Skip to comments.
AFTERWORD: ON CLINTON SMALLNESS--BRINKLEY MISSES THE POINT (CLINTON'S HOFSTRA APOLOGIA)
Hofstra University, History News Network ^
| 12.27.05
| Mia T
Posted on 12/27/2005 9:58:50 AM PST by Mia T
- AFTERWORD:
-
ON CLINTON SMALLNESS--BRINKLEY MISSES THE POINT
- THE FAILED, DYSFUNCTIONAL CLINTON PRESIDENCY
(DECONSTRUCTING CLINTON'S HOFSTRA SPEECH) part1: The "Brinkley" Lie
-
- by Mia T, 12.27.05
- One of the American historians I most admire, Douglas Brinkley out there, sitting here, was quoted in the paper today as saying that I would be viewed as a great president except for the fact of the impeachment, which is just there.
-
bill clinton Hofstra apologia November 11, 2005
|
- clinton's ranking will likely get worse over time. Economic issues fade in importance. Moral issues presist and grow. (paraphrase)
-
Douglas Brinkley February 2000 (discussing C-SPAN PRESIDENTS POLL) Washington Journal
|
Note that although Brinkley doesn't place much importance on the economic management dimension--he argues that the economy variable is not durable over time--he fails to recognize that the evaluation of the clinton economy by the historians is erroneous to begin with.
Note also that C-SPAN historians found no evidence of clinton "greatness" irrespective of his moral-authority deficit, contrary to Douglas Brinkley's claim made at the clinton revisionist confab3.
(NOTE: My later research has revealed that Brinkley's qualified mention of clinton "greatness" was not a claim but rather a polite guest's white lie about an abject loser. Instead of taking the AP report at face value, one must carefully parse Brinkley's actual words and especially note the subjunctive construction.)
Mia T, 11.10.05 Historian massages clinton numbers, ego + legacy at revisionist confab C-SPAN historians find no clinton "greatness" irrespective of moral-authority deficit
|
The term "great" is probably an overused term. There are only a few presidents who make that top tier: Abraham Lincoln, George Washington, Franklin Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt, Harry Truman, Thomas Jefferson, and a few others who might be there.
I don't think bill clinton ever reached that category.
One, it's hard if you're not a wartime president
Note to Douglas Brinkley (NTDB): clinton WAS a wartime president. The problem is, he surrendered.
Preemptively.
You might say the clinton approach to The War on Terror was the perverse obverse of The Bush Doctrine.
or have some huge event.
NTDB: clinton had one almost immediately, which he summarily ignored, the first attack on American soil since Pearl Harbor, the 1993 WTC bombing.
Do you recall that he urged us to ignore the bombing, too? Ignore the first major Islamofascist terrorist attack on the continental United States?!
Did you know clinton never visited the site? (And he was only 15 minutes away mere days after the bombing. He chose, instead, to give some forgettable speech on --what else? -- the economy.)
Second, clinton is not known for something like Lyndon Johnson was -- The Civil Rights Act -- or even Theodore Roosevelt and conservation, or one big thing.
I think his successes were in welfare reform, economic discipline,trade pacts.
NTDB: Arguable. He was dragged kicking and screaming by the Republicans.
Those are achievements, but they're hard to get people queuing up a hundred years from now excited to see the "NAFTA Pen Under Glass."
- NTDB:
Great turn of phrase.
Douglas Brinkley Nov. 12, 2005 The History News Network Refuting clinton's Hofstra-apologia "Brinkley" lie |
- The clintons continue to imperil virtually every sector of society, indeed, continue to imperil America and the world, with their exponentially increasing facility in manipulating electoral/policy matter and energy at ever smaller scales. Their "school uniforms" of the '90s became "nanotech uniforms" today; both are proxies for "fight terrorism," which the clintons have neither the stomach nor the know-how to do.
NANO-PRESIDENT the danger of the unrelenting smallness of bill + hillary clinton by Mia T, 7.31.05
|
LEHRER: President Bush, your closing statement, sir.
