Freeper Joanie-f review of "The Great Raid" and what we dare not foget from it

FR ^ | 13-Aug-2005 | Joanie-f

[Jeff Head]

As you probably already know, I am not a movie-goer – only set foot in a theater maybe once or twice a year, if that -- for three reasons: (1) most of the ‘stuff’ that passes for cinematic excellence these days is no more visually or intellectually rewarding than staring at road kill, (2) I cringe at the thought of lining the pockets of the politically-activist Hollywood left, and (3) I’d rather be biking. :)

With that disclaimer out of the way … Rick and I saw the just-released movie ‘The Great Raid’ last night. Knowing the shared love that you and I have for ‘Saving Private Ryan’ and ‘Band of Brothers’, I told myself that I must e-mail you this weekend and alert you to this new ‘greatest generation’ portrayal (so now a post here will do just as well, since you brought up the subject yourself. :)

Before telling you a little about the movie, let me first describe three reactions (two audience, and one personal) that may provide a clue as to its impact:

(1) I generally wear a headband in my hair (it’s long) to keep it out of my face. I took the headband off during the movie and was holding it in my hands. During one of the more emotionally wrenching scenes, I unconsciously broke it in half. :)

(2) The theater was about half full. When the daring POW rescue around which the story centers succeeded, and the American POWs and their rescuers walked/staggered/were carried through the camp gates, the audience erupted in applause and some cheers, accompanied by tears.

(3) When the story had ended, the credits began to roll, accompanied in the background by dozens of black-and-white photos of the actual POW camp survivors, their rescuers, and their welcome home to American soil. Hardly a person in the theater left until the credits and stream of photos were over. And, when we did leave, we all left in silence.

The movie is based on two books: ‘Ghost Soldiers’ (which I have read, and highly recommend) and ‘The Great Raid on Cabanatuan’ (which I intend to read now. :)

It is the story of what is said to be the most successful rescue mission in the history of the American military. It beautifully details how the 6th Ranger Battalion (comprised of an elite group of 121 men), accompanied by a large group of Filipino guerrillas, traveled thirty miles by foot, behind enemy lines (which numbered nearly 30,000 Japanese), in order to rescue the 511 remaining survivors of the Bataan Death March. Word had come back that the Japanese were torturing and brutally murdering American POWs rather than housing them until the end of the war. The plan was to rescue those survivors who represented the mere five percent who endured the unprecedented, sadistically barbaric Bataan march, and then three additional indescribably brutal, gruesome, macabre years in Camp Cabanatuan in the Philippines. Miraculously, 523 Japanese troops were killed or wounded during the raid, yet only two Americans and twenty-one Filipino guerillas were killed in the mission, with two dying afterwards of their wounds.

I won’t go into much more detail about the story (although it is extremely difficult not to want to share some of the more arresting and wrenching scenes) because I hope you will try to see the movie, and because I suspect that you are already painfully aware of the factual account of the brutality of the Bataan Death March, the inhumane conditions in the POW camp, and the details of the rescue itself.

‘The Great Raid’ portrays one extraordinarily moving chapter in the Pacific theater in the same way that ‘Saving Private Ryan’ does regarding D-Day and its aftermath in Europe. As a movie, ‘Saving Private Ryan’ may be somewhat more powerful, but the impact of this movie is significantly enhanced by the fact that it is not a fictional account. And it’s a shame that the magnificence and inspiring success of this raid, in the face of overwhelming odds, were eclipsed by subsequent events such as the liberation of Iwo Jima and the bombing of Hiroshima.

What made the deepest impression on me was the fact that the elite Ranger battalion was ordered on this mission, not because it in any way benefited the Allies in a militarily strategic way. It was simply a mission of mercy – a seemingly impossible, suicidal assignment: to traverse thirty miles, by foot, outnumbered by enemy troops in the area by a ratio of 100:1, and rescue and transport home the last of those who, three years earlier, had been abandoned when Macarthur was ordered to leave the Philippines. The mission was simply to bring home those last remaining 511 men who had endured a hell on earth the likes of which none of us can even imagine, and who had come to believe that their country had abandoned them.

