administrators were now behind it, were worried about who was running it, didnt have memorials designed of their own and didnt have other offers to be part of one, and knew saying no would be an extremely hard decision to defend.
So the student groups came on board and they are all to be congratulated, along with the administration, for putting aside their political biases and being part of something so profoundly important. It was a wonderful thing to see a community coalition supporting a 9/11 memorial that is meaningful and so distant from what youd expect on a college campus. Ive certainly been critical of the Duke administration, but here I both applaud and thank them profusely for their support, which I believe is a very significant step forward.
Here is the program they were supporting and which was brought to Dukes campus, as explained in the full page ad we ran in our student newspaper.
5 years ago America suffered the worst and most horrific attack in its history. It was a brutal, unprovoked assault against thousands of innocent civilians and the country in which they lived. Nearly 3,000 were murdered at the Pentagon, the World Trade Center, and in a flight that crashed into a field in Shanksville, Pennsylvania.
The victims knew no common age, religion, race or creed. They came from all walks of life. They represented all facets and attributes of American society. They were brothers and sisters, friends and companions; they were mothers and fathers, sons and daughters, husbands and wives.
This Monday, September 11th , we come together to mourn the dead, honor their memory, and pay tribute to those firefighters, police, and rescue workers who made the supreme sacrifice. We come together as a community and as Americans.
The night before, Sunday at 8:30 PM, we will be screening the film United 93 in Griffith Theatre to share the tragic story of the flights passengers and to recognize their heroic acts. All are invited to view this powerful and sobering film.
On Monday, there will be a display of 2,997 flags on West Campus to memorialize the fallenone flag for each person who perished on 9/11. Flag pins will also be distributed, which we encourage everyone to wear to show our strength and resolve in the ashes of such devastation, and to display our unity across all ideological and political boundaries.
There will also be a visual display in the Bryan Center to mark the attacks and to pay tribute to the noble rescue workers who rushed upwards towards hell as the sky rained down with ash and fire, dying as they livedwith the great and selfless courage that showed the whole world the unyielding spirit of our nation.
At 8 PM on Monday, 9/11, there will be a memorial service on the Plaza to which everyone at Duke and in Durham is urged to attend. The service will feature representatives from the Durham Fire Department, Durham Police Department, the Durham City Council, the U.S. Armed Services, and the Chapel Dean, Reverend Sam Wells. It is an opportunity for all of us to show our sympathy for the bereaved families; our support for the rescue workers who risk their lives to keep our communities safe and the soldiers called away from home and into battle; our defiance of the terrorists who condemned thousands of innocents to fiery tombs; and our solidarity as we remember and honor the fallen.
I'll try to give a brief idea illustration of how each of these components played out, especially the memorial service which was everything I had hoped it would be and could be.
The flag memorial was beautiful, and we were able to recruit about 25 people to help set it up. The Duke Chapel lies at the heart of campus and Chapel Drive runs right into it. As one comes up Chapel drive they could see the flags and the chapel all in one line of sight. This image was made even more moving by the fact that the Durham Fire Department had a truck directly behind the flag memorial and in front of the chapel all day long. They rotated trucks and crews every two hours and right before the service began at 8, they parked five trucks in front of the chapel and two Durham police cars were added as well. Throughout the day there was also a Duke police car beside the fire truck and two Durham police cars joined in the evening. I also rented a light tower and put it in the quad so at night all the flags were illuminated, which created a very powerful effect. From midnight to 8am I hired a Durham Police officer to guard the memorial so there was no chance of anyone disturbing it in any capacity. When students woke up that morning they were greeted by a stirring image the likes of which theyve never seen on Dukes campus. All day I saw photographing the display and the firemen, stopping there to reflect and taking time to mourn. It was very moving.
All the local stations came down to add the display to their evening and/or morning news feeds. Everyone watching at home would be reminded of the staggering toll of that heinous attack five years ago and would also see that while their community was neglecting this painful but essential 9/11 anniversary, Duke students were not.
Indeed, one of the city councilmen explained to me that part of the reason he was so tremendously supportive was not only that he believed in the need for our memorial but that to his dismay the city of Durham, a very far-left operation, didnt really have anything planned of their own. What we were creating was a memorial for the whole Duke and Durham community.
The budget allowed 3,000 flag pins, which I was able to get at a discount price. It was great to see students walking around wearing their pins on 9/11 and when students and community members arrived at the service, we had them laid out on the table next to the programs so they could be available to everyone present.
On Sunday night we showed "United 93" to what I understand was a good crowd. I welcomed everyone to the film at the beginning but didn't get to see how many finally showed up as I had to return to setting up the flag memorial. One of the students present told me that those everyone seemed to be affected by the film. As students left, there was none of the energetic small talk and joking around that is usual as people exit a movie theater. Instead, people were very quiet and the mood was very somber, befitting the occasion.
The display in our student union, the Bryan Center, was put onto large foam boards which rested on easels. The memorial display consisted of 15 panels broken into four sections. Three panels for the FNDY and NYPD tribute and memoriam, seven for the six for the Duke alumni killed, with the first just reading "In Memoriam," four reflecting on the devestation of the attacks, with quotes from Rudy Giuliani about the horrors he witnessed, pictures of the pentagon and WTC attacks, and family photos of the 9.11 victims with some text to accompany it. The fifteenth memorial panel was by itself, facing students by the main entrance, reading, "9.11.0/ In Memoriam / 2,997 Lives Taken / May We Never Forget" There were two additional, separate panels which informed students of the evening's memorial service. I also draped a huge American Flag over the main stairwell of the Bryan Center, and covered the wood railing overlooking the lower floor with small American flags placed in stands. Never before had I seen patriotic decorations in the Bryan Center.