PRESIDENT BUSH (audio): Three weeks from now--two weeks from tomorrow, America goes to the polls and you're going to have to decide who you want to lead this country ...
On foreign affairs, some think it's irrelevant. I believe it's not. We're living in an interconnected world...And if a crisis comes up, ask who has the judgment and the experience and, yes, the character to make the right decision?
And, lastly, the other night on character Governor Clinton said it's not the character of the president but the character of the presidency. I couldn't disagree more. Horace Greeley said the only thing that endures is character. And I think it was Justice Black who talked about great nations, like great men, must keep their word.
And so the question is, who will safeguard this nation, who will safeguard our people and our children? I need your support, I ask for your support. And may God bless the United States of America.
(Applause)
|

ouglas Brinkley totally misses the point of clinton smallness.
The clinton presidency was small not because of absence of opportunity, but rather because of absence of courage, vision, selflessness, real intelligence and a moral core.
The endless parade of clinton small was required to fill the void created by an absence of the big stuff -- big stuff like "fighting terrorism." |
|
HORNS: Bush vs. clinton
- by Mia T, 12.19.05
|
-
-
- a tin-horn politician with the manner of a rural corn doctor and the mien of a ham actor
-
H.L. Mencken
|
- Far better it is to dare mighty things, to win glorious triumphs, even though checkered by failure, than to take rank with those poor spirits who neither enjoy much nor suffer much, because they live in the gray twilight that knows neither victory nor defeat.
-
Theodore Roosevelt
|
- The cowardly, self-serving, seditious clintons may have found temporary refuge in 'the gray twilight,' but, as 9/11 demonstrated, America was not similarly sheltered....
-
-
deconstructing clinton
"just because I could"
 (viewing movie requires Flash Player 7, available HERE) FOOL ME ONCE, SHAME ON YOU! FOOL ME TWICE, SHAME ON ME!
-
|
|
December 7, 1941+64
AN OPEN LETTER TO TIM ROBBINS, DAVID GEFFEN, CHRIS MATTHEWS, MAUREEN DOWD + JEANINE PIRRO
RE: a not-so-modest proposal concerning hillary clinton
Dear Concerned Americans,
Hillary Clinton's revisionist tome notwithstanding, 'living history' begets a certain symmetry. It is in that light that I make this not-so-modest proposal on this day, exactly 64 years after the attack on Pearl Harbor.
The context of our concern today--regardless of political affiliation--is Iraq and The War on Terror, but the larger fear is that our democracy may not survive.
We have the requisite machines, power and know-how to defeat the enemy in Iraq and elsewhere, but do we have the will?
In particular, do we have the will to identify and defeat the enemy in our midst?
Answerable to no one, heir apparent in her own mind, self-serving in the extreme, Hillary Clinton incarnates this insidious new threat to our survival.
What we decide to do about Missus Clinton will tell us much about what awaits us in these perilous new times.
COMPLETE LETTER
December 7, 1941+64 Mia T AN OPEN LETTER TO TIM ROBBINS, DAVID GEFFEN, CHRIS MATTHEWS, MAUREEN DOWD + JEANINE PIRRO RE: a not-so-modest proposal concerning hillary clinton
COPYRIGHT MIA T 2005 |
THE FAILED, DYSFUNCTIONAL CLINTON PRESIDENCY (DECONSTRUCTING CLINTON'S HOFSTRA SPEECH) part1: The "Brinkley" Lie
by Mia T, 12.26.05
 (viewing movie requires Flash Player 7, available HERE)
-

ne would think that after bill clinton's shameless--pathetic, really--Hofstra apologia, Doris Kearns Goodwin and those 400 other hog-and-bow-tied-save-clinton retrograde-obsessing historiographers would finally get it. But then, we are talking leftist lobe here....
The speech, full of poses, poll-tested phrases and prevarication, was just another example of the clintons' utter contempt. For the people, for the presidents, for the presidency, for the country, for the Constitution... and, ultimately I suspect, for themselves.