The sadistic tactics of the Japanese army (beginning in one of the very first scenes, in which American POWs were herded into underground air raid shelters, into which gasoline tanks were then rolled and ignited – and any burning POW who ran from the conflagration was gunned down) eerily reminded me of many of the hauntingly brutal scenes in Jeremiah Denton’s Vietnam-era POW saga, ‘When Hell Was in Session’ or ‘The Hanoi Hilton’.

I have been repeating, again and again, here on the forum that I believe that one of the most powerful forces working to bring our republic to her knees is the fact that America arose from Christian roots, but much of the rest of the world doesn't share that foundation or its viewpoints. The genius of our founding fathers, and the grace and generous blessings of God, gave birth to our indispensable national belief that human life is precious, and must be treasured and preserved at all costs. To ignore the fact that that fundamental cultural belief is not shared by much of the rest of the world may one day prove to be the death of us.

We need only look at the brutal human atrocities portrayed in this film … and beyond: to Stalin’s Ukrainian starvation, the Holocaust, the Vietnam POW camps, the killing fields of Cambodia, Mao’s ‘cultural revolution’, North Korea’s purges and concentration camps, genocides in Armenia, Ethiopia, Turkey, Biafra, Rwanda, East Timor, Sudan … ad infinitum.

We need only look at comments such as this one, made recently by a high-ranking member of the Chinese Communist Party:

Whatever the case may be, we can only move forward fearlessly for the sake of our Party and state and our nation’s future, regardless of the hardships we have to face and the sacrifices we have to make. The population, even if more than half dies, can be reproduced. But if the Party falls, everything is gone, and forever gone!

And now, when ‘terrorists’ (such a nebulous term, when so many violent, bloodthirsty splinter groups are included under that massive umbrella) threaten to murder all humans who do not choose to believe as they do … now is the time when we must recognize, and defensively react to, the fact that life is not precious to the rulers of the majority of the global population … and those who knowingly elect to follow them.

Even more disturbing, and equally necessary to acknowledge, is the fact that life is not as precious to those of our countrymen who occupy the far left of the political spectrum as it is to the rest of us. And, because of their lowering of the bar as regards the sanctity of life, they are every bit as much enemies of this republic as are foreign ‘terrorists’.

Our ‘homegrown enemies’ defile life by their acceptance and support of partial birth abortion, convenient euthanasia, and the like.

As recent evidence of the fact that, in the mids of the far left, political power and the furtherance of political ideology places a reverence for life lower on a list of human priorities, consider the number of decisions (both overt and behind-the-scenes) made by our forty-second president, and his cohorts on the Hill and in the courts, that were either treasonous or short-sighted … many of which still put this entire nation and her people at risk. The most recent example of this atrocious behavior is the revelation that Clinton administration lawyers ordered military intelligence officials to keep under wraps, rather than sharing with the FBI, sensitive information they had discovered on Mohamed Atta, the instigator of the 9/11 attacks … and that Clinton and the mainstream media, yet today, are treating this abominable revelation as a non-story, in spite of the fact that that very directive might well have contributed to the loss of 3,000 American lives.

The extreme left also seeks to downplay (at best), or ignore (at worst), the human atrocities committed by our foreign enemies. We are no longer permitted to see photos of beheaded ‘infidels’, hear reports of kidnappings, tortures and mutilations, or re-witness innocent Americans jumping to their deaths from the conflagration that was once the World Trade Center. And the average American has very little, if any, real knowledge of the inconceivably gruesome structures and implements of torture and dismemberment our soldiers have unearthed since our liberation of Iraq. We are shielded from the human-on-human barbarism occurring in so many parts of the world. If you ask the average American ‘In how many countries do you believe torture, genocide and/or slavery are prevalent?’ I would imagine he couldn’t name more than one or two, when, in reality, there are dozens … and growing.

And our ‘homegrown enemies’ strategy is a double-barreled one. In addition to suppressing the fact that our belief in the sanctity of human life is not shared by much of the rest of the world, they also invariably seek out, or manufacture, examples of ‘American barbarism’ in an effort to prove that the wars in which we are involved are prosecuted on a more-or-less level moral playing field.

Just one of the more recent of countless examples: The behaviors of a few mental degenerates (whose incidence probably represents .001% of the population of this country) in the Abu Ghraib prison ‘scandal’ was plastered all over our (and the world’s) televisions for weeks on end … and it still merits mention now and then, when a ‘homegrown enemy’ seeks to paint the American conscience with the same brush stroke as the mindset of those who seek our destruction, and who value human life only to the degree that it suits their purposes or furthers their agenda.