Each time I went into the Bryan Center lines of people looking at the display, reading about the lives of the alumni lost, pondering the suffering and sacrifices of the day. It accomplished exactly what I'd hoped it would.
I had been worried about the weather, as we've had on and off rain for the last several weeks here, and forecasts predicted scattered thunderstorms, but the weather ended up being absolutely perfect and it was just a remarkably beautiful evening and setting.
Right before an event starts there's always a huge knot in my stomach as the great question looms large: Will anyone show up? This experience is not helped by the fact that students usually don't arrive for an event before it starts. However, slowly but surely the audience started to build, and by the time the service began there were hundreds and hundreds of people, so many that they were lined up all over the plaza and even had to start lining up at the side of the outdoor stage. I would say there was as many as 1,000 people in attendance. And as they arrived they saw the powerful image of all the cops and firefighters assembled, and the honor guards of the Durham Fire Department, Police Department and Duke's ROTC.
I want to mention that while the service was designed as a community memorial and was thus non-partisan, it was non-partisan in the best and traditional sense of the word. It was not non-partisan in the modern sense, as is par for the course on college campuses--politically correct nonsense about nonviolence and understanding that might not make reference to party or ideology but stands in square contrast to conservative, American values. For instance, on the first year anniversary of 9/11, in her very short remarks, former President Nan Keohane implied that true peace is possible, if we seek understanding, and realize that love banishes hatred. And to think weve been spending all of this money on the militaryall we really need are enough guitars and the music for a global kumbaya.
No, our service was non-partisan in the traditional American sense, with the idea that there are core values and beliefs which we can all unite behind--love of country, support for the military, defense of our nation, belief in our goodness and the wickedness of those who attack us, God and faith.
The service began with the entrance of the Fire Department honor guard and the posting of the flags, who stood with the flags as the Duke Chorale sang the national anthem. Then, the Fire Department Chaplain offered an opening reflection and prayer, I made introductory remarks, and then City Councilman Mike Woodard, who'd been such a strong supporter from the beginning, delivered an amazing speech about the significance of the attacks and our responsibilities in a post 9-11 world.
After Councilman Woodard, our Vice-President of Student Affairs delivered his remarks, which, to his great credit, lacked any hint of political agenda. Ive spoken with the Vice-President on a number of occasions and he is very open about being a flaming liberal, but none of that was evident here.
He was followed by the State Commander of Veterans of Foreign Wars, who delivered a very powerful speech about the 9/11 attacks and the sacrifices of the soldiers called to defend us in their wake, as well as the need to support our troops across ideological boundaries. Before he went up to the podium the Duke Army ROTC marched up the stage with their colors and stood in formation behind Commander Goins as he spoke and then followed him off the stage. Another deeply stirring image.
Next a member of the Fire Department honor guard rang the firefighters memorial bell, in five groups of five, and then Captain Sean Fields from the Fire Department spoke, who made extremely moving remarks about the sacrifices of firefighters and the work that they do and the significance for firefighters of a tragedy like 9/11.
Captain Fields was followed by Reverend Sam Wells, of the Duke Chapel, who spoke of the meaning of 9/11 from a religious and spiritual perspective, led us in a prayer, and initiated a moment of silence. That moment of silence lasted until a member of the honor guard from the Durham Police Department began playing taps off stage. When taps was finished, the Fire Department Guard entered the stage and took down the flags, thus concluding the memorial service.
It was covered in all the local media. We also had a collection table for the FDNY and NYPD and raised several hundred dollars for each, which is quite decent given that so many students carry around little cash as a simple swipe of their ID card can buy about anything on campus. The service was so moving and beautiful and, in spite of all the sorrow, so profoundly inspiring. It was one of the most memorable and meaningful days of my life.
In the days that followed Ive heard enthusiastic feedback from those present and I am proud that we could bring this event to Dukes campus -- that, in the heart of an academic world that wants so dearly for us to forget, we were able come together to mourn the fallen, honor our heroes, and unite as Americans. It shows that for all the indoctrination, for the tragic manner in which society has failed in its education of our youth, there are still ties that bind, there are still ideals and values which can bring us together and in which, perhaps, lay the key to the endurance of our beloved nation.
Universities have vast budgets and spectacular amounts of money go toward funding all manner of left-wing, postmodernist, secular-progressive events and programs. Hopefully, what happened at Duke shows that with enough persistence, the support of a watchdog group like SAF on campus, with the changing landscape -- thanks in part to the David Horowitz Freedom Center -- and the backing of influential people in their community, students can start to break this pernicious monopoly and start to transform the face of their school -- and, ultimately, higher education in America.
"Show me just what Mohammed brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached." -Manuel II Paleologus
I read with great interest and with tears. This is a heartwarming story about the 'power of one' and the fact that persistence never fails. Kudos!
This was inspiring. I live in a region with several very liberal colleges, as well as one that was founded by Catholic brothers, which unfortunately, doesn't have the temerity to uphold its own historical mandate/traditions.
The whole memorial effort detailed in the article was undertaken from the ground up. That is the way Universities can be truly diversified--by the persistent efforts those on campus and in the community willing to challenge the orthodoxies and appeal to the common sense of every day working people in the community. Bravo!
Wow! This is great!
Miller should be chief of staff if the rats don’t steel the election and Johnson doesn’t split the ticket.
I want to show how the city of Durham celebrated its Fourth of July parade in 2017:
While these images clearly show the Islamic, Mexican and other foreign flags posted higher than the American flag to "celebrate" America's birthday, the numerous gay rainbow flags and lawn signs welcoming illegals and Arabic-speaking refugees are out of the frame.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.