This endeavor is the first in a series of essays with video that will attempt to deconstruct this very revealing speech.
The clintons' fundamental error: They are too arrogant and dim-witted to understand that the demagogic process in this fiberoptic age isn't about counting spun heads; it's about not discounting circumambient brains. (Did bill clinton really think Douglas Brinkley would let the "clinton greatness but for impeachment" lie stand? Is clinton delusional? Or just plain dumb?)
-
COPYRIGHT MIA T 2005
-
|
|
|
This legacy confab is in and of itself proof certain of clinton's deeply flawed character, and a demonstration in real time of the way in which the clinton years were about a legacy that was incidentally a presidency.
Madeleine Albright captured the essence of this dysfunctional presidency best when she explained why clinton couldn't go after bin Laden.
According to Richard Miniter, the Albright revelation occurred at the cabinet meeting that would decide the disposition of the USS Cole bombing by al Qaeda [that is to say, that would decide to do what it had always done when a "bimbo" was not spilling the beans on the clintons: Nothing]. Only Clarke wanted to retaliate militarily for this unambiguous act of war.
Albright explained that a [sham] Mideast accord would yield [if not peace for the principals, surely] a Nobel Peace Prize for clinton. Kill or capture bin Laden and clinton could kiss the 'accord' and the Peace Prize good-bye.
If clinton liberalism, smallness, cowardice, corruption, perfidy--and, to borrow a phrase from Andrew Cuomo, clinton cluelessness--played a part, it was, in the end, the Nobel Peace Prize that produced the puerile pertinacity that enabled the clintons to shrug off terrorism's global danger.
COMPLETE ARTICLE
|
|
|
|
C-SPAN asked noted presidential historians to rank the American presidents1 along the following ten dimensions: public persuasion, crisis leadership, economic management, moral authority, international relations, administrative skills, relations with congress, vision/setting an agenda, pursued equal justice for all, and performance within context of times.
bill clinton emerged as middling in most dimensions; he was surpassed in others by a settled mediocrity (Carter) and a putative failure (Nixon). In moral authority, bill clinton was rated dead last.2 He did fairly well in public persuasion, not a surprising finding given the volume of snake oil he managed to peddle during his putative presidency.
"It's NOT the economy, stupid!"
Clinton's best scores were on the economic management and pursued equal justice for all dimensions. However, both of these results are meaningful only insofar as they redound to the moral authority dimension: they are wholly based on clinton fraudulence, cooked books and black poses, respectively; and clinton's shameless Rosa Parks eulogy last week assured us that the insidious brand of clinton racism is alive and well during these tiptoe years of what the clintons hope will be their interregnum.
Note that although Brinkley doesn't place much importance on the economic management dimension--he argues that the economy variable is not durable over time--he fails to recognize that the evaluation of the clinton economy by the historians is erroneous to begin with.
Note also that C-SPAN historians found no evidence of clinton "greatness" irrespective of his moral-authority deficit, contrary to Douglas Brinkley's claim made at the clinton revisionist confab3.
(NOTE: My later research has revealed that Brinkley's qualified mention of clinton "greatness" was not a claim but rather a polite guest's white lie about an abject loser. Instead of taking the AP report at face value, one must carefully parse Brinkley's actual words and especially note the subjunctive construction.)
MIDDLING
Twenty presidents rank higher than bill clinton and 20 rank lower. But this placement assumes equal weight for each of the dimensions. And therein lies the flaw.
If 9/11 taught us anything, it is that presidential character and moral authority count, and count most.4 If the variables are properly weighted, bill clinton will always come out dead last.
That is, unless Americans are dumb enough to make the same mistake twice.