Some of the most recent such ‘homegrown enemy’ utterances have come from Cindy Sheehan, in an address she gave at San Francisco State University:

'America has been killing people on this continent since it was started.'

'The biggest terrorist is George W. Bush.'

'The U.S. government a morally repugnant system.'

In just the past couple of weeks alone, Harry Belafonte, Jane Fonda, and Dick Gregory have echoed the same ludicrous types of accusations, and worse. Multiply those three leftist Hollywood types by several hundred. And then multiply that by the number of mindless followers such glib celebrities impress and you have an idea of the number of Americans who believe this country is every bit as evil as those who would destroy us.

The American republic isn’t without warts. Far from it. But our Christian roots, and Judeo/Christian view of life (yes, I happily plead guilty to unbridled, America-centric political incorrectness) places the American belief in the sanctity of life at odds with much of the rest of the world. And, falling prey to the efforts of our enemies within by allowing ourselves to be convinced that we are just as ruthless as our enemies, will prove deadly. It will dilute our vigilance. It will promote the ‘we are the world’ mindset that believes that all men are good, if only we are willing to sit at the same table with them, and treat them with dignity and respect.

The ‘greatest generation’ learned that significant lesson the hard way. And, by virtue of their integrity, courage, sense of duty, and love of country, they emerged victorious over power-hungry barbarians.

Now, six decades later, the power-hungry barbarians are wearing a new face, and are no longer concentrated in fairly easily definable areas on the globe. Some of them even live among us, in terrorist cells throughout the country. So, in some ways, we need to be more wary, more suspicious, and more vigilant than our heroes of the ‘40s were … because we are under attack on so many more fronts.

We must recognize that ‘their’ (our foreign and home-grown enemies’) assessment of the value of life is diametrically opposed to ours. And we must realize that they are forever attempting to camouflage that fact by either hiding or disguising their beliefs, or by deliberately distorting ours. If we don’t acknowledge that distinction, we will downplay the need for vigilance, and we will ultimately fail in our responsibility to step forward and fill the shoes of ‘the greatest generation’.

Reflecting on that distinction may prove uncomfortable.

Not doing so threatens our very survival.

[Diva Betsy Ross]

"But don't count on it winning any academy awards (which is all the more reason to see it..)"

I am with you Ms. Joanie. I am not known for my love of the Academy Awards either... *snicker*

[Clemenza]

Good review.

BTW: Do you STILL love Chachi?

[Jerez2]

Beautifully written. Thank you.
BTTT

[joanie-f]

No rational citizen capable of analytical thought can argue with your comments here.

But the bottom line is that scripture tells us that there will remain a faithful remnant (many of whom I believe are represented on this forum), and it may well be that, here in America, our future will rest on the continued existence of those who are grounded in a belief in, and a striving for, righteousness … and who will not allow their feet to be moved, no matter the chaos occurring around them.

If you care to read it, this is what I believe He expects of us now:

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/1124992/posts?page=716#716

Thank you for the very insightful comments.

~ joanie

[joanie-f]

Thank you!

[SuzanneC]

bump

[joanie-f]

I saw this movie this afternoon. There were tears and cheers during the movie and total silence leaving the theater. If this film doesn't move the movie-goer, then they have nothing to move.

Beautifully said.

[joanie-f]

I believe this film will rank among the all-time great war pictures, also one of the few films that isn't a let-down after reading the book (Ghost Soldiers).

I couldn't agree more. The only advantage the book has over the movie is that I believe the characters are more developed in the book. Other than that, the movie more than did the heroic story justice. A very rare feat indeed.

[Yasotay]

Side Note:

Col Bull Simons was one of the planners of "The Great Raid" .... he also staged the last successful "Great Raid" into Tehran, Iran ..... RLTW!!!

[joanie-f]

Never did love Chachi. That was just a vicious rumor manufactured by the Hollywood left. (Potsie had it all over him.)

[joanie-f]

Thanks for the kind comments.

[B4Ranch]

...but more importantly for the eloquent remarks about our nation and the lessons we must retain if we are to preserve our liberty and way of life, and if we are to ultimately survive as a people and as a culture.

Jeff, Since I joined FR, I have been posting about the illegal alien invasion which has now become an honest to goodness re-colonization of America.

