Posted on 12/01/2005 8:56:49 PM PST by DuckFan4ever
I am all for giving people a second chance to serve in the military. There are a lot of people in the past who had turned their lives around in just that way.
I don't think he will succeed in this quest. Luckily, there are lots of ways to serve your country. He will have to look down another path.
2) You can't enlist to be a SEAL.
She was a talented skater who came from a lower class background and was unprepared to deal with that world.
Man with much to prove and nothing to lose... Why not have Dirty Dozen units?
Yeah, the Seals are often called upon to beat up ice skaters.
The guy assaulted an innocent woman with a pipe. Why should he be in the military (not that there'd be a snowball's chance of him ever becoming a SEAL anyway)?
Agreed. He can do many other things useful to society such as volunteer his services for the incapicated victims that have lost limbs in the war.
Sh#%^&*! I think I have internal injuries from laughing so hard.
He can find other ways to serve. Hell, after I was medically disqualified from enlistment in the military I joined a fire department.
"Tonya Harding "
You can't put lipstick on a pig.
As for Stant he is a violent felon. Why would the Navy even want him?
Maybe not a Seal, but we could use him as one of the Dirty Dozen and send him after the terrorists.
I assume you feel the same way about Tookie?
Hey....do you know where I can purchase the NY Times bestseller book " I Tookie Ur Children"...??
Agreed on the second point. And, as you said, enlisting to be a SEAL is a nice goal for someone, but you have to get there on your merits, not your wants.
That said, I believe that the Military could be an option on a case by case basis for a subset of people who have run afoul the law. It is true that there were some people in the past who were given the choice of jail or the military, chose the military and did well. Granted, these were not murderers or rapists, but I would not advocate that anyway.
I would advocate a system where someone who has shown reliable evidence of reform (and not being of a certain class of criminal) being able to enlist under a probationary status on a case by case basis, where even the smallest infraction can result in immediate expulsion.
I agree with you. The man is sorry for what he did in his youth and I do feel he is entitled to redemption. If he wants to serve his country, I think a place should be found for him, somewhere.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.