Mia T, 11.10.05 Historian massages clinton numbers, ego + legacy at revisionist confab C-SPAN historians find no clinton "greatness" irrespective of moral-authority deficit
|
IT TAKES A CLINTON TO RAZE A COUNTRY by Mia T, 11.14.05
 (viewing movie requires Flash Player 7, available HERE)
|

TOPICS: Your Opinion/Questions
KEYWORDS: billclinton; clinton; clintondysfunction; clintonfailure; clintonlegacy; clintonsmallness; douglasbrinkley; hofstra; hofstraconfab; imemine; iraq; legacy; nationalsecurity; revisionisthistory; terror; terrorism; terrorists; waronterror; wot; x42
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-55 next last
1
posted on
12/27/2005 9:58:56 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: Mia T
Thanks for all your great efforts, Mia.
2
posted on
12/27/2005 10:02:19 AM PST
by
ncountylee
(Dead terrorists smell like victory)
To: jla; WorkingClassFilth; Gail Wynand; Brian Allen; Wolverine; Lonesome in Massachussets; IVote2; ...
3
posted on
12/27/2005 10:02:55 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: Mia T
4
posted on
12/27/2005 10:05:07 AM PST
by
bmwcyle
(Evolution is a myth -- Libertarians just won't evolve into Conservatives.)
To: ncountylee
5
posted on
12/27/2005 10:09:31 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: bmwcyle
6
posted on
12/27/2005 10:10:00 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: Mia T
Small and Left leaning in a Peyronie's sort of way...or so they say.
7
posted on
12/27/2005 10:10:38 AM PST
by
Vaquero
To: Vaquero
- Thou art arm'd that hath thy crook'd schemers straight.
Cudgel thy brains no more, the clinton plots are great....
- On Neutered and Neutering
-
- by Mia T and Edward Zehr (EZ)
-
- With all the neutered talk of late
- I thought y'all would appreciate
- a relevant Shakespearean conversation
- with EZ, a clinton chronicler Elizabethan.
-
- [I had just asked the playwright if he had writer's block.]
-
-
- EZ:
- Think that thy bard hath now MacJeff forsaken?
- In that would'st thou be verily mistaken.
- Mayhap thou hast impatiently forgot
- That facts comprise the essence of the plot.
-
-
- MIA T:
- Methinks thy bard hath schemes forsaken.
- Mayhap thou art verily mistaken.
- Plots comprise the essence of the facts.
- Forsake the contrariwise artifacts.
-
-
- EZ:
- Gadzooks, could'st be thy bard is put to rout?
- 'Twould seem his veriest words are turned about.
- Could'st show whereby effect doth flow from cause,
- Would'st then be due a round of brisk applause.
-
- Perhaps I could this point of view adopt,
- For was not Bill by Hillary thus bopped
- In like wise as MacJeff, upon the head,
- And with a lamp, just as thy bard hath said?
-
- Thus are the facts revealed for all to see:
- Thy bard did make good use of ESP.
- Contrariwise, the White House read my serial,
- And sought to make good use of the material.
-
-
- MIA T:
- Thy bard's "effect doth flow from cause" linearity
- And 'twould seem thy veriest good use of oracularity
- 'Twere not the nature of the plots I pricked thy bard to adopt
- Withal Bill, like wise as MacJeff, upon the head was bopped.
-
- Methought the plots thou would'st use sprung not o' telepathy.
- Didst thou never hear the most traitorously corrupted conspiracy?
- Brutus's heart wrapp'd in Hillaryous hide.
- Interns and China suckling the impotent fool Cheapside.
-
- What more paying play than a corrupted plot untainted
- With thrice times two naked villains feinted?
- Thou art arm'd that hath thy crook'd schemers straight.
- Cudgel thy brains no more, the clinton plots are great.
-
-
- EZ:
- A point well made, experience vicarious
- Was grounded in events utmost Hillaryous.
- Betruth, the president sustained concussion
- Ere I had even started the discussion.
-
- But, lest thy bard be seen to make retreat,
- The second bop was truly a repeat.
- In consequence, I need no psychic hotline
- To reconstruct an oft repeated plotline.
-
- Now, as regards the wretched Cheapside brat,
- And turmoil his concupiscence begat,
- Need'st have no fear regards unfolding strife
- O'er these events, for Art must copy Life.