Four states have changed so drastically that minorities now are in the majority. You say "if we are to ultimately survive as a people and as a culture." As a people, our nation, America is rapidly changing to North Americans instead of just good ole Americans. Our culture, thanks to the enforcement of the recent politically correct regulations and laws is almost gone. We are now a hyphenated nation of people who refuse to assimilate. We have so many different socialist cultures today that we resemble the United Nations more than a freedom loving people who once respected individual liberty and held our national sovereignty high with pride.

The world screams at us for having prisoners at Gitmo and our response is to release them! These prisoners have never held such a fine idea of what imprisonment can be in their minds. They know about beatings and whippings, blood splattered walls in the interrogation rooms. They understand what a mass burial is because they participated in them.

The just-released movie, 'The Great Raid' shows us what Americans once were. That was a time in our history when the President wouldn't dare opening our borders to illegal aliens because there would be an armed revolt at the first sign of selective law enforcement.

I think the days have gone past to where Americans could ultimately survive as a people and as a culture. Today our government encourages immigrants to maintain their culture. We celebrate diversity and multi-languages rather than unity. We encourage dual citizenships and promote divided loyalties. We are rapidly evolving into North Americans of a multiculturalist continent where national sovereignty is frowned upon. This social engineering process is being supported by both parties making it more difficult to determine who we should vote for.

Sure, there is a few of us who refuse to accept what we have allowed to happen to our once great nation but soon we too will die of old age and that debate will settle into past history. It will be another NON recorded vote with only very few present that sends us over the edge and erases America from existance. We will soon become another United Nations state rather than an independent country.

[B4Ranch]

"We must recognize that ‘their’ (our foreign and home-grown enemies’) assessment of the value of life is diametrically opposed to ours. And we must realize that they are forever attempting to camouflage that fact by either hiding or disguising their beliefs, or by deliberately distorting ours. If we don’t acknowledge that distinction, we will downplay the need for vigilance, and we will ultimately fail in our responsibility to step forward and fill the shoes of ‘the greatest generation’.

Reflecting on that distinction may prove uncomfortable.

Not doing so threatens our very survival."

joanie
Truer words were never spoken by anyone!

[joanie-f]

When you have the time, I urge you to also read this comment by Euro-American Scum, a fellow FReeper who is a Vietnam vet himself, and who made a personal pilgrimage to Normandy (and beyond) last year to pay homage to the those who served, and those who offered the ultimate sacrifice, for the commemoration of the 60th anniversary of D-Day. He adds an extraordinarily moving personal perspective to the entire noble ‘greatest generation’ saga:

a href=http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1461919/posts?page=56#56

And some beautifully-worded, probing questions posed by FReeper tet68:

Why does our country no longer recognize the rightousness of our ideology? Has our society been permeated by the insidious tendrils of the left for so long that our will to defend and spread our way of life and government has been completely subverted? It's a far cry from the country I grew up in.

What the socialists pray for, a major defeat of US forces, with hundreds taken captive, would come to be the petard which they hoist themselves. Those captives would not be afforded the protections of Geneva, how then would the left justify their support of the terrorists?

Both E-A-S and tet are Vietnam vets whose patriotism can never come into question. And they both have their fingers accurately placed on the pulse of this republic. Combining the impact of their own personal sacrifices, and their ability to extrpolate their hard-won insight, it would be wise to respect their reading of our republic's strengths, weaknesses, and future ... and their warnings that that future is precarious at best.

[Brad’s Gramma]

This sounds like I'm going to have to break my MANY year's long record of not having seen a movie!!

Thank you to all for the head's up.

[joanie-f]

Thank you.

[Jeff Head]

Thanks...but thank Joanie for the review...I just posted it.

[Don W]

A Freeper Foxhole BTTT!

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-vetscor/1460274/posts

[frannie]

I would have thought many freepers would have seen Ollie North's Sunday night show on this very rescue. He had some of the survivors and some actual film.

It starts with the surrender at Guadalcanal, goes through some of the Bataan Death March and ends up with the rescue.
It shows the welcome by the troops on their return to camp.

I understood that the rescuers were all volunteers.

If you haven't seen it, ALL should watch for it to be on and make a point of watching it. There are even some political statements that I found amazing. About WHO were expendable.

[Minuteman23]

Encore BTTT!