Why would you assume nobody crosses over? (Help us, we've been zotted!)

June 26, 2005

Guest Viewpoint: The party's over for betrayed Republican

I still believe in the vast power of markets to inspire ideas, motivate solutions and eliminate waste. I still believe in international vigilance and a strong defense, because this world will always be home to people who will avidly seek to take or destroy what we have built as a nation. I still believe in the protection of individuals and businesses from the influence and expense of an over-involved government. I still believe in the hand-in-hand concepts of separation of church and state and absolute freedom to worship, in the rights of the states to govern themselves without undo federal interference, and in the host of other things that defined me as a Republican.

My problem is this: I believe in principles and ideals which my party has systematically discarded in the last 10 years.

My Republican Party was the party of Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, Dwight Eisenhower, Barry Goldwater, and George H.W. Bush. It was a party of honesty and accountability. It was a party of tolerance, and practicality and honor. It was a party that faced facts and dealt with reality, and that crafted common-sense solutions to problems based on the facts as they were, not as we wished them to be, or even worse, as we made them up. It was a party that told the truth, even when the truth came hard. And now, it is none of those things.

Fifty years from now, the Republican Party of this era will be judged by how we provided for the nation's future on three core issues: how we led the world on the environment, how we minded the business of running our country in such a way that we didn't go bankrupt, and whether we gracefully accepted our place on the world's stage as its only superpower. Sadly, we have built the foundation for dismal failure on all three counts. And we've done it in such a way that we shouldn't be surprised if neither the American people nor the world ever trusts us again.

My party has repeatedly ignored, discarded and even invented science to suit its needs, most spectacularly as to global warming. We have an opportunity and the responsibility to lead the world on this issue, but instead we've chosen greed, shortsightedness and deliberate ignorance.

We have mortgaged the country's fiscal future in a way that no Democratic Congress or administration ever did, and to justify the tax cuts that brought us here, we've simply changed the rules. I matured as a Republican believing that uncontrolled deficit spending is harmful and irresponsible; I still do. But the party has yet to explain to me why it's a good thing now, other than to say "... because we say so."

Our greatest failure, though, has been in our role as superpower. This world needs justice, democracy and compassion, and as the keystone of those things, it needs one thing above all else: truth.

Republican decisions made in 2002 and 2003 have killed almost 2,000 of the most capable patriots our country has to offer - volunteers, every one. Support for those decisions was gathered through what appeared at the time to be spin and marketing, but which now turns out to have been deliberate planning and falsehood. The Blair government's internal documentation only confirms what has been suspected for years: Americans are dying every day for Republican lies first crafted in 2002, expanded and embellished upon in 2003, and which continue to this day. This calculated deception is now burned into the legacy of the party, every bit as much as Reagan's triumph in the Cold War, or Nixon's disgrace over Watergate.

I could go on and on - about how we have compromised our international integrity by sanctioning torture, about how we are systematically dismantling the civil liberties that it took us two centuries to define and preserve, and about how we have substituted bullying, brinksmanship and "staying on message" for real political discourse - but those three issues are enough.

While it has compiled this record of failure and deception, the party which I'm leaving today has spent its time, energy and political capital trying to save Terri Schiavo, battling the threat of single-sex unions, fighting medical marijuana and physician-assisted suicide, manufacturing political crises over presidential nominees, and selling privatized Social Security to an America that isn't buying. We fiddle while Rome burns.

James Chaney is a Eugene attorney who has been in private practice for more than 20 years, and who has been a registered Republican since 1980.

Just curious, are any of them socially conservative?

I'm not personally acquainted with every single Republican who went over to the Dark Side, but the ones I am acquainted with who felt strongly enough to take out an anti-Bush ad last fall are quite socially conservative. They're folks who have previously followed a perfectly straight party line for many years--you know, low taxes, strong defense, individual responsibility and independence, limiting government, cutting spending on social causes, ending abortion, etc.

I don't understand it and don't support it at all.

FYI, here is a partial, off-the-top-of-the-head list. It's far from complete. My recollection is that there was a large ad signed by scores and scores of Republicans who had served in previous administrations in management positions.

Elmer L. Andersen, former Republican Governor of Minnesota (1961-63)
Dr. Timothy Ashby, director, Office of Mexico and the Caribbean, U.S. Commerce Department under Reagan and Bush I
Jack Bogle Founder of the Vanguard Mutual Fund
David Catania, Republican Councilman from Washington, D.C.
Steve Chapman, conservative syndicated columnist, Chicago Tribune
Mike Cobb, former Republican Mayor of Palo Alto, California
George Comstock, Mayor of Portola Valley, California --
Marlow Cook, former Republican Senator from Kentucky
Comer Cottrell, longtime Republican, Bush ally, and old baseball partner
David Durenberger, former Senator from Minnesota (1978-95) (endorsing Kerry health plan over Bush's)
John Eisenhower, son of former Republican President Dwight D. Eisenhower
John A. Galbraith, former Republican Ohio General Assemblyman
Peter Gillette, former Republican Commissioner of Trade for Minnesota (1991-95)
Lee Iacocca, former Chrysler Chairman
Anne Morton Kimberly, widow of Rogers C.B. Morton, former Republican Representative from Maryland
Steve May, former Republican state legislator from Arizona
Pete McCloskey, former Republican Representative from California
Scott McConnell, executive editor, The American Conservative
Al Meiklejohn, former Republican state senator from Colorado
Ballard Morton, son of Thruston Morton, former Republican Senator from Kentucky
Clay Myers, Republican Secretary of State (1967-77) and State Treasurer (1977-84) for Oregon
Clyde Prestowitz, counselor to Ronald Reagan's Secretary of Commerce
Rick Russman, former Republican State Senator from New Hampshire
William Milliken, former Republican Governor of Michigan (1969-82)
Charley Reese, conservative columnist/journalist, Orlando Sentinel (1971-2001)
Bill Rutherford, former Treasurer of Oregon and Chair of the Oregon Investment Council
Richard Schmalensee, former Council of Economic Advisers member for President George H. W. Bush
Jon Silver, former Republican Mayor of Portola Valley, California
Gail Slocum, former Republican Mayor of Menlo Park, California
Bob Smith, retired Republican Senator from New Hampshire
Russell E. Train, EPA chief under Richard Nixon and Gerald Ford
Jude Wanniski, former associate editor of The Wall Street Journal, coined term "supply side economics"
Marshall Wittmann, former communications director to Arizona Republican Senator John McCain

Mind, I'm not with these people. I think they're misguided. Just for the record, though, there they are. There are a lot more.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.