-
-
- MIA T:
- Eureka! (Not Gadzooks!)
- Though I have neither wit, nor words, nor playbooks
- Thy bard this simpleminded poster avoidth plagiarize.
- (Withal thy bard's own baseborn tendency contrariwise.)
-
- Now, as regards the wretched Cheapside brat,
- And turmoil his concupiscence begat,
- Methinks MacJeff's crook'd feelpolitik, the lasix death, his solipsistic sex
- Thou must put in cold blood'd cardiovascular context.
-
- The brain deviseth laws for the blood,
- but the brain 'tself is ne'er understood.
- The King's crook'dness flows from limp circulation.
- Methinks the solution is swift amputation.
-
-
- EZ:
- Thou place thy versifier in a quandary,
- Redoubling thy most sharp-edged entendre.
- The gist of they intent can I but gape on.
- Dost thou propose the prez be made a capon?
-
- In blood caught up these wretches play their role,
- But this must not become Le Grand Guignol.
- Lest those of delicate mien be made to faint,
- 'Twere better I should exercise restraint.
-
- Mind you, Act I, scene 4 drips the odd bit of gore here and there.
-
-
- MIA T:
- Thy bard's excessive predilection metaphorical
- confuseth redoubled sharp-edged entendre with one blunt oracle.
-
- Forsooth, thy bard surely knowth,
- Phallus on eunuch can't growth.
- Plucking capon from hen's an impossibility,
- Unless the cluck's hermaphroditic Hillary.
|
8
posted on
12/27/2005 10:21:35 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: Mia T
9
posted on
12/27/2005 10:25:50 AM PST
by
E.G.C.
To: Mia T
10
posted on
12/27/2005 10:29:31 AM PST
by
oldbrowser
(Release the Barrett Report)
To: Mia T
encyclopedia of American Presidents:
George H.W. Bush (40 pages)
Bill Clinton
Racked by scandals of his own making as well as others, President Clinton's administration left no enduring legacy.
George W. Bush (90 pages)
Clinton will be flanked by two war-time Presidents who are father and son. He won't be remembered.
To: E.G.C.
doug brinkley is both a whore and a pimp for slick willy. He definitely wants to be the monica lewinsky male replacement. There is nothing remotely objective about this wordsmith. A fairly good vocabulary does not make an "objective historian".
If the fbi checks, there would be plenty of bj's dna on brinkley's clothes. I puke on that phoney pos brinkley.
12
posted on
12/27/2005 10:33:07 AM PST
by
USS Alaska
(Nuke the terrorist savages - In Honor of Standing Wolf)
To: Mia T
DB: I think his successes were in welfare reform, economic discipline,trade pacts. Let's not forget Midnight Basketball!
ML/NJ
13
posted on
12/27/2005 10:39:05 AM PST
by
ml/nj
To: ml/nj
14
posted on
12/27/2005 10:50:26 AM PST
by
sgtyork
(If Osamma calls someone in the US, should the NSA hang up?)
To: sgtyork
15
posted on
12/27/2005 10:54:02 AM PST
by
Burlem
To: Burlem
AFTERWORD: ON CLINTON SMALLNESS-- Monica Lewinsky spoke????
16
posted on
12/27/2005 10:57:56 AM PST
by
bkwells
(Liberals=Hypocrites)
To: Vaquero
- Actually, the Peyronie's Disease saga actually segues well into the issue of clinton's obsession with his pathetic legacy.
On clinton Crookedness: a theory Mulligans, Peyronie's Disease and The First Rapist -
by Mia T -
-
- He made more of a fuss over a minor knee injury than FDR ever did about polio.
-
The Weekly Standard, Ask Not. . . -
- Now, as regards the wretched Cheapside brat,
- And turmoil his concupiscence begat,
- Methinks MacJeff's crook'd feelpolitik, the lasix death, his solipsistic sex
- Thou must put in cold blood'd cardiovascular context.
-
- The brain deviseth laws for the blood,
- but the brain 'tself is ne'er understood.
- The King's crook'dness flows from limp circulation.
- Methinks the solution is swift amputation.
Mia T, On Neutered and Neutering Mia T and Edward Zehr (EZ) |
 The evaluation of the treatments for Peyronie's disease is difficult; the natural history is such that the plaque may resolve spontaneously. As recently as 1973, no treatment had been evaluated in a controlled clinical study. Francois de LaPeyronie (1678-1747) notwithstanding, the origin of the eponym is vague and the disease remains an enigma. To this day, the treatment can be difficult. It is not surprising that so many treatments have been tried and so much dogma written. Indeed, in 1903, William Johnson Walsham, the famous surgeon from St Bartholomew's Hospital in London, and author of the standard surgical text book of the day, wrote; "... if treatment of the plaque with iodides is unsuccessful ... or if the induration progresses ... then the whole penis must be promptly amputated." Would that Dr. Walsham had treated The First Rapist. As we shall see, in a bizarre twist of knee--not fate--bill clinton seems to have suffered penile surgery, nonetheless.
- Note:
-
- Peyronie's disease occurs most frequently in middle-aged men, less frequently in older men and infrequently in younger men who have more elastic tissues.
- The acquired penile curvature of Peyronie's disease can result from certain sexual practices.
- Correction of congenital penile curvature -- or acquired penile curvature secondary to Peyronie's disease -- can be accomplished through a number of simple surgical techniques and medical treatments.
- Correction is difficult to detect but it is possible when done by an expert who is specifically looking for it.
- When the surgery is performed, the urologist's standard recommendation is that the patient USE CRUTCHES AND LATER A CANE to avoid irritating the area, which begs the following question:
-
- Was bill clinton the first U.S. President in history to obstruct justice by penile surgery?
-
- The First Rapist clearly understood that Jones v. clinton was on the docket.
- Being the most brilliant president ever, he must have figured out that any confirmation of the crookedness alleged by Jones would surely do him in.
-
- The documented serial shredder of documents and reflexive obstructor of justice would have, doubtless, thought nothing of a little evidentiary nip here and tuck there.
-
- But how to explain the time out for the surgery and the post-op crutches?
-
- Eureka! (Or we should say "Fore!"?) A knee injury--actual or feigned--would (if you'll pardon the expression) turn the trick.
-
NOTE: I would normally favor the former option--a real knee injury, as it would require one less doctor to be in on the felony obstruction (i.e., the urologist and not the orthopedic surgeon); but in this case we are dealing with a quintessential coward (one who is as cowardly about physical harm to himself as he is cavalier about physical harm to others--witness the rapes and the bombings), so I will have to go with the latter option, a feigned bum knee... Unless... unless the penile surgery was done "in-house" on an "outpatient" basis, i.e., unless the penile surgery in fact preceded "the accident," and the urologist was instructed to give The First Rapist's knee the requisite whack while the coward was under anesthesia.
Either scenario is consistent with The First Rapist's convenient "accident" at the estate of pro golfer, Greg Norman where, you may recall, Mulligan Man injured his "knee," required emergent surgery on said "knee" FORE!thwith...and used crutches and then a cane for an extended period post-op.
-
-
-
The happy couple:"Mission Accomplished"
|
-
-
Hauling him onto Air Force One
|
-
- Despite milking the wheelchair bit for all it was worth--or perhaps because of it--bill clinton emerged post-op more Larry Flynt
-
-
-
- than FDR.
-
-
-
- proving the propostition confirmed by the democrat debacle of '02, that maladroit, clintonian use of props and poses often backfires.
-
-
|
17
posted on
12/27/2005 11:02:14 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: sgtyork
18
posted on
12/27/2005 11:12:44 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: ml/nj
19
posted on
12/27/2005 11:13:10 AM PST
by
Mia T
To: TexanToTheCore
I disagree. As the consequences of the clinton years play out, as more information comes out, the clintons, I believe, will be increasingly reviled.
20
posted on
12/27/2005 11:20:03 AM PST
by
Mia T
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-55 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson