Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

District pulls plug on speech
Review Journal ^ | June 17, 2006 | Antonio Planas

Posted on 06/19/2006 1:33:47 PM PDT by BradtotheBone

She knew her speech as valedictorian of Foothill High School would be cut short, but Brittany McComb was determined to tell her fellow graduates what was on her mind and in her heart.

But before she could get to the word in her speech that meant the most to her -- Christ -- her microphone went dead.

Advertisement

The decision to cut short McComb's commencement speech Thursday at The Orleans drew jeers from the nearly 400 graduates and their families that went on for several minutes.

However, Clark County School District officials and an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union said Friday that cutting McComb's mic was the right call. Graduation ceremonies are school-sponsored events, a stance supported by federal court rulings, and as such may include religious references but not proselytizing, they said.

They said McComb's speech amounted to proselytizing and that her commentary could have been perceived as school-sponsored.

Before she delivered her commencement speech, McComb met with Foothill administrators, who edited her remarks. It's standard district practice to have graduation speeches vetted before they are read publicly.

School officials removed from McComb's speech some biblical references and the only reference to Christ.

But even though administrators warned McComb that her speech would get cut short if she deviated from the language approved by the school, she said it all boiled down to her fundamental right to free speech.

That's why, for what she said was the first time in her life, the valedictorian who graduated with a 4.7 GPA rebelled against authority.

"I went through four years of school at Foothill and they taught me logic and they taught me freedom of speech," McComb said. "God's the biggest part of my life. Just like other valedictorians thank their parents, I wanted to thank my lord and savior."

In the 750-word unedited version of McComb's speech, she made two references to the lord, nine mentions of God and one mention of Christ.

In the version approved by school officials, six of those words were omitted along with two biblical references. Also deleted from her speech was a reference to God's love being so great that he gave his only son to suffer an excruciated death in order to cover everyone's shortcomings and forge a path to heaven.

Allen Lichtenstein, general counsel for the ACLU of Nevada, had read the unedited version of McComb's speech and said district officials did the right thing by cutting McComb's speech short because her commentary promoted religion.

"There should be no controversy here," Lichtenstein said. "It's important for people to understand that a student was given a school-sponsored forum by a school and therefore, in essence, it was a school-sponsored speech."

Lichtenstein said that position was supported by two decisions by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in 2000 and 2003.

Both cases involved graduation ceremonies and religious speeches given by commencement speakers. In the 2003 case, Lichtenstein said, the plaintiff even petitioned the Supreme Court to have the decision reversed, but the request was denied.

In 2003, the Clark County School Board amended district regulations on religious free speech, prohibiting district officials from organizing a prayer at graduation or selecting speakers for such events in a manner that favors religious speech or a prayer.

The remainder of the amendment allows for religious expression during school ceremonies.

Where students or other private graduation speakers are selected on the basis of genuinely neutral, evenhanded criteria and retain primary control over the content of their expression, however, that expression is not attributable to the school and, therefore, may not be restricted because of its religious (or anti-religious) content," it states.

"To avoid any mistaken perception that a school endorses student or other private speech that is not in fact attributable to the school, school officials may make appropriate neutral disclaimers to clarify that such speech is not school sponsored."

District legal counsel Bill Hoffman said the regulation allows students to talk about religion, but speeches can't cross into the realm of preaching.

"We review the speeches and tell them they may not proselytize," Hoffman said. "We encourage people to talk about religion and the impact on their lives. But when that discussion crosses over to become proselytizing, then we to tell students they can't do that."

McComb, who will study journalism at Biola University, a private Christian school in La Mirada, Calif., doesn't believe she was preaching. She said although some people might not like the message of her speech, it was just that, her speech.

"People aren't stupid and they know we have freedom of speech and the district wasn't advocating my ideas," McComb said. "Those are my opinions.

"It's what I believe."


TOPICS: Culture/Society; Extended News; US: Nevada
KEYWORDS: aclu; aclulist; christianstudents; commencement; govwatch; jbts; libertarians; religion; school; students; zerotolerance
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-4041-6061-63 next last

1 posted on 06/19/2006 1:33:48 PM PDT by BradtotheBone
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

So much for the 1st Amendment if you are Christian I guess. I thought it was HER speech to give. Guess not.


2 posted on 06/19/2006 1:35:32 PM PDT by MNJohnnie (The Democrat Party! For people who prefer slogans over solutions!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone
Ann Coulter has SO nailed the secular "Godless" official religion of left. No heresy allowed; no free speech; no mention of the word "God" in public.


3 posted on 06/19/2006 1:37:17 PM PDT by FormerACLUmember (No program, no ideas, no clue: The democrats!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

4 posted on 06/19/2006 1:38:49 PM PDT by FormerACLUmember (No program, no ideas, no clue: The democrats!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone
"They said McComb's speech amounted to proselytizing and that her commentary could have been perceived as school-sponsored."

No one is safe, then. This is how freedom ends.

5 posted on 06/19/2006 1:40:55 PM PDT by L98Fiero (I'm worth a million in prizes.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: swmobuffalo


PING


6 posted on 06/19/2006 1:42:40 PM PDT by Paperdoll (.........on the cutting edge)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: MNJohnnie
When the valedictorian (or any other student speaker) is introduced, I don't understand why the introduction can't conclude with a disclaimer that the contents of the speech is not school sponsored. Problem solved.

They do that with TV and radio editorials all the time. Everyone understands.

7 posted on 06/19/2006 1:44:09 PM PDT by robertpaulsen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

you mean the ACLU wont advocate for Christians??
Only against us huh... Big surprise!


8 posted on 06/19/2006 1:44:23 PM PDT by AzNASCARfan
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

Wow, I just noticed it but I have those same three crosses in my house leading up the stair-well. (See pic at link).


9 posted on 06/19/2006 1:46:37 PM PDT by L98Fiero (I'm worth a million in prizes.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone
Is the unedited text of her speech available anywhere?
10 posted on 06/19/2006 1:48:54 PM PDT by BenLurkin ("The entire remedy is with the people." - W. H. Harrison)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

I'm guessing the microphone wouldn't be cut off if the student stood there declaring herself homosexual and praising all the virtues of secular humanism.


11 posted on 06/19/2006 1:49:52 PM PDT by Tired of Taxes (That's taxes, not Texas. I have no beef with TX. NJ has the highest property taxes in the nation.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

This ACLU is a trip. She can`t talk, but these psycho Professors can, and do it everyday. Who was that Professor last week who was bashing everything about the white race, the US, and bashing Jews? I didn`t see the ACLU pulling no plug on that guy.


12 posted on 06/19/2006 1:50:56 PM PDT by Screamname (George Noory freggin` rules!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

This has gotten truly bizzare. You have school districts believing it violates the US Constitution for an individual student speaker to make reference to their own religious beliefs. That just cannot be true, if it were we are living in China now, not the USA. And someone must stop schools from pulling the plug on individual comments about Christ or any other religion. IMHO the federal government ought to investigate this as a civil rights violation.


13 posted on 06/19/2006 1:53:14 PM PDT by Williams
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: robertpaulsen
Curious what the response would of been if they pull the plug on a "Gay Pride" event. So much for "Celebrating Diversity". One of the most obnoxious things about the Modern Political Left, their rabid hypocrisy.
14 posted on 06/19/2006 1:59:14 PM PDT by MNJohnnie (The Democrat Party! For people who prefer slogans over solutions!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

Luckily, the Commissars of Free Speech were there to protect everyone from this dangerous counterrevolutionary. Uncontrollable theism might have broken out! (/sarcasm off)


15 posted on 06/19/2006 2:04:13 PM PDT by Tirian
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone
Brittany McComb will be on Hannity and Colmes tonight and they will show video of the muzzled commencement speech.

I always thought that a valedictorian asked to speak, explaining in their own words what contributed to their success would not be censored. The school and admin is soliciting their opinions, whether they adhere to the same beliefs or not. This story is ridiculous and really is a prime example of the rampant discrimination which is targeting people of faith every day in this country, thanks in large part to the communistic ACLU.
16 posted on 06/19/2006 2:06:36 PM PDT by khnyny (Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few.- Winston Churchill)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BradtotheBone

If the LIEberal DUmocrats are for "separation of church & state", then why are their rallies ALWAYS held at a black church?


17 posted on 06/19/2006 2:10:40 PM PDT by RasterMaster ("Big Tents" you get Clowns & Circus Freaks! The road to HELL is paved with LIEberals!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: MNJohnnie

I do disagree with Miss McComb's statement "People aren't stupid". Examples to support my argument would be Allen Lichtenstein and Bill Hoffman.


18 posted on 06/19/2006 2:18:12 PM PDT by jjones9853
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]

To: Tirian
Luckily, the Commissars of Free Speech were there to protect everyone from this dangerous counterrevolutionary. Uncontrollable theism might have broken out! (/sarcasm off)

Blimy! I didn't expect the Secular Inquisition!

If this was not so sad it would be funny. Everything the Leftist CLAIM is why they hate "Religious Right" does is only actually being done BY them to any person of faith they can get their hands on. The rabid hypocrisy on the part of the Political Left here is stunning

19 posted on 06/19/2006 2:25:29 PM PDT by MNJohnnie (The Democrat Party! For people who prefer slogans over solutions!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 15 | View Replies]

To: Abram; albertp; AlexandriaDuke; Allosaurs_r_us; Americanwolf; Americanwolfsbrother; Annie03; ...
Libertarian ping.To be added or removed from my ping list freepmail me or post a message here
20 posted on 06/19/2006 2:52:49 PM PDT by freepatriot32 (Holding you head high & voting Libertarian is better then holding your nose and voting republican)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 19 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021-4041-6061-63